slip and fall injury

westendman

Active member
Jan 8, 2009
499
83
28
Last Thursday I slipped on an ice covered sidewalk and broke my ankle does anyone have experience with injury lawyers. If I'm not mistaken cleaning the snow and ice of a sidewalk is the home owners responsibility. I'm in a cast for 7 weeks and with physo I will be out of work for 3 months. EI only pays a little, not enough to cover bills. So what I'm wondering is approximatly how much can I expect to get from a suit against the home owner that never to bothered to shovel the side walk in front of his house.
 
I guess you must have hit your head as well and suffered injury. Because if you didn't the obvious answer would be to contact a PERSONAL INJURY LAWYER.

There's a new thing called the Interweb, and on it exist little known tools called search engines. Rumour has it if you type in "Toronto Personal Injury Lawyers" they give you a fairly accurate list of what you are searching for. My guess is that some may even offer a free consultation to answer the very question you have.
 
I'm going to call a lawyer on Monday morning. I was just looking for some info from someone who has experienced this before.
 
I'm going to call a lawyer on Monday morning. I was just looking for some info from someone who has experienced this before.
With all due respect, wasn't there a bad storm recently that left much of southern Ontario under a thick sheet of SLIPPERY ice? So much in fact that the majority of trees were damaged.
It does suck that you slipped on ice that was EVERYWHERE, and had the bad luck to break your ankle.
So why is it someone else's fault?
Why is no one responsible for their own missteps any more?
BTW, I'm not a doctor, but you probably won't be out of commission for 3 months unless you have underlying medical issues or just want to milk this thing out.
Good luck mending
 
I have noticed an dramatic uptick in the number of advertisements for Personal Injury lawyers in Toronto, and correspondingly a large number of claims for motor vehicle accidents and associated injuries. In my line of work, I must forward documents as requested to these lawyers, presumably to aid in their claims of injury, pain & suffering, long term disability, etc.

There are a plethora of choices now but I'm personally saddened that it has come to this. I've always admired Canada for the fact that places like "Celino and Barnes" didn't become mainstream (this firm is well known in Buffalo NY, where they advertise like crazy on TV and billboards you'll see everywhere). We seem to be following suit, as now I've seen ads for "Diamond and Diamond" here now. Pretty soon, we'll all start seeing our insurance premiums go up, not just b/c of the ice storm damages, but b/c of these personal injury claims increasingly becoming more common. I esp. despise the MVA claims, since i personally know a few bogus incidents and the fraud that is associated, with the doctors, lawyers, physio and rehab etc that comes with it.

OP i do sincerely hope you get better soon. You are now caught in the cycle of this personal injury vortex machine. Please tread carefully - everyone who owns a house knows the rules that snow and ice should be cleared, but then again everyone who walks and has eyes knows that in an ice storm, everything is slippery too. Clearing ice was not an easy task last week, I used two bags of salt and had to go to two different stores to find some at that. They were sold out.
 
It's Canada. It's winter. There is going to be ice!

If you were wearing quality snow boots with good ankle support this wouldn't have happened. If there was an environment Canada weather warning in effect you should have been careful.

It's too bad you broke your ankle, but if there is any possibility of you getting money from whatever old lady owns that house, we need legislation to stop it.
 
If it's a city sidewalk, the homeowner's liability could be very limited. I believe there were some cases in the past which resulted such that that while Toronto could fine homeowners for not clearing their sidewalks, this did not pass liability onto the homeowner. Toronto expanded it's mechanized sidewalk clearing program in large parts of the city as a result; it was cheaper to clear the sidewalks themselves rather than pay all the lawsuits.

This is by memory only though.
 
Google is my friend...

http://aaron.ca/columns/2000-12-14.htm

Under the Municipal Act, Ontario municipalities have a duty to remove snow and ice from sidewalks and are responsible for breaching that duty. When Vaughan got sued, it denied responsibility and added the Mangiapanes to the lawsuit, claiming they were in violation of a bylaw requiring owners to clear snow from the sidewalks next to their properties.

The Mangiapanes objected to being named defendants and asked the court to dismiss the claim against them. As grounds for their application, they argued that a simple breach of the bylaw did not impose civil responsibility on them for any resulting damages.

The lower court judge tossed out the claim against the property owners, and the Court of Appeal agreed. It said there is no common-law duty on a property owner to clear snow and ice from public sidewalks adjacent to the property.

By law, the snow and ice are the legal responsibility of the municipality, not the adjacent property owner. There are two exceptions to this general rule.

First, a property owner may be responsible as an occupier of a sidewalk if the owner assumes control of the area - for example, a boulevard eating area in front of a coffee shop or a sidewalk fruit stall in front of a grocery store.

The second exception is that property owners have a duty of care to make sure nothing flows off the property that could injure persons on the sidewalk.


http://www.moodiemair.com/blog/slippery-sidewalk-eh-better-watch-your-step/
 
Before you see dollar signs in your eyes, remember,you are in Canada, not the US. If you proceed with legal action, due to the circumstances f last week, your case will be split into two parts. Direct and indirect damages. In the case of direct damages you will be awarded the difference between EI and your salary plus any out of pocket medical expenses (anything not paid by your OHIP and insurance). If you make $1400 per week and EI pays $400 you are looking at $12,000. The lawyer will take $4000 plus HST. The indirect damages could take years and unless there was intent are hard to get. Under this scenario.
From the Law firms perspective, they will have to prepare paperwork, pay for medical exams etc. and perform various other administrative duties. $4000 in fees will be eaten up very quickly so a lot of firms like Diamond and Diamond will not take on cases that are so small. ( they will refer you though)
 
Do you have anything called proof. Did the ambulance pick you up there, any video evidence of you slipping where you said you slipped, anyone see you fall. You can say you fell there, the homeowner said `no you didn`t`, then what.

Here`s what I hope happens, you take them to court, you lose, then you pay yours and their lawyers fees. Good luck with that 2000$ retainer.
 
Here`s what I hope happens, you take them to court, you lose, then you pay yours and their lawyers fees.
Which is why you have an initial consultation (typically free) with a Tort Lawyer who assesses with you the likelihood of your claim being successful at trial.
 
IMHO, get the best lawyer. Most likely the other side will settle out of court.

I'm not a lawyer but this is what I would do if the owners did not clear the snow within 24 hours
 
Which is why you have an initial consultation (typically free) with a Tort Lawyer who assesses with you the likelihood of your claim being successful at trial.

I don't think that is the norm anymore, too much wasted time for the lawyers on petty bullshit stuff like this. What happens when the lawyer askd the op; "you saw it was unshovelled and icy yet continued to walk over it, why didn't you take an alternate route?" or "You knew there was an ice storm and that conditions were bad, why didn't you have spikes on your boots that are available at many stores?" In other words, what did you do to prevent the fall?

With many court decisions there is a %age of blame for each person I believe.
 
If you were wearing quality snow boots with good ankle support this wouldn't have happened.
My heart always skips a beat whenever I see an elderly or physically challenged person (some with canes and walkers) on our icy snowy sidewalks. If they fall and break a hip, that could be a negative life changing event.
 
Few points made. Like to add also exigent circumstances. If the home owner was not around due to electrical outage then they likely excused due to such unusual & extreme circumstances.
 
I'm going to call a lawyer on Monday morning. I was just looking for some info from someone who has experienced this before.
I am sorry for being sarcastic. However, really a lawyer is the best person to answer your questions. Just wait another 8-10 hours to get your question answered. Some websites I googled even have on-line forms to fill-in.

I get a sense your case is straight-forward and a lawyer can tell you in 2-5 minutes if you have a chance and how much you could receive.

As pointed-out above, you better have proof of where you fell. Did you take any pictures? I am assuming that if you broke your ankle you called an ambulance where you fell...