Should the Leafs Gut and Rebuild?

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
508
113
The Keebler Factory
I'm not a hockey guru like some people out there so I'm posing this question:

If the Leafs could (i.e., notwithstanding contract restrictions), should the Leafs gut their current roster (drop/trade Tucker, McCabe, Sundin)?

My impression is that they should but then they'd have nobody of significance (i.e., name brand recognition) in the lineup, which Toronto fans won't accept.

If/when the Leafs miss the playoffs again this year, they should be two years into a rebuilding program. I'm not so sure the team roster reflects this. They seem to be getting a little younger, but then they hang on to the likes of Sundin and Tucker. It's like half-assed all the way!
 
They should tank and build through the draft. The problem is, they'd fuck that up too.:rolleyes:
 
No matter how talented a group of guys are, once they've gotten used to losing, it's time to gut and rebuild. Ottawa should do the same.
 
Keebler Elf said:
My impression is that they should but then they'd have nobody of significance (i.e., name brand recognition) in the lineup, which Toronto fans won't accept.

Since when has MLSE cared about the fans? It's not really the fans that pay the bills,it's all corporate $$$.
 
Yes, they should, but the chance to do so with any major impact may have passed them by:

What could they get for McCabe and his contract right now? Unless he turns it around in a hurry, the Leafs will be stuck with his salary to the end of the contract.

Sundin is still effective but isn't getting any younger. The time will come when he just doesn't have it anymore. And by the next trade deadline, he may be done, meaning the return on moving him will be negligable.

Tucker is the kind of player a lot of teams would want as a rental going into the playoffs, or perhaps with one year left on his contract. With four years remaining, he's good but not the impact players teams would pay big for.

Kaberle is the only one who might fetch you any kind of decent return, and he's the last one that you want to trade.

Raycroft won't get you much now. Nor will any of their other veterans.

The worst thing you can do is move ANY of the kids, so they have to stop doing that.

So really, when you look at it, they had their chance this year when teams like Atlanta (for Tkachuk), New York (for Smyth), Nashville (for Forsberg) were giving up a lot for anyone, the Leafs once again BLEW IT! Heck, Montreal got a 1st round pick for Craig Rivet... CRAIG RIVET!!!
 
Back Burner said:
Destroy and rebuild around Stajan.
He's the first guy I'd get rid of (while they could still get something for him before other teams realize he'll never be more than a 3rd or 4th line centre at best).
 
yeah...i think the leafs could have afforded a 5th round pick for anson carter.....having both him and perrault (sp?) in the line-up could have boosted them for the playoff run...

the first thing the leafs gotta do is get rid of guys like antropov (this guy is a joke, why does he get so many chances?), hal gill (worst defenceman in the league), and kubina (way too much money)

i hope the leafs re-sign bates battaglia, he's not a franchise player by any means but he does everything that has been asked of him, he does his job and plays his role night in and night out...........if more guys did that the leafs would be in the playoff picture right now....
 
I think you've gotta drop the mentality of, "but what will we get for him?" and just pull the trigger anyways. If you don't, you'll always be saying that and always be (over)spending your money.

Better to start with a clean slate. Sure it'll hurt in the shortrun, but you've gotta look at the longrun if you're looking to rebuild.
 
I'd get a better GM before all this trading starts so they can pick good players with there drafts. Dont see any stars coming up with there recent picks.
 
JFJ is NOT a GM. He's a fuckin' lawyer, period. Until the Leafs put a hockey savvy group at the top, they'll never acomplish anything. But ultimately it's us Leafs fan's fault, cuz we keep fillin' the stands.

With the support that the Leafs get, the mentality in Toronto should be the same as it is with the NY Yankees - we are the best market for this sport, therefore we must do our utmost to put the best product out there.

But we don't hold them acountable, therfore there is no incentive to do it.

Leafs forever...
 
hardlicks said:
But we don't hold them acountable, therfore there is no incentive to do it.

I don't believe that for a second.

Winning a Stanley Cup would not only make the careers of all of those involved, but it would also transform the Leafs from a cash cow into a CASH COW. Mo' money, mo' money, mo' money. That's the language businessmen understand.

I think the Leaf's problem is a lack of (long-term) vision and the discipline needed to get the team from Stanley Cup pretender to contender.
 
Anybody notice the Raps inprovement this year with a good/decent gm. Not saying there going all the way but hell of alot better then they were. He made the trades and the picks.
As for cash cow, the leafs will always make money. You, me and Joe Blow may not buy tickets but corporations fill boxes and seats thats what makes money. Stop them and then see how empty the place is.
My son wants to go to Raptors or Leafs game, good luck. Cheaper going to Jays game. Although they screwed the sched this year with NO Yanks or Box any weekend home game.
BOOO whats the league thinking.
Sorry just ranting.
 
getting close to a time where this gutting can become a reality- Sundin's contract is almost up.

but, we'll still have McCabe, Raycroft and Kubina.