Should US Forces Go Home?

oldjones said:
Oh, c'mon, you know your history better than that! The US made a proud civic virtue out of "standing idly by" for years, encouraging Hitler to run amok in Europe, and then claimed, as now, to have single-handedly saved humanity. Following their WWI precedent to to the letter. Damning indeed.
Certainly the characteristic smugness hasn't changed.

I don't know that our standing by too long in 1940 excuses you from doing so today. And we did save the world thank you very much, not alone (by a long shot) but in the end it couldn't have been done without us - and we're the only country you can say that about. It's not smugness if it's accurate.

OTB
 
oldjones said:
Oh, c'mon, you know your history better than that! The US made a proud civic virtue out of "standing idly by" for years, encouraging Hitler to run amok in Europe, and then claimed, as now, to have single-handedly saved humanity. Following their WWI precedent to to the letter. Damning indeed.
Certainly the characteristic smugness hasn't changed.
Ahahaha :D The US only officially entered the European conflict in WWII when Hitler declared war on them! That is right! Dec 1941 Germany declared war on the US.

On September 5, 1939 the USA declares its neutrality.

On September 10, 1939 Canada declares war on Germany.

Who stood by for two years; and only engaged Germany after it declared war on them?

OTB is too funny!
 
onthebottom said:
I don't know that our standing by too long in 1940 excuses you from doing so today.
OTB
In respects to what is Canada standing by today? With respects to Iraq; and Saddam who is a terrorists with direct links to Al Queda and responsible for 9/11? Or because we stand by as the US solidifies it's hegemony and we say nothing? There are always different perspectives ...
 
onthebottom said:
I don't know that our standing by too long in 1940 excuses you from doing so today.…edit…It's not smugness if it's accurate.

OTB
You don't need excuses if you're right. We preferred to uphold the principle of collective action against tyranny, which was the good thing that emerged from WWII, rather than sign on with the local bully determined on petty vengeance for the "plot to kill my Daddy." We said we'd go, if and when the UN says there's a war to be fought for a just cause—as they did for BushI, and we were there. So far the Coalition of the Willing has proven a Coalition of the Duped, and the UN Inspectorate Cheney sneered at, has been vindicated right down the line. It's the US who's looking for excuses.

But as to history: Either you're smugly denying American passivity "in the face of evil" in two world wars—accurate history—or your country is, as you said, "damned" by that statement above: "Evil exists when good men stand idly by." Nobody here but us pots and kettles calling each other black. So enlightening.
 
The US entered the war later than it should have, the US was very isolationist (like I think it will become again) because of the cost of WWI. That being said:

tompeepin said:
Ahahaha :D The US only officially entered the European conflict in WWII when Hitler declared war on them! That is right! Dec 1941 Germany declared war on the US.

You forgot to mention that Japan and Germany were allies (along with Italy) and when the US declared war on Japan Germany then declared war on the US (as did Italy but I'm not clear on when that happened).

Your list of events was a bit misleading from that perspective.

tompeepin said:

On September 5, 1939 the USA declares its neutrality.

On September 10, 1939 Canada declares war on Germany.

Bit too late for Austria, Czech. and Poland wouldn’t you say? To use TJO’s favorite line, it’s all relative. And you were just following the UK were you not?

tompeepin said:

Who stood by for two years; and only engaged Germany after it declared war on them?

OTB is too funny!

Stood by is debatable (lend lease, Shermans being sent to North Africa to save the UK there.......) but what drove the US joining the war was Pearl Harbor, it was the only thing that Roosevelt could use to get the US population out of it's isolationist stance.

The risk (or opportunity depending on your perspective) is that the US experience in the Middle East, the perceived back stabbing (again debatable) from an allied that we've liberated TWICE in the last century and the shear cost of our military will cause the US populous to move back to an isolationist stance. Hence the thread.

As a footnote, use the logic you use for our involvement in Iraq against our involvement in WWII, think the mid 1930s.

Final point, how does any of this excuse your current impotence in a dangerous world?

OTB
 
oldjones, Tompeeing,

My comment was not that you don't go when everyone one else does (following the crowd as it were) it was more (and I guess this was unclear) that you don't have much to go with when you go and can't even get there yourself.

You have no credible air force, or way to get your air force to theater, no credible armor or way to get your armor to theater, not much of a credible ground force and no way to get it to theater.... And this from a very rich G8 country - you should be ashamed that you have no way to pursue a policy without hitchhiking with the US.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
... that you don't have much to go with when you go and can't even get there yourself.
Very true. But then again we do not start things that we have to "get" to. :p And if we are part of a UN assignment we fulfill a role that we are best suited for and our buddies in the UN get our forces where they need to be. So I guess we have not built our forces with the ability to engage unilaterally. But you do have a point; we need to improve our military capabilities just slightly.

onthebottom said:
... And this from a very rich G8 country ...
OTB
Rich? In another thread you said that we trail far behind the US and EU ... so therefore maybe that is why we are too "poor" to support a huge army. :P

For all you observers out there, OTB likes to have it both ways. hehehe
 
tompeepin said:
Very true. But then again we do not start things that we have to "get" to. :p And if we are part of a UN assignment we fulfill a role that we are best suited for and our buddies in the UN get our forces where they need to be. So I guess we have not built our forces with the ability to engage unilaterally. But you do have a point; we need to improve our military capabilities just slightly.


Rich? In another thread you said that we trail far behind the US and EU ... so therefore maybe that is why we are too "poor" to support a huge army. :P

For all you observers out there, OTB likes to have it both ways. hehehe

I was starting to miss those hehehes. By world standards you are rich, just not as rich as the US or Japan, on par with Germany and much of the EU on a per capita basis.

Both NATO and the UN are too dependent on the US for forces because the other rich countries of the world take the view you've expressed above. Any idea who's providing air support for the Olympic games in Greece? I'll give you one hint, it's not the EU or Greece....

OTB

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Any idea who's providing air support for the Olympic games in Greece? I'll give you one hint, it's not the EU or Greece....

OTB
IF ...

the venues will be finished in time! hehehe
 
onthebottom said:
oldjones, Tompeeing,

My comment was not that you don't go when everyone one else does…edit.
OTB
Oh, was it not? How was a guy to know?
Should we bring our pitiable little contingent back from Afghanistan then? Although it's a great training ground for the sorta 'defence' we've relied on our North American neighbours to provide since the Cold War.
I think "Raindrops keep falling…" was the sixth all-time favourite movie song in the recent poll.
 
Last edited:
onthebottom said:
My point is, why does America need to be there, surly the clever Europeans can defend themselves these days, there is no reason for the US to have any troops in Europe, even peace keeping missions (Bosnia) could or should be done by the EU. It's the only way to get the EU to step up to their responsibilities.

In an ideal world this is true. But in reality the Europeans are spoiled to have the Americans nuclear umbralla for half a century and they are getting used to the dependence.

Think about this, if you were getting used to have domestic helpers, cleaning ladies and what not to take care of your house, would you ever make up your mind to do those housework all by yourself and stop asking those professionals to come?

That's exactly what the Europeans are thinking today.

Ditto above on Japan, could not the US Navy (carrier battle groups) protect our interests in SEA without our needing to base troops there. I would guess that two CBGs in a given theater would represent the strongest military in that theater (certainly superior air and missile power). Do you agree? I just don't see an American reason for the US to have boots on the ground in Asia.

Two CBGs are adequate to deter any aggression from small and middle powers. But for medium size countries with extraordinary large military or large country like China, you need at least four CBGs to have minimum punches. My guess will be six CBGs.

I am talking only the naval components.

Problem is the USN Carrier battle groups are razor thin nowadays. The USN has 12 carriers but one, usually the conventional powered one is needed to train new naval air pilots, three are needed for six months mandatory maintenances in the shipyards (nothing to do with nuclear reactors asi t takes about 15 years for one refuel).

That leave only around 8 carriers deployable around the world. One carrier will be for permanent stationed with the third fleet in Mediterranian Sea, seven fleet in the Pacific Ocean, and fifth fleet near the Persian gulf respectively. After that you have 3 Carriers stationed either in San Dieago or Pearl Harbor and 2 Carriers at Norfolk.

If the US needs direct confrontation to China on Taiwan, the USN will be forced to deploy other carriers from other AOR (area of responsibilities) to back up in Pacific via Falkland islands (the carriers are too big for the Panama canal). That will create a vacuum in those area.

This is also the case for the Marines MEUs. Most the Marines core strengths are in Pacific for "kicking doors in North Korea" or counter attack if China invades Taiwan without provocation.

BTW, you can use your navy to enforce naval blockade around your enemy territorial waters and unleash destruction along the coast by unleashing cruise missles from the Cruisers, destroyers and SSNs.

You can use your air force to pulvarize the enemy territories and bomb the shit out of your enemies by waves of B-52, B-1 and handful of B-2 with JDAMs, air launched cruise missiles, FAB munitions or what not 24/7.

But all of these can only help to seize the land. Towards the end of the day, you need to send the grunts of the US Marines, and Army into the harms way to control the "real estate" of your enemy, hold the ground if you may.

The enemies can hide deep underground and emerge out after the Navy and Air Force finish their missions of destroying the infrastructures but you still need infantries to, put it bluntly, close in and hunt for the kill. Without this gut wrenching step, you can't win the war.

Plus, there's always the "symbol of presence" in the region. The Navy and Air forces are no substitute.
 
onthebottom said:
The US entered the war later than it should have... That being said ... Your list of events was a bit misleading from that perspective ... To use TJO’s favorite line, it’s all relative. And you were just following the UK were you not? ... Stood by is debatable ... Final point, how does any of this excuse your current impotence in a dangerous world?

OTB [/B]
Again you like to have it both ways. :p Absolute then relative, right thing to do and then debatable. Debateable and justifiable for the US to sit by and watch ... but negate Canada's sacrifice as "just following the UK".

Yes we get it! In your view, you always strive to be "right"! When in fact you're a revisionist US jingoist. hehehe
 
sweet guy said:
In an ideal world this is true. But in reality the Europeans are spoiled to have the Americans nuclear umbralla for half a century and they are getting used to the dependence.

Think about this, if you were getting used to have domestic helpers, cleaning ladies and what not to take care of your house, would you ever make up your mind to do those housework all by yourself and stop asking those professionals to come?

That's exactly what the Europeans are thinking today.



Two CBGs are adequate to deter any aggression from small and middle powers. But for medium size countries with extraordinary large military or large country like China, you need at least four CBGs to have minimum punches. My guess will be six CBGs.

I am talking only the naval components.

Problem is the USN Carrier battle groups are razor thin nowadays. The USN has 12 carriers but one, usually the conventional powered one is needed to train new naval air pilots, three are needed for six months mandatory maintenances in the shipyards (nothing to do with nuclear reactors asi t takes about 15 years for one refuel).

That leave only around 8 carriers deployable around the world. One carrier will be for permanent stationed with the third fleet in Mediterranian Sea, seven fleet in the Pacific Ocean, and fifth fleet near the Persian gulf respectively. After that you have 3 Carriers stationed either in San Dieago or Pearl Harbor and 2 Carriers at Norfolk.

If the US needs direct confrontation to China on Taiwan, the USN will be forced to deploy other carriers from other AOR (area of responsibilities) to back up in Pacific via Falkland islands (the carriers are too big for the Panama canal). That will create a vacuum in those area.

This is also the case for the Marines MEUs. Most the Marines core strengths are in Pacific for "kicking doors in North Korea" or counter attack if China invades Taiwan without provocation.

BTW, you can use your navy to enforce naval blockade around your enemy territorial waters and unleash destruction along the coast by unleashing cruise missles from the Cruisers, destroyers and SSNs.

You can use your air force to pulvarize the enemy territories and bomb the shit out of your enemies by waves of B-52, B-1 and handful of B-2 with JDAMs, air launched cruise missiles, FAB munitions or what not 24/7.

But all of these can only help to seize the land. Towards the end of the day, you need to send the grunts of the US Marines, and Army into the harms way to control the "real estate" of your enemy, hold the ground if you may.

The enemies can hide deep underground and emerge out after the Navy and Air Force finish their missions of destroying the infrastructures but you still need infantries to, put it bluntly, close in and hunt for the kill. Without this gut wrenching step, you can't win the war.

Plus, there's always the "symbol of presence" in the region. The Navy and Air forces are no substitute.

Again, another great post!

Europe is spoiled, one of the key benefits of bringing the troops home is that it would shock Europe into defending themselves.

If we have 12 Carrier battle groups and no troops deployed in foreign lands I don't see the harm in leaving the Med uncovered - again Europe could always handle it right?

OTB
 
Ah, the sweet smell of sucess:

News today form Reuteres on the US pulling back it's troops - careful what you wish for:

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - President Bush (news - web sites) is expected to announce on Monday the withdrawal of about 70,000 troops from Europe and Asia in a major realignment of the U.S. military presence to better fight the war on terrorism.
Bu sh is to speak in Ohio, seen as one of the November election battleground states, to the Veterans of Foreign Wars to outline a major realignment of the U.S. military presence prompted by the end of the Cold War, U.S. officials said.
Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld has said the changes will take years to put in place and did not expect large troop movements soon. But the realignment will mean big changes in long-standing arrangements with close allies and likely more U.S. troops on home soil, at a time when critics say the Iraq (news - web sites) and Afghanistan (news - web sites) conflicts have stretched U.S. forces.
"The principal characteristics of all of them taken together are that we want greater usability of our forces, that we very likely will end up with more forces back in the United States, that we will be looking for flexibility and relationships so that we can rotate forces in, have exercises with various countries," Rumsfeld told reporters on Sunday as he returned from Europe and Asia.
U.S. officials said the changes will mean the withdrawal of about 70,000 troops from Europe and Asia, two regions where the United States has maintained a major presence since the end of the Second World War in 1945. In the Cold War era, the European forces, especially in Germany, were meant to be a counterweight to the threat posed by the Soviet Union's Warsaw Pact forces.
There are more than 100,000 U.S. troops in Europe, with 70,000 in Germany, and another 100,000 in the Pacific and Asia.
"There will be a shift from Germany, and we've talked to the Germans about that and some numbers, they are doing the same thing -- they're also readjusting their forces and they understand that," Rumsfeld said.
The proposed global realignment includes plans to use bases in Eastern European countries of the former Soviet bloc as transit points to quickly send forces from the United States to trouble spots such as the Middle East and northern Africa.
While many soldiers would be brought home from both Europe and Asia, sophisticated weaponry, including fighter planes, would be sent overseas to some bases to make up for the smaller number of deployed ground troops.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I don't know that our standing by too long in 1940 excuses you from doing so today. And we did save the world thank you very much, not alone (by a long shot) but in the end it couldn't have been done without us - and we're the only country you can say that about. It's not smugness if it's accurate.

OTB

OK OTB, you just blew it right there.

The US did NOT save the world's ass twice as so many americans like to believe.

Last time I checked it was a group effort.

110,000 Canadians got themselves killed in WW1 and WW2, that's like 1.1 million Americans getting themselves killed.

Shame on you sir. Do you think that it somehow hurt less when a Canadian or Brit, or Aussie, or Pole got shot than when an american got shot.

Shame, I thought you were above such arrogance.
 
james t kirk said:
OK OTB, you just blew it right there.

The US did NOT save the world's ass twice as so many americans like to believe.

Last time I checked it was a group effort.

110,000 Canadians got themselves killed in WW1 and WW2, that's like 1.1 million Americans getting themselves killed.

Shame on you sir. Do you think that it somehow hurt less when a Canadian or Brit, or Aussie, or Pole got shot than when an american got shot.

Shame, I thought you were above such arrogance.

Dude, learn to read "not alone (by a long shot) would seem to cover your little rant don't you think?

OTB
 
Winston said:
The US joined WWI in 1917, and more US soldiers died of the flu, then saw combat, let alone died from combat injuries. The US also missed the mustard gas attacks, if memory serves me correctly.

While the US did help with the effort in WWII, the war might have been over sooner if the US had not shipped steel, energy, and munitions to Nazi Germany. Until Pearl Harbour, the US continued to have normal trade with the Japanese and Germans.

Winston, your arguments are both tired and off subject. The question is should the US pull those forces home now that WWII is not going to flame up again.

I think you are forgetting that the US embargoed Japan for its invasion of China, thus Pearl Harbor. The US provided substantial aid to the UK before we entered the war. As I've said repeatedly, the lesson of WWII was that everyone waited too long to respond to the German threat, the US included.

I believe the US is shifting to a more isolationist stance, the above troop redeployment, when it happens, will be a dramatic shift in that direction.

OTB
 
Lee Cum Gay said:
I am the Director of the Okinawa for Okinawans - Kick out the Yankees Association ...

If you don't leave, we will start a rebellion !!!

And stop harrasing our schoolgirls man!!!

NO, you're a short unemployed guy from Hong Kong who lives with his parents. And as a former resident of Hong Kong you should know what brought those troops to Okinawa.

But I do share the view that they should come home.

OTB

P.S. Did anyone show up for your anonymous cocksuckfest last Friday?
 
Lee Cum Gay said:
I am the Director of the Okinawa for Okinawans - Kick out the Yankees Association ...

If you don't leave, we will start a rebellion !!!

And stop harrasing our schoolgirls man!!!

:rolleyes: