onthebottom said:
My point is, why does America need to be there, surly the clever Europeans can defend themselves these days, there is no reason for the US to have any troops in Europe, even peace keeping missions (Bosnia) could or should be done by the EU. It's the only way to get the EU to step up to their responsibilities.
In an ideal world this is true. But in reality the Europeans are spoiled to have the Americans nuclear umbralla for half a century and they are getting used to the dependence.
Think about this, if you were getting used to have domestic helpers, cleaning ladies and what not to take care of your house, would you ever make up your mind to do those housework all by yourself and stop asking those professionals to come?
That's exactly what the Europeans are thinking today.
Ditto above on Japan, could not the US Navy (carrier battle groups) protect our interests in SEA without our needing to base troops there. I would guess that two CBGs in a given theater would represent the strongest military in that theater (certainly superior air and missile power). Do you agree? I just don't see an American reason for the US to have boots on the ground in Asia.
Two CBGs are adequate to deter any aggression from small and middle powers. But for medium size countries with extraordinary large military or large country like China, you need at least four CBGs to have minimum punches. My guess will be six CBGs.
I am talking
only the naval components.
Problem is the USN Carrier battle groups are razor thin nowadays. The USN has 12 carriers
but one, usually the conventional powered one is needed to train new naval air pilots, three are needed for six months mandatory maintenances in the shipyards (nothing to do with nuclear reactors asi t takes about 15 years for one refuel).
That leave only around 8 carriers deployable around the world. One carrier will be for permanent stationed with the third fleet in Mediterranian Sea, seven fleet in the Pacific Ocean, and fifth fleet near the Persian gulf
respectively. After that you have 3 Carriers stationed either in San Dieago or Pearl Harbor and 2 Carriers at Norfolk.
If the US needs direct confrontation to China on Taiwan, the USN will be forced to deploy other carriers from other AOR (area of responsibilities) to back up in Pacific via Falkland islands (the carriers are too big for the Panama canal). That will create a vacuum in those area.
This is also the case for the Marines MEUs. Most the Marines core strengths are in Pacific for "kicking doors in North Korea" or counter attack if China invades Taiwan
without provocation.
BTW, you can use your navy to enforce naval blockade around your enemy territorial waters and unleash destruction along the coast by unleashing cruise missles from the Cruisers, destroyers and SSNs.
You can use your air force to pulvarize the enemy territories and bomb the shit out of your enemies by waves of B-52, B-1 and handful of B-2 with JDAMs, air launched cruise missiles, FAB munitions or what not 24/7.
But all of these can only help to seize the land. Towards the end of the day, you need to send the grunts of the US Marines, and Army into the harms way to control the "real estate" of your enemy, hold the ground if you may.
The enemies can hide deep underground and emerge out after the Navy and Air Force finish their missions of destroying the infrastructures but you still need infantries to, put it bluntly, close in and hunt for the kill. Without this gut wrenching step, you can't win the war.
Plus, there's always the "symbol of presence" in the region. The Navy and Air forces are no substitute.