Should US Forces Go Home?

onthebottom said:
…edit…I wonder what the City and State of NY get out of the UN in the way of Property Taxes each year, that must be a killer bill.

OTB
Don't you imagine they put in that in the deal that brought the UN to New York? Even if it just was for a few beads and trinkets, I thought a deal was a deal. And an obligation to pay, voluntarily undertaken, still an obligation.
Anyway, to end your wondering: e-mail the NYC Commisssioner for the United Nations @ http://www.nyc.gov/html/mail/html/mailmcp.html
 
oldjones said:
Don't you imagine they put in that in the deal that brought the UN to New York? Even if it just was for a few beads and trinkets, I thought a deal was a deal. And an obligation to pay, voluntarily undertaken, still an obligation.

And besides the fact that the economic spin-offs from having foreign diplomats with cash to throw away is worth more than the rent anyways.....

The day the UN leaves NYC will put lots of local businesses out of their misery (most notably the escorting and limo ones, I'd gather).

PAL
 
oldjones said:
Don't you imagine they put in that in the deal that brought the UN to New York? Even if it just was for a few beads and trinkets, I thought a deal was a deal. And an obligation to pay, voluntarily undertaken, still an obligation.
Anyway, to end your wondering: e-mail the NYC Commisssioner for the United Nations @ http://www.nyc.gov/html/mail/html/mailmcp.html

I was kidding, I'm sure we get to provide police and fire services for the UN for free, just one of the benefits of having diplomats double park in your city and insult your country.

OTB
 
Pallydin said:
And besides the fact that the economic spin-offs from having foreign diplomats with cash to throw away is worth more than the rent anyways.....

The day the UN leaves NYC will put lots of local businesses out of their misery (most notably the escorting and limo ones, I'd gather).

PAL

But what a happy day that would be, I don't think either the Limo or Escort businesses are short of customers in NYC.

OTB
 
tillithurts said:
The Japanesse woke up the sleeping Giant and brought the US into WWII. It's time for the Giant to go back to sleep.

Something we can agree on.

OTB
 
harleycharley said:
Yes, its time the US forces got out of these places and Bush was tried for war crimes.

Neither will happen but thanks for playing.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I was kidding, I'm sure we get to provide police and fire services for the UN for free, just one of the benefits of having diplomats double park in your city and insult your country.

OTB
Still at it, too. Wottakidder!
The UN jokes might be funnier if you guys weren't still welching on the back dues you owe.
 
oldjones said:
Still at it, too. Wottakidder!
The UN jokes might be funnier if you guys weren't still welching on the back dues you owe.

Something about a bunch of poor countries hanging out in your city and sending you the bill that irks congress, although I don't see it myself.

I do think that we've caught up a bit on the past due bill although congress wanted some reforms at the UN first (very bloated organization). I used to work for a guy with 5 sons, his rule was you can make all the decisions you can pay for, otherwise I decide. I think the US has taken that position with the UN from time to time.

OTB
 
Alucard said:
it would be nice if they are gone but now isn't really a good time for them to leave.

The problem is it's never a good time.

OTB
 
Yes, pull back the troops and cut military spending.

I remember part of Bush's platform in 2000 was that he was going to "stay out of other people's business" when people asked him about his foreign policy and criticized him on his lack of foreign knowledge. His policy was "take care of problem at home first before trying to take care of problems abroad". He was actually criticized badly on this because that meant the US would stop brokering the peace deal Clinton was working on before he left office.

Then 9/11 and man have things changed.
 
Don said:
Yes, pull back the troops and cut military spending.

I remember part of Bush's platform in 2000 was that he was going to "stay out of other people's business" when people asked him about his foreign policy and criticized him on his lack of foreign knowledge. His policy was "take care of problem at home first before trying to take care of problems abroad". He was actually criticized badly on this because that meant the US would stop brokering the peace deal Clinton was working on before he left office.

Then 9/11 and man have things changed.

Interesting how events can change the dynamic isn't it. One lesson that Bush learned is that the war is the easy part in these campaigns - if he gets a second term (not at all assured) he's sure to tread much more lightly (look at North Korea and Iran for examples of being the leader of the West instead of the only cowboy). I'm sure the NeoCons have taken it on the chin from an influence perspective and Powell should be riding high (if you break it you own it). If W does get another 4 (and I'll be voting for him) I sure hope Powell stays - he'd make a damn fine POTUS some day.

OTB
 
In an ideal world, the US Forces should leave Germany since Germany became like any normal European country after decades of repentance and reforms.

But it's easier said than done. The Germans are smart enough not to kick the US out. Why? Cause the Bundeswehr has very limited training space to train the troops. This is more acute to the Luftwaffe since the airspace in Europe is too crowded for training and war games.

If the Germans tell the Americans to get out, the Americans will return the favor by cancelling any NATO-type training in Nevada for the Luftwaffe. Canada is only good at winter, snowy training for the Luftwaffe, not the all weather, type in Nevada.

So, as long as both sides see the need to keep the status quos. I think the only option for the Americans will be to return the V corps back to the states, only when the Panzer gruppen in Germany are confident enough and the armies of Poland, Hungary, the Czech republic are strong enough to deter any possible comeback of the Russian Forces.

Japan case is unique and the Americans will not leave that easily.

Japan wants the Americans to stay even though they are not that wholeheartedly to do so. The Americans are barbwires like the case in 38th parallel, to deter any attack from North Korea such as suicide topedo or subarines attacks on Japanese Naval Self-Defense Force and US Navy by the North Koreans, or Ballistic missile attacks.

Another will be Okinawa is among the poorest region in Japan and ironically, the US Forces are the largest employer of the island, ranging from maintenance to tourism industries. Japan doesn't want to subsidise additional yen in the poor region.

Finally, US Force in Japan is the closet forward base in Asia. Guam is still too far away. China is the main reason why US Force still needs to stay in Asia-to deter any Chinese expansion.

Without the US Force presence, the Southeast Asia as a whole will be at best put the PLA at Bay, but not enough to stop China from "going to the sea". Japan will be forced to rearm WMD and expand her already sophisticated naval self-defence force to protect her oil route from Chinese encroachment.

This is especially precarious when China says she will reunite Taiwan with all cost.
 
sweet guy said:
If the Germans tell the Americans to get out, the Americans will return the favor by cancelling any NATO-type training in Nevada for the Luftwaffe. Canada is only good at winter, snowy training for the Luftwaffe, not the all weather, type in Nevada.

Out of curiosity, do you really believe Nevada represents an "all weather" scenario for training? If it was *really* about good training areas, there is nothing in the USA climate or terrain-wise that cannot easily be found in Canada or Mexico (both non-Coalition of the Willing allies).

Just saying.....

PAL
 
Pallydin said:
Out of curiosity, do you really believe Nevada represents an "all weather" scenario for training? If it was *really* about good training areas, there is nothing in the USA climate or terrain-wise that cannot easily be found in Canada or Mexico (both non-Coalition of the Willing allies).

Just saying.....

PAL

Yes, Canada is cheaper than in the United States.

But unlike in the United States, they can't train with the USAF, USN, or USMC air wings together as a team.

In Canada the Germans may be able to train with either NATO allies training in the same area (can't remember Manitoba or Alberta) such as the UK or Italy, or having the RCAF deploying CF 18 fighters to the base. USAF is not allowed to train and station in Canada because of "respecting" Canada's sovereignty.

No pun intended, only training with the Americans in war games counts. The RCAF contribution is insiginficant. The CF18s Canada are using are basically the same model as F/A-18 A/B models in early 80s. The USN and USMC are getting the Super Hornets (E/F models) and Growler (G models ECM fighter) to supersde the C/D models and address the short combat distances for good.

Only the RAAF and Spanish Air Force still use F/A-18A/B models but their upgraded fighters are much more sophisticated and multi-roled than our upgraded ones, and those fighters are going to be replaced by Eurofighters in a few years time. In Canada, there's NONE and we could not even afford to get a replacement.

Regarding Mexico, Mexico is not a NATO ally so there's no point to train with Mexico. Unless the Luftwaffe needs to train their fighter pilots in high attitude/ mountainous areas like Mexico, otherwise there is no need to train in Mexico.

BTW, training with the Americans guarantee participation in annual "Red Flags" air combat exercise. Plus the pilots and their ground crews can spend time and try their luck in Las Vegas before going back to Deutchland. This is something Canada can't provide since the training base is in the middle of nowhere (near Churchill if I remember right).
 
sweet guy said:
In an ideal world, the US Forces should leave Germany since Germany became like any normal European country after decades of repentance and reforms.

But it's easier said than done. The Germans are smart enough not to kick the US out. Why? Cause the Bundeswehr has very limited training space to train the troops. This is more acute to the Luftwaffe since the airspace in Europe is too crowded for training and war games.

If the Germans tell the Americans to get out, the Americans will return the favor by cancelling any NATO-type training in Nevada for the Luftwaffe. Canada is only good at winter, snowy training for the Luftwaffe, not the all weather, type in Nevada.

So, as long as both sides see the need to keep the status quos. I think the only option for the Americans will be to return the V corps back to the states, only when the Panzer gruppen in Germany are confident enough and the armies of Poland, Hungary, the Czech republic are strong enough to deter any possible comeback of the Russian Forces.

First let me say, excellent level of detail, I love it when I learn something on these threads!

I think perhaps you're missing my point, I can understand why Germany wants the US there - free protection and a boost to their economy. My point is, why does America need to be there, surly the clever Europeans can defend themselves these days, there is no reason for the US to have any troops in Europe, even peace keeping missions (Bosnia) could or should be done by the EU. It's the only way to get the EU to step up to their responsibilities.

sweet guy said:

Japan case is unique and the Americans will not leave that easily.

Japan wants the Americans to stay even though they are not that wholeheartedly to do so. The Americans are barbwires like the case in 38th parallel, to deter any attack from North Korea such as suicide topedo or subarines attacks on Japanese Naval Self-Defense Force and US Navy by the North Koreans, or Ballistic missile attacks.

Another will be Okinawa is among the poorest region in Japan and ironically, the US Forces are the largest employer of the island, ranging from maintenance to tourism industries. Japan doesn't want to subsidise additional yen in the poor region.

Finally, US Force in Japan is the closet forward base in Asia. Guam is still too far away. China is the main reason why US Force still needs to stay in Asia-to deter any Chinese expansion.

Without the US Force presence, the Southeast Asia as a whole will be at best put the PLA at Bay, but not enough to stop China from "going to the sea". Japan will be forced to rearm WMD and expand her already sophisticated naval self-defence force to protect her oil route from Chinese encroachment.

This is especially precarious when China says she will reunite Taiwan with all cost.

Ditto above on Japan, could not the US Navy (carrier battle groups) protect our interests in SEA without our needing to base troops there. I would guess that two CBGs in a given theater would represent the strongest military in that theater (certainly superior air and missile power). Do you agree? I just don't see an American reason for the US to have boots on the ground in Asia.

OTB
 
healer677 said:
"Evil exists when good men stand idly by."

If you're a Canadian that's a pretty damning statement!

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
If you're a Canadian that's a pretty damning statement!

OTB
Oh, c'mon, you know your history better than that! The US made a proud civic virtue out of "standing idly by" for years, encouraging Hitler to run amok in Europe, and then claimed, as now, to have single-handedly saved humanity. Following their WWI precedent to to the letter. Damning indeed.
Certainly the characteristic smugness hasn't changed.