Should we keep the Queen?

Should we keep the Queen?

  • Yes

    Votes: 38 40.4%
  • No

    Votes: 50 53.2%
  • Yes but in a different form

    Votes: 4 4.3%
  • Undecided

    Votes: 2 2.1%

  • Total voters
    94
If the Queen / Gov-Gen were not head of state, someone else would be. Who would you want that someone to be?

Or rather, how do you want that person to be selected? An appointment by the prime minister? By general election? Do you want that person to be a recognizable and incontestable figurehead, who embodies and establishes the state? Should the head of state have political power? Better still - what provision should there be for the head of state to be changed?

If the Queen and the monarchy didn't exist as it does at present, it would be impossible to create it. But here they are.

The history of kings and queens and heads of state around the world is not pleasant to contemplate, and is relevant to the question, who else would we have? The question is, given the Queen, and the institution of the British monarchy, as it exists at present, what would be better?

The question "Should we keep the Queen?" is rather meaningless in the absence of the alternatives. Like asking, "Should we keep the income tax?"
 
Charles is a jerk. The Royal Family are hoping to find a way to skip him, and are plainly investing a fortune in a PR campaign grooming William as the real successor. Plainly they hope Charles will not be long on the throne as they expect his reign will diminish support for the monarchy.

I really don't care about the monarchy but I agree with you about Charles. If he had half a brain he would step down and let William take his place but his ugly wife wants to be queen so she probably won't let him do that.
 
But get outside the GTA and things change to a more traditional Canadian society with strong ties to Britain and Canadian history and those people would never agree with any such notion of opting out of the British Commonwealth. It would be denying our Canadian heritage.
My observation is that you are absolutely correct in stating the above.

I always find it interesting how Toronto truly believes that it is Canada when it is the outlier to much of the rest of the Province let alone the Country.
 
If the Queen / Gov-Gen were not head of state, someone else would be. Who would you want that someone to be?

Or rather, how do you want that person to be selected? An appointment by the prime minister? By general election? Do you want that person to be a recognizable and incontestable figurehead, who embodies and establishes the state? Should the head of state have political power? Better still - what provision should there be for the head of state to be changed?

If the Queen and the monarchy didn't exist as it does at present, it would be impossible to create it. But here they are.

The history of kings and queens and heads of state around the world is not pleasant to contemplate, and is relevant to the question, who else would we have? The question is, given the Queen, and the institution of the British monarchy, as it exists at present, what would be better?

The question "Should we keep the Queen?" is rather meaningless in the absence of the alternatives. Like asking, "Should we keep the income tax?"


how about having no head of state? we have a prime minister. what more do we need really?
 
QEII only costs Canadian Taxpayers when she visits Canada as tradition dictates that we pick up the tab for her travelling costs.

Other than that, the Canadian Taxpayers don't contribute towards the cost of the Monarchy.

There's a lovely house up in Ottawa called Rideau Hall that costs taxpayers plenty. Not to mention that scandal a few years ago when Adrienne Clarkson was nice enough to bill us $500,000 for business services even after she stepped down as Governor General.

If you live in the UK though, God Save the Queen and keep those tourists dollars coming:


Maybe we should move Buckingham Palace and Queenie over here so we can cash in. Or turn Rideau Hall into a casino?!
 
magna cartaMagna Carta (Latin for Great Charter),[SUP][1][/SUP] also called Magna Carta Libertatum or The Great Charter of the Liberties of England, is an Angevin charter originally issued in Latin in the year 1215.
Magna Carta was the first document forced onto a King of England by a group of his subjects, the feudal barons, in an attempt to limit his powers by law and protect their privileges.
The charter was an important part of the extensive historical process that led to the rule of constitutional law in the English speaking world. Magna Carta was important in the colonization of American colonies as England's legal system was used as a model for many of the colonies as they were developing their own legal systems.
The 1215 charter required King John of England to proclaim certain liberties and accept that his will was not arbitrary—for example by explicitly accepting that no "freeman" (in the sense of non-serf) could be punished except through the law of the land, a right that still exists.
It was preceded and directly influenced by the Charter of Liberties in 1100, in which King Henry I had specified particular areas wherein his powers would be limited.
It was translated into vernacular French as early as 1219,[SUP][2][/SUP] and reissued later in the 13th century in modified versions. The later versions excluded the most direct challenges to the monarch's authority that had been present in the 1215 charter. The charter first passed into law in 1225; the 1297 version, with the long title (originally in Latin) "The Great Charter of the Liberties of England, and of the Liberties of the Forest," still remains on the statute books of England and Wales.
Despite its recognised importance, by the second half of the 19th century nearly all of its clauses had been repealed in their original form. Three clauses currently remain part of the law of England and Wales, however, and it is generally considered part of the uncodified constitution. Lord Denning described it as "the greatest constitutional document of all times – the foundation of the freedom of the individual against the arbitrary authority of the despot".[SUP][3][/SUP] In a 2005 speech, Lord Woolf described it as "first of a series of instruments that now are recognised as having a special constitutional status",[SUP][4][/SUP] the others being the Habeas Corpus Act (1679), the Petition of Right (1628), the Bill of Rights (1689), and the Act of Settlement (1701).
It was Magna Carta, over other early concessions by the monarch, which survived to become a "sacred text".[SUP][5][/SUP] In practice, Magna Carta in the medieval period did not generally limit the power of kings, but by the time of the English Civil War it had become an important symbol for those who wished to show that the King was bound by the law. It influenced the early settlers in New England[SUP][6][/SUP] and inspired later constitutional documents, including the United States Constitution.[SUP][7][/SUP]

thanks for the interesting read

it seems to me the magna carta was to give rights to the English feudal barony and that no "freeman" (non-Serf) could be punished except through the Law


it was not a democracy for the people and was meant to continue oppression of the masses

that it inspired later constitutional documents, including the United States Constitution, was not by design but by circumstance



the nobility the magna carta created was always very reluctant to give up its powers as in the English Revolution of 1640.

The state was essentially feudal and was violently overthrown, power passed into the hands of a new class, and so the freer development of capitalism was made possible. The Civil War was a class war, in which the despotism of Charles I was defended by the established Church and conservative landlords.

Parliament beat the King because it could appeal to the enthusiastic support of the trading and industrial classes in town and countryside, to the yeomen and progressive gentry, and to wider masses of the population whenever they were able by free discussion to understand what the struggle was really about.
 
If the Queen / Gov-Gen were not head of state, someone else would be. Who would you want that someone to be?

Or rather, how do you want that person to be selected? An appointment by the prime minister? By general election? Do you want that person to be a recognizable and incontestable figurehead, who embodies and establishes the state? Should the head of state have political power? Better still - what provision should there be for the head of state to be changed?

If the Queen and the monarchy didn't exist as it does at present, it would be impossible to create it. But here they are.

The history of kings and queens and heads of state around the world is not pleasant to contemplate, and is relevant to the question, who else would we have? The question is, given the Queen, and the institution of the British monarchy, as it exists at present, what would be better?

The question "Should we keep the Queen?" is rather meaningless in the absence of the alternatives. Like asking, "Should we keep the income tax?"

These questions have been resolved by the Germans, French, italians, and Greeks, all of whom were once part of some monarchical political system. Why assume as well that an alternative to our present non-system might actually work worse? Monarchists always use the old canard that why tempt fate, or mess with something that has fulfilled its role up to the present time. The answer: because symbols matter...a lot, and that it could be viewed as an opportunity to pursue a process of political maturation in this country. I don't for a minute think a change of this magnitude will or should be concluded quickly. Anyhow, I'm done with this topic. It's a shame that Canada is a very immature place in many ways.
 
There's a lovely house up in Ottawa called Rideau Hall that costs taxpayers plenty. Not to mention that scandal a few years ago when Adrienne Clarkson was nice enough to bill us $500,000 for business services even after she stepped down as Governor General.

If you live in the UK though, God Save the Queen and keep those tourists dollars coming:

Maybe we should move Buckingham Palace and Queenie over here so we can cash in. Or turn Rideau Hall into a casino?!

Yes, however, in Post No. 5 I quoted Azprint and here is what he said:

And to some she represents a useless figure, that outlived its purpose a very long time ago, while still costing a hefty sum of money to taxpayers.

The implication of the word "SHE" is Queen Elizabeth II, and Queen Elizabeth II does not cost the Canadian Taxpayers a dime unless she visits Canada. This is a fact - look it up yourself. A great many uniformed and ignorant believe that Canadian Tax dollars go to support the Queen. This is not the case. (I had an argument one time with a Serbian guy who was convinced that for every $20.00 bill out there with the Queen's face on it we had to pay QE2 5 cents. Absurdity never sleeps.

I was not referring to the Governor General, or Rideau Hall (and I'm not going to get worked up about 500k either).

As far as I'm concerned, they could ditch the office of the Governor General and all the associated infrastructure, but maintain the Queen as the Head of State in Canada.
 
Your supposed point seems to fall on it's head!

The Spanish Habsburgs died out due to inbreeding. Charles II, the last Habsburg King of Spain was a mongoloid. After the bitter lesson of 1529, the Austrian Habsburgs formed alliances through marriage. Bringing Flemish, Bavarian, Polish and Hungarian blood into the mix. They have survived to the present day.

As for elected royalty it worked perfectly for the Byzantine Empire for over a Millenium. Leo III, who repelled the Arab siege of Constantinople started life as a donkey herder.

As for Royalty in general, there's is a reason why France's most important holiday is Bastille Day.
 
I like having the monarchy. It's a tradition and Queen Elizabeth can trace her roots back to Ethelred the Unready. What a lineage! I realize that her role isn't that important anymore but I like the tradition of it.
 
The Spanish Habsburgs died out due to inbreeding. Charles II, the last Habsburg King of Spain was a mongoloid. After the bitter lesson of 1529, the Austrian Habsburgs formed alliances through marriage. Bringing Flemish, Bavarian, Polish and Hungarian blood into the mix. They have survived to the present day.

As for elected royalty it worked perfectly for the Byzantine Empire for over a Millenium. Leo III, who repelled the Arab siege of Constantinople started life as a donkey herder.

As for Royalty in general, there's is a reason why France's most important holiday is Bastille Day.

and how old do you think the British monarchy is?
 
My oddball opinion is royalty should be voted in.

It should be an honorary position and its job should be to represent its people at its finest with charity work and an immaculate public display of what it means to represent the people of the Empire.


I do not understand the concept of bloodlines being important.


That's essentially what we have in the Governor General within Canada. Here is a definition from Wikipedia for the role...

she(the Queen - my inclusion), on the advice of her Canadian prime minister only, appoints the governor general to carry out most of her constitutional and ceremonial duties for an unfixed period of time—known as serving at Her Majesty's pleasure—though five years is the normal convention. Beginning in 1959, it is also traditional to rotate between anglophone and francophone incumbents. Once in office, the governor general maintains direct contact with the Queen, wherever she may be at the time.
 
I'm in favour of letting the current Queen reign and pulling the plug on the institution when she dies. In the interim her portrait could be removed from banknotes, coins, stamps, and the "Royal" prefix dropped from everything.
 
If the Queen / Gov-Gen were not head of state, someone else would be. Who would you want that someone to be?

Or rather, how do you want that person to be selected? An appointment by the prime minister? By general election? Do you want that person to be a recognizable and incontestable figurehead, who embodies and establishes the state? Should the head of state have political power? Better still - what provision should there be for the head of state to be changed?

If the Queen and the monarchy didn't exist as it does at present, it would be impossible to create it. But here they are.

The history of kings and queens and heads of state around the world is not pleasant to contemplate, and is relevant to the question, who else would we have? The question is, given the Queen, and the institution of the British monarchy, as it exists at present, what would be better?

The question "Should we keep the Queen?" is rather meaningless in the absence of the alternatives. Like asking, "Should we keep the income tax?"

There are many alternatives, most of which are far more rational and defensible than having our head of state predetermined to be the first male to exit the womb of some woman overseas.
 
Yes, however, in Post No. 5 I quoted Azprint and here is what he said:



The implication of the word "SHE" is Queen Elizabeth II, and Queen Elizabeth II does not cost the Canadian Taxpayers a dime unless she visits Canada. This is a fact - look it up yourself. A great many uniformed and ignorant believe that Canadian Tax dollars go to support the Queen. This is not the case. (I had an argument one time with a Serbian guy who was convinced that for every $20.00 bill out there with the Queen's face on it we had to pay QE2 5 cents. Absurdity never sleeps.

I was not referring to the Governor General, or Rideau Hall (and I'm not going to get worked up about 500k either).

As far as I'm concerned, they could ditch the office of the Governor General and all the associated infrastructure, but maintain the Queen as the Head of State in Canada.

I never said we're sending tax dollars directly to Queenie. On the other hand, the Governor General and Lieutenant Governor do have costs attached to them without providing much other than ceremonial value. $500K might not be much, but it is still money being spent on frivolous things. So I agree with you then the offices of Governor General and Lieutenant Governor are of dubious value.

Having the Queen as Canada's Head of State is fine and it's fair that some of her costs are covered while she's here (at least the security costs.)
 
To some she represents oppression - the oppression of nobility over the working class and the oppression of the development of a truly democratic society.

Anyone who finds that the Queen represents oppression has it completely backwards: while it is true that the Monarchy (in effect, the Office of The Queen, but not actually the Queen herself) holds all actual governmental authority - the power to tax, to spend tax dollars, to direct the military - the Queen is bound to the advice of her First Minister. The Crown is subjugated to the people.

That is, it is the Prime Minister (or, in the case of the Provinces, the corresponding Premiers) who holds the power. The Queen has no authority to act on her own except in the awarding of certain Royal Honours.

The Governor-General, as the Queen's Representative in Canada, exercises the Queen's authority on her behalf, but again is bound to the advice of the PM in all matters.

When people talk about "Reserve Powers" of the Crown, they are referring to authority exercised on the advice of the PM which is not bound by the legislature, and is contrasted with spending authority - which, while advised by the Ministry, is subject to the prior approval of the House of Commons (and the Senate, although as an unelected body they are not permitted to initiate any spending bills).

And as the previous discussion suggested, the idea of the Crown being made subject to the People is generally credited to Magna Carta and the fields at Runnymede: the green in the House of Commons is meant to be reminiscent of the fields at Runnymede to emphasize that it is The People's House and is contrasted with the Royal Red in the Upper Chamber representing the Lords appointed to govern by the Crown.

To change our political system not only raises the simple questions of how one would go about selecting the successor, but more important questions of what political authority they would hold: electing a President and then binding them to the advice of the Prime Minister would not be acceptable to many.