Should Canada Ban Handguns??

Should we ban handguns??

  • Yes

    Votes: 94 58.0%
  • No

    Votes: 68 42.0%

  • Total voters
    162
  • Poll closed .
Seems to me that if Canadians think they are not capable of using a handgun, then they should ban them.
 
If we are in the mood to ban things that kill people on a large scale could we please ban all cigarettes the kill exponetonally more people per year and cause far more suffering than guns could ever could (personally i dont care as long as the smoke isnt near me go ahead and kill yourself).
 
Esco! said:
Does anyone think giving cops the power to randomly search people on the street for guns is a solution????
Right now they cant do it cause its against the constitution. A cop need reasonable cause to search you.

Thugs will think twice about walking around with a piece if they can be searched at any given time



That's the whole idea they might think twice about packing . Desperate situations call for desperate measures and sometimes that means serching innocent people . The only idea politicians can come up with is to ban legal handgun ownership , what a joke. They needed tougher laws and sentences a long time ago and did nothing , now all they suggest is taking away the rights of legal owners.
 
Don't forget to ban Automobiles they kill more people even with the mandatory registry. Maybe we should ban knives to they kill a lot of people. How about extension cords, toasters & Snowshovels since we are blaming death on inanimate objects and not the people who wield them.
 
A 10 year sentance would be good. But make up a super jail on Baffin Island.

No need for all that costly security,if you can survive the bug's in the summer and the cold in the winter and still make it to civilization good luck.

Did I mention the cute,cuddly Polar Bear's? :D
 
I appologize I have not read this whole thread (too long), but

I voted yes to banning handguns, at least unlicensed ones.

If you want to end the handgun violence, make it simple, get caught with a concealed handgun in a public place, minimum 5 years, no questions asked, no mitigating circumstances, no bail, no matter if you are a minor or not.

Commit a crime with a handgun, minimum add 10 years to the normal sentence for the crime, not concurrent, just add it, again no questions asked, no mitigating circumstances, no bail, same sentence if you are a minor or not.

If you are stupid enough to be carrying a handgun for someone else, too bad. Yeh, I know there will be the bleeding hearts for the poor sap, honour student who gets caught carrying a gun for a criminal, I say too bad.

And while they are at it, remove the stupid calculation on time served. If convicted, time spent in jail waiting is just that, each day is counted as one

Some judges have proved through sentencing that they are out of touch with society's concerns, so it is best to remove some of their sentencing leeway. Hand gun sentencing should be automatic and add ons to any additional crimes, not concurrent.
 
burlboy said:
Don't forget to ban Automobiles they kill more people even with the mandatory registry. Maybe we should ban knives to they kill a lot of people. How about extension cords, toasters & Snowshovels since we are blaming death on inanimate objects and not the people who wield them.

If you have not noticed the trend this past year then you are blind. We can all sit back and listen to the inane argument that people kill people not guns or we can avoid the route the US has taken and just ban unlicensed handguns.

I have no problem with licensed handguns for the hobbiests, they are not the problem. But all other handguns should be banned.
 
dreamer said:
I have no problem with licensed handguns for the hobbiests, they are not the problem. But all other handguns should be banned.


How do you enforce this genius, Criminals don't register. A ban just makes everybody feel like they have done something when in reality nothing has changed. The only way reduce gun crime is remove the criminal from the equation, through better parenting, tougher sentencing.
 
dreamer said:
I have no problem with licensed handguns for the hobbiests, they are not the problem. But all other handguns should be banned.

All other handguns are already banned/illegal. What they are proposing is taking the registered handguns away from the licensed gun owners. This should be easy, although expensive to accomplish because the licensed gun owners are law abiding citizens.

Because a relatively small group of thugs want to carry handguns, the government is going to force the licensed gun owners to turn in their registered guns.

Would be more effective to ban SUVs, as the thugs like to carry their guns in, and do their shooting from these vehicles. SUVs serve no purpose in the city, and banning them will also save gas, and lives.
 
burlboy said:
How do you enforce this genius, Criminals don't register. A ban just makes everybody feel like they have done something when in reality nothing has changed. The only way reduce gun crime is remove the criminal from the equation, through better parenting, tougher sentencing.

Thanks for recognizing that I am a genius :)

I believe in attacking the problem from both ends, just not one.

My new catch phrase for 2006 is "too bad"

License and regulate handguns and too bad to those that feel like they are criminals. Then enforce the law and increase the penalties for those caught with an unlicensed handgun or using an handgun in a crime.

In my mind you cannot change the current trend without doing both. Think about how criminals think. I carry the handgun unloaded. My friend carries the bullets. I get caught, cry the blues, it was unloaded, I collect guns, an unloaded gun can do no harm, etc etc etc. Forget about excuses. Get caught carrying an unlicensed handgun, automatic 5 years. The onus is on the ligitimate owners of handguns (very few as a %) to separate themselves from the criminals, then crack down hard on the criminals. You either license legitimate users or ban them outright.

I do not see the problem, well except the number of people dying on our streets.

Of course our politicians have trouble dealing with simple solutions because they want to deal with all the exceptions. I say get licenced and forget about exceptions. Some people worry too much about the poor sap who has to spend 5 years in jail verses the poor victims dying on the street.

And you are right, criminals do not license their guns and that is the point of my argument. Seperate the legitimate users from the criminals then have automatic penalties for those caught.

I have no idea what the current state of our licensing system is right now. I always hear about how expensive it has been and how it has been a failure. So improve the licensing sytem to make it work and at the same time make penalties harsher and automatic.
 
KBear said:
All other handguns are already banned/illegal. What they are proposing is taking the registered handguns away from the licensed gun owners. This should be easy, although expensive to accomplish because the licensed gun owners are law abiding citizens.

If that is the case, then give them 2 months to ensure that they are licensed then no excuses. I have no problem with licensed handguns. I realize that law abiding citizens are not the problem. The real problem is that we worry about the exceptions and do not have tough enough penalties or give judges too much leeway in sentencing. I say it is better for some idiot who doesn't license his handgun to spend 5 years in jail than one person dying on our streets.

After the two month period

5 years for having an unlicensed handgun.
10 years for selling or giving someone a unlicensed handgun

Like I have said before too bad for anyone who gets caught.
 
dreamer said:
... I realize that law abiding citizens are not the problem. ..

Then you voted without understanding the issues, a common trend these days it seems.

There is no need for a 2 month grace period. All unregistered handguns are illegal, that is the way it has been for decades.

One of the guys arrested for the shooting in the city he was out on parole after serving 30 day for an armed (assumed) robbery. Could be this is a big part of the problem.
 
KBear said:
Then you voted without understanding the issues, a common trend these days it seems.

There is no need for a 2 month grace period. All unregistered handguns are illegal, that is the way it has been for decades.

I posted

I appologize I have not read this whole thread (too long), but

I voted yes to banning handguns, at least unlicensed ones.

You are right since I am riding the fence here.

If we cannot live with simple solutions like automatic penalties where people think too much about the exceptions, then I would agree with a total ban and "too bad" for law abiding citizens. If you had a total ban then you would not have to worry about the exceptions, like I just got the gun and am in the process of licensing it, or it is my friends and I am just holding it and he said he was licensed. Total ban means no exceptions, then no problem with automatic penalties.

If we can live with a simple solution like tough, automatic penalties without worrying about exceptions, then I do not think we need a ban, but we do need licensing, because without licensing we would have no means to enforce automatic penalties for those caught with an unlicensed gun.

So maybe it is the poll that is badly worded, so black and white, rather than not understanding the issues.
 
dreamer said:
...we do need licensing, because without licensing we would have no means to enforce automatic penalties for those caught with an unlicensed gun...

Currently in Canada, all handguns must be registered. All handgun owners must be licensed. These laws have been in place for decades.
 
ronzodd said:
As your post says "still dreaming"...

You are not the first and probably not the last to point that out :)

As for sitting on the fence, well that is how I feel about the subject. I could live without banning handguns as long as they impose automatic, unconditional penalties for carrying "unlicensed" handguns.

The problem though, and I do realize I probably have not explained myself properly, is that we worry too much about the "exceptions" in our criminal law. We worry too much about someone being wrongly punished or punished too severely as opposed to worrying about the victims.

In this debate the victims are actually dying.

To impose such unconditional laws such as automatic five years for possession of a handgun, it is probably best to have such a law where handguns are banned outright. That way you do not have to worry about the exceptions and not allow leeway for judges.

For example, a white middle aged man is caught with a handgun outside of his home. He apologizes and said he received it as a gift from an american friend and he intended on licensing it. Most would say that he does not deserve 5 years. A young blank man is caught with a handgun in a busy nightclub. He apologizes and said he received it as a gift from an american friend and he intended on licensing it. What would most say about that.

So my point is that it is easier to impose harsh and automatic penalties for something that is banned 100%, that way the white middle class man would not have an excuse.
 
Banning handguns wont solve the problem. Anyone who thinks it will make any real difference is deluding themselves. Stiffer penalties for illegal firearms of all types; and stiffer penalties for use of firearms in crime I am up for; but even that won't make a big difference. As someone else has commented, these recent brazen shootings is because the shooters don't give a shit anymore.
 
George OTJ said:
Banning handguns wont solve the problem. Anyone who thinks it will make any real difference is deluding themselves. Stiffer penalties for illegal firearms of all types; and stiffer penalties for use of firearms in crime I am up for; but even that won't make a big difference. As someone else has commented, these recent brazen shootings is because the shooters don't give a shit anymore.

Amen... banning handguns wont do a damn thing... thats like trying to cure cancer with a bandaid
 
George OTJ said:
Banning handguns wont solve the problem. Anyone who thinks it will make any real difference is deluding themselves. Stiffer penalties for illegal firearms of all types; and stiffer penalties for use of firearms in crime I am up for; but even that won't make a big difference. As someone else has commented, these recent brazen shootings is because the shooters don't give a shit anymore.

The shooters dont give a shit anymore because they know they can get away with it,plain and simple,if we kick out Martin and his gang of soft on violent crime Liberals and do the same to Mayor Miller and his cronies,and elect people who will enact tough laws AND make the Courts enforce them,then youll see what a change that will make on how much they give a shit!!
 
Ok, this is one hell of a long post. So I did not read all of it.

But I don't think anyone has suggested that THE REAL ANSWER might be in education,discipline and support.

Teach someone the rights and wrongs, lay down discipline and punishment when they get out of line and help them out (this is what the government should do) so that they don't have to struggle desperately just to stay alive. And more than likely, they will create a better, productive life for themselves and others.

As I see it. These three things are lacking and where they are needed the most. In our schools. If some kid misbehaves. Teachers should punish them. If they don't want to learn, then give them a mop and tell them to clean the bathroom "cause thats the only thing you'll be qualified to do if you don't learn." That should give them an eye opener at least.

As for handguns. They were still legal several years ago when we did not have so much violence. So they must not be the underlying issue.

Since things look pretty grim right now, another (crazy) idea might be to give out handguns to every individual that is tested to be sane and intelligent enough to "use them properly and wisely." Meaning that if any punk pull out a gun, there would be am armed citizen or two to swiftly put a stop to it. It would be a way of 'leveling the field.' Might make some criminals and idiot 'gangsta' wannabes think twice on shooting up the neighborhood.

(yeah I know it's crazy, but there hasn't been much sanity on our streets as of late either).
 
An article in NOW magazine a few weeks back had stats that of crimes committed with a handgun, 75% of the time, then gun was obtained illegally.

Banning handguns is a start... but I believe will hardly make a dent since most handguns are illegal. We all know that making something illegal does not necessarily reduce usage (ex. the U.S. "war on drugs").