This should be easy to try here. Unlike roundabouts, there is zero construction required, you just turn off the lights. This makes it a 4 way stop which we are supposed to assume when the lights go out anyway. And if it is not better, you just turn the lights back on!
The issue in a densely populated area like downtown is pedestrians. I cannot see this working where there is a constant stream of them. At least lights bunch them up so they cross 30 at a time, all at once.
I hope they try it around here. Of course, we can already see how this works....... at existing busy 4 way stops.