Should we keep the Queen?

Should we keep the Queen?

  • Yes

    Votes: 38 40.4%
  • No

    Votes: 50 53.2%
  • Yes but in a different form

    Votes: 4 4.3%
  • Undecided

    Votes: 2 2.1%

  • Total voters
    94
They dont cost the country as much as they bring in tourism, and the charities they provide and support. In a way its like a business they get a salary and the money bring into the country is huge.
 
I'm quite familiar with Hapsburg legacy, yet it wasn't unique to the Royals, or Upper Class society through history. There are a couple of members who could school you quite well on the ins and out of their lineage better than I.

As for your vote there are a number of members, not I, who would strongly argue against him, labeling him a hypocrite, charlatan, phony. Good luck with it.

my point is nobility bloodlines are self serving and usually political in nature

hardly designed to create a superior race
 
They dont cost the country as much as they bring in tourism, and the charities they provide and support. In a way its like a business they get a salary and the money bring into the country is huge.

Ignorant Sheeple.

If most people did their homework, they will find the astronomical deaths, rapes, pillaging, blood, etc., that these 'tourist attractions' have caused.
 
my point is nobility bloodlines are self serving and usually political in nature

hardly designed to create a superior race

I said nothing about a superior race and do realize some/many marriages in the Royals are political, more so in the past, but political marriages aren't unique to Royals.
 
Ignorant Sheeple.

If most people did their homework, they will find the astronomical deaths, rapes, pillaging, blood, etc., that these 'tourist attractions' have caused.

Nothing like living in the past and taking the bad stuff as the standard. They also bankrolled explorers, scientists, composers and artists, allowing them to discover people, places, things, and ideas, and create seminal masterpieces that we treasure or perhaps saddly take for granted today.
 
I had seen a serious discussion of what would replace the monarchy as head of state. I have difficulty with concept of a political head of state. --For example Richard Nixon
 
I would disagree that nobility is the foundation of the free world


that it has evolved into freedom was not its raison d'être


its raison d'être was to keep the rich and powerful rich and powerful


it was by circumstance, not design, that it evolved into a democracy so it should not be trumpeted

and that is (now sound the trumpets) what I think

magna cartaMagna Carta (Latin for Great Charter),[SUP][1][/SUP] also called Magna Carta Libertatum or The Great Charter of the Liberties of England, is an Angevin charter originally issued in Latin in the year 1215.
Magna Carta was the first document forced onto a King of England by a group of his subjects, the feudal barons, in an attempt to limit his powers by law and protect their privileges.
The charter was an important part of the extensive historical process that led to the rule of constitutional law in the English speaking world. Magna Carta was important in the colonization of American colonies as England's legal system was used as a model for many of the colonies as they were developing their own legal systems.
The 1215 charter required King John of England to proclaim certain liberties and accept that his will was not arbitrary—for example by explicitly accepting that no "freeman" (in the sense of non-serf) could be punished except through the law of the land, a right that still exists.
It was preceded and directly influenced by the Charter of Liberties in 1100, in which King Henry I had specified particular areas wherein his powers would be limited.
It was translated into vernacular French as early as 1219,[SUP][2][/SUP] and reissued later in the 13th century in modified versions. The later versions excluded the most direct challenges to the monarch's authority that had been present in the 1215 charter. The charter first passed into law in 1225; the 1297 version, with the long title (originally in Latin) "The Great Charter of the Liberties of England, and of the Liberties of the Forest," still remains on the statute books of England and Wales.
Despite its recognised importance, by the second half of the 19th century nearly all of its clauses had been repealed in their original form. Three clauses currently remain part of the law of England and Wales, however, and it is generally considered part of the uncodified constitution. Lord Denning described it as "the greatest constitutional document of all times – the foundation of the freedom of the individual against the arbitrary authority of the despot".[SUP][3][/SUP] In a 2005 speech, Lord Woolf described it as "first of a series of instruments that now are recognised as having a special constitutional status",[SUP][4][/SUP] the others being the Habeas Corpus Act (1679), the Petition of Right (1628), the Bill of Rights (1689), and the Act of Settlement (1701).
It was Magna Carta, over other early concessions by the monarch, which survived to become a "sacred text".[SUP][5][/SUP] In practice, Magna Carta in the medieval period did not generally limit the power of kings, but by the time of the English Civil War it had become an important symbol for those who wished to show that the King was bound by the law. It influenced the early settlers in New England[SUP][6][/SUP] and inspired later constitutional documents, including the United States Constitution.[SUP][7][/SUP]
 
Yes, keep the monarchy, but I have a creative solution.

Let's change the rules so that you do not cease being the monarch at death. Thus, QE2 can remain the Queen indefinitely--forever basically. We'll turn Buckingham Palace into a big mausoleum and inter her there as the monarch in perpetuity. A Governor General would be appointed to serve in her stead in England, just as we have one here in Canada.

That way we can keep our traditions, while simultaneously avoiding any possibility of Charles *ever* appearing on our money. We can keep printing pictures of QE2 on it.
 
That way we can keep our traditions, while simultaneously avoiding any possibility of Charles *ever* appearing on our money. We can keep printing pictures of QE2 on it.

I would like to see the monarchy stick around in it's present form (a figure head of the government) but I must admit the idea of Charles as King is scary. I'm guessing it is for the Queen who is going to hang on as long as possible. I'm surprised that Charles hasn't sicked his pitbull on her yet.
 
I would like to see the monarchy stick around in it's present form (a figure head of the government) but I must admit the idea of Charles as King is scary. I'm guessing it is for the Queen who is going to hang on as long as possible. I'm surprised that Charles hasn't sicked his pitbull on her yet.

Charles is a jerk. The Royal Family are hoping to find a way to skip him, and are plainly investing a fortune in a PR campaign grooming William as the real successor. Plainly they hope Charles will not be long on the throne as they expect his reign will diminish support for the monarchy.
 
I was a war baby, born in England. My Canadian father married my English mother during WW2. Thus I hold both English and Canadian passports. The English one comes in handy at times, such as last year when I was in Dubai. If you were English, there was no visa fee. For Canadians, it was $250. Of course I used the English passport.

I have spent a considerable amount of time working in the UK over the years. I admire and enjoy the history and the pagaentry. Pomp and circumstance anyone. I am sure for the British it is a source of pride. Trying going to the Last Night of the Proms sometime.

However, having lived in Canada since I was one year old, I consider myself Canadian. It is time we cut loose the bonds of Mother England and go our own way. Once the Queen has passed on, we should begin the debate to become a republic. Let's have a race with the Aussies to see who says goodbye to the monarchy first.
 
Let's have a race with the Aussies to see who says goodbye to the monarchy first.

I suspect Australia will say goodbye first.

Toronto is a very multicultural city with lots of people from all over the world who have no respect for Canadian history and don't really identify themselves as Canadian, hence, no real ties to the British monarchy.

But get outside the GTA and things change to a more traditional Canadian society with strong ties to Britain and Canadian history and those people would never agree with any such notion of opting out of the British Commonwealth. It would be denying our Canadian heritage.
 
can we not take the good things in our heritage and get rid of the bad or nonsensical?
 
QEII only costs Canadian Taxpayers when she visits Canada as tradition dictates that we pick up the tab for her travelling costs.

Other than that, the Canadian Taxpayers don't contribute towards the cost of the Monarchy.

Canada is the greatest country in the world. While I will not dispute that it is a multicultural society, the fact is that Canada as we know it was conceived and built by the British system of government, laws, and society. This is a fact of history. The Royal Family is part of that history, part of what makes Canada the greatest country in the world and ending it would be denying our heritage.

The Queen has dedicated her entire life to the service of the Empire, the world even. She has served with dignity and grace and that is a scarce thing in this day and age. I for one would not want her life. She lives in a guilded cage as far as I'm concerned.

How is amiably smiling and waving at crowds 'serving' anyone? Anglo canucks, also referred to as Real Canadians (tm), really crack me up. The monarchy is a completely useless institution that simply serves to remind people in this country that english people and their progeny are first among so-called equals, and that's all. When Harper was proroguing parliament in the name of the crown, did the supposed representative and guardian of parliamentary traditions, David Johnston intervene to stop this trampling of said tradition? Nope. She has no legitimacy do much of anything anymore, and I for one don't understand why I should feel any affection for a doddering old nice lady from another country. Canada should just grow the fuck up and get rid of the monarchy.

edit: Btw kirk and your fellow canadians from outside the GTA, if you and your antecedents were too, frankly, useless to create your own traditions and culture after spending hundreds of years inhabiting this land (for example, what on earth is real canadian cuisine? Most peoples create their own cuisine as a matter of course), don't blame the immigrants who came after you who are not sufficiently steeped in the glories of the British empire. Blame yourselves for not creating a sufficiently robust and compelling culture that immigrants would gladly adopt in exchange for what they grew up with. American culture, for all its vapidity, manages to somehow make the immigrants there feel like they belong. Should've ditched fealty to the monarchy generations ago, really.
 
QEII only costs Canadian Taxpayers when she visits Canada as tradition dictates that we pick up the tab for her travelling costs.

Other than that, the Canadian Taxpayers don't contribute towards the cost of the Monarchy.

Canada is the greatest country in the world. While I will not dispute that it is a multicultural society, the fact is that Canada as we know it was conceived and built by the British system of government, laws, and society. This is a fact of history. The Royal Family is part of that history, part of what makes Canada the greatest country in the world and ending it would be denying our heritage.

The Queen has dedicated her entire life to the service of the Empire, the world even. She has served with dignity and grace and that is a scarce thing in this day and age. I for one would not want her life. She lives in a guilded cage as far as I'm concerned.

Holy fuck !
Is there one drop of kool-aid left in the glass ?




It would make me very happy to Drop the Royals now !