Should we keep the Queen?

Should we keep the Queen?

  • Yes

    Votes: 38 40.4%
  • No

    Votes: 50 53.2%
  • Yes but in a different form

    Votes: 4 4.3%
  • Undecided

    Votes: 2 2.1%

  • Total voters
    94
The Spanish Habsburgs died out due to inbreeding.
Save for the past century and a quarter, the Spanish Bourbon's were not a great deal better. It is not the inbreeding, it is continuous inbreeding. That has never been a problem with our Royal Family.
 
We have Rob Ford and Harper as our leaders and you have a problem with the Queen??? !! WTF...
 
She is not Canadian...our head of state needs to be. If we are to be an independent nation we need to create our own symbols and leaders, not import them part time from another country.
Cutting the monarchy would be good for Canadian unity because the french have no love for her, yet we ask them to swear allegiance to her? Dumb.
 
She is not Canadian...our head of state needs to be. If we are to be an independent nation we need to create our own symbols and leaders, not import them part time from another country.
Cutting the monarchy would be good for Canadian unity because the french have no love for her, yet we ask them to swear allegiance to her? Dumb.

I would rather swear alligence to the queen then harpo
 
She is not Canadian...our head of state needs to be. If we are to be an independent nation we need to create our own symbols and leaders, not import them part time from another country.
Cutting the monarchy would be good for Canadian unity because the french have no love for her, yet we ask them to swear allegiance to her? Dumb.


Since Canada is a constitutional monarchy, are you suggesting a Canadian monarch?
 
But get outside the GTA and things change to a more traditional Canadian society with strong ties to Britain and Canadian history and those people would never agree with any such notion of opting out of the British Commonwealth. It would be denying our Canadian heritage.

thats an interesting yet somewhat archaic stereotype...hmmmmmmmmm outside the GTA....you mean like Quebec, or say Alberta or BC?????? or how about our Aboriginal Canadians out on their various reserves???
 
thats an interesting yet somewhat archaic stereotype...hmmmmmmmmm outside the GTA....you mean like Quebec, or say Alberta or BC?????? or how about our Aboriginal Canadians out on their various reserves???

Actually many of the bands hold the Crown in high regard, realizing it basically stays out of the fray and is certainly more trusted than the boys and girls on the hill, but you knew that.
 
thats an interesting yet somewhat archaic stereotype...hmmmmmmmmm outside the GTA....you mean like Quebec, or say Alberta or BC?????? or how about our Aboriginal Canadians out on their various reserves???

I've been everywhere in Canada. My work takes me from Windsor to Hay River, from Lab City to Prince Rupert to Thompson Manitoba, to Grand Mere Quebec.

I've been there.

Sure, Quebec is an exception, but Canada is more about Cochrane Ontario (been there too) than it is Toronto and most of Canada (other than Quebec) would want to keep the monarchy (IMHO).
 
I've been everywhere in Canada. My work takes me from Windsor to Hay River, from Lab City to Prince Rupert to Thompson Manitoba, to Grand Mere Quebec.

I've been there.

Sure, Quebec is an exception, but Canada is more about Cochrane Ontario (been there too) than it is Toronto and most of Canada (other than Quebec) would want to keep the monarchy (IMHO).

I've been everywhere in Canada too and I don't recall anyone ever mentioning the queen.
 
you're welcome ;)

I'd love to know how many of the 48 (so far) NO voters are actually British. It's like asking non catholics if catholics should keep the Pope. Isn't it?

Not quite.
The question is whether Canada should keep the monarchy, not Britain.

I think it's a divisive force here, something to stick it to Quebec - maybe that's a good thing though. :eyebrows:
 
was it? So the "we" in the title refers to Canadians? Thank you for clarifying. Ok maybe I shouldn't have voted then LoL
I assumed he meant Canada because that's where we are, but you're right - he could be referring to the whole Commonwealth.
Of course you should have voted, you have an opinion.