Should euthanasia be legal?

Should euthanasia be legal?

  • Yes

    Votes: 39 54.2%
  • Yes in some cases

    Votes: 24 33.3%
  • No

    Votes: 9 12.5%
  • No opinion

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    72
Surprised we haven't heard the religious view point yet !!
We did!

Blackcock finally posted.....:biggrin1:

He's been busy in the pig thread.....:D
 
The idea that murdering someone is okay if they are "suffering" is horrifying.

A lot of drama queens love to use 'murder' instead of 'assisted suicide'. If English is not your strong suit, let me try and distinguish the difference. If Grandma stubs her toe and I sneak up to her and clobber her dead with a hammer - that would be murder. If I have a living will or written instructions entering the hospital when I want to have the plug pulled should I have unsuccessful surgery, that is not murder.

Most (all?) life insurance policies are incontestable for suicide, sane or insane, after three years! So why should they not pay upon the death of the insured?
I have the same coverage in my policy and I can't see why the insurance would argue the difference in using a gun or a doctor to carry it out.
 
Laws are archaic on this one IMHO. If you want to die, why not allow it? The standard of life at that point is not going to be good even if you're not elderly.
 
We have a wide range of tools to manage and eliminate pain and other causes of suffering. Murdering someone is not a way to end their suffering, but rather only ends the 'suffering' of those who are watching - people who aren't in the least bit of medical distress.

WTF?

The "'suffering' of those watching" should have no bearing on euthanasia. It's the person's own desires that are important when it comes to their own life. And if said person believes the wide range of often ineffectual tools to eliminate pain are not helping, and that they'd rather have an end to it, who are we to prevent them?
 
Laws are archaic on this one IMHO. If you want to die, why not allow it? The standard of life at that point is not going to be good even if you're not elderly.

So any one who wants to die should be allowed to kill themselves? The teenager that think she's worthless because the love of her life dumped her. The guy that just got fired from his first job? The mother suffering postpartum depression and just can't live another day? Who adjudicates which one of these is okay to snuff themselves?
 
So any one who wants to die should be allowed to kill themselves? The teenager that think she's worthless because the love of her life dumped her. The guy that just got fired from his first job? The mother suffering postpartum depression and just can't live another day? Who adjudicates which one of these is okay to snuff themselves?
No no no. Just the old, infirm, and sick who believe, whether of their own accord or encouraged by their loving family, that they really shouldn't be a burden to anyone any more. Those who feel the world is better off without them and that they really should check out before their kids' inheritance dwindles down to nothing. Surely that's OK, innit? Like, not a thing that could possibly be wrong in any way, amirite?
 
Laws are archaic on this one IMHO. If you want to die, why not allow it? The standard of life at that point is not going to be good even if you're not elderly.

It's a slippery slope because it opens up legal spiderwebs. "I didn't murder my aunt, I simply helped her die. That's legal." "Can you prove that?" "Well, I'd say ask her, but...it's a little late."

I know I know I know, we can make contracts, we could legislate it, we could do all kinds of things... But it'd cost money for committees, we'd need tons of legal reviews plus it'd cost you the entire religious vote. There are still enough staunch believers to prevent any government that proposes it from getting to power, which means no one would ever be able to get in to pass the law.

Archaic? Sure... But also impossible to change given the current socio-economic situation.
 
No no no. Just the old, infirm, and sick who believe, whether of their own accord or encouraged by their loving family, that they really shouldn't be a burden to anyone any more. Those who feel the world is better off without them and that they really should check out before their kids' inheritance dwindles down to nothing. Surely that's OK, innit? Like, not a thing that could possibly be wrong in any way, amirite?

A disease like Auldsheimer is very difficult to tag as to when and where it is contracted. When do we allowed the old guy/gal to make that choice. After he forgets where he put his favourite sweater a point we all have experienced or maybe after his first wandering down the street, at which point it's too late for him to make that call, because he's truly not competent. How about the newly retired executive or mill worker, who isn't taking his retirement well and sees his life as near worthless, especially when his golf handicap isn't what it once was. Should he be allowed to swallow a handful of pills with his favourite Scotch.

It isn't ever that cut and dry. I've had to watch family and friends struggle with cancer, ALS, and dementia and it is not a good time for anyone. What I did find is that others around them learn a lot about the person and life in general by accompanying that person along the road to the inevitable conclusion. Most, by a large margin, of those lessons were positive ones. It is not a life choice easily made. I've mentioned before that doctors regularly struggle to balance their Hippocratic oath and the patient's comfort and care. Having said this I do believe that a person should have a final say, but make that point known early, so if others have to speak for you, and make that choice, they know how you feel and hopefully respect them. It will also be less of a burden on them to know your thoughts.
 
HAHA what a comeback. did you write for the Pat Sajak show?

Wheel of Fortune? It was the second highest rated show on CBC which blackie thinks we should continue to fund. Vanna does sound an awful lot like blackrock though didn't she?
 
We have a wide range of tools to manage and eliminate pain and other causes of suffering. Murdering someone is not a way to end their suffering, but rather only ends the 'suffering' of those who are watching - people who aren't in the least bit of medical distress.

You obviously have no idea. I watched my father suffer for months, constantly in pain because nothing short of putting him under would help. He kept saying he wished it would all end because all there was to life for him was suffering in bed.
 
So any one who wants to die should be allowed to kill themselves? The teenager that think she's worthless because the love of her life dumped her. The guy that just got fired from his first job? The mother suffering postpartum depression and just can't live another day? Who adjudicates which one of these is okay to snuff themselves?

How do you propose to stop them?

By not allowing them to kill themselves?

What punishment are you going to put on suicide, that will deter someone who is determined to commit suicide? The death penalty?

Right now, suicide is not a crime, in Canada. Nor is attempted suicide. (Assisted suicide is a crime, but that law keeps on being attacked constitutionally, and one of these days, it will be declared unconstitutional. I hope it happens before it's my turn to contract some horrible wasting painful terminal disease.