If the Queen / Gov-Gen were not head of state, someone else would be. Who would you want that someone to be?
Or rather, how do you want that person to be selected? An appointment by the prime minister? By general election? Do you want that person to be a recognizable and incontestable figurehead, who embodies and establishes the state? Should the head of state have political power? Better still - what provision should there be for the head of state to be changed?
If the Queen and the monarchy didn't exist as it does at present, it would be impossible to create it. But here they are.
The history of kings and queens and heads of state around the world is not pleasant to contemplate, and is relevant to the question, who else would we have? The question is, given the Queen, and the institution of the British monarchy, as it exists at present, what would be better?
The question "Should we keep the Queen?" is rather meaningless in the absence of the alternatives. Like asking, "Should we keep the income tax?"
Or rather, how do you want that person to be selected? An appointment by the prime minister? By general election? Do you want that person to be a recognizable and incontestable figurehead, who embodies and establishes the state? Should the head of state have political power? Better still - what provision should there be for the head of state to be changed?
If the Queen and the monarchy didn't exist as it does at present, it would be impossible to create it. But here they are.
The history of kings and queens and heads of state around the world is not pleasant to contemplate, and is relevant to the question, who else would we have? The question is, given the Queen, and the institution of the British monarchy, as it exists at present, what would be better?
The question "Should we keep the Queen?" is rather meaningless in the absence of the alternatives. Like asking, "Should we keep the income tax?"

