Should Canada Ban Handguns??

Should we ban handguns??

  • Yes

    Votes: 94 58.0%
  • No

    Votes: 68 42.0%

  • Total voters
    162
  • Poll closed .
Regardless of what the pro hand gun people on this forum say, they aren't going to change Judas H's position on this matter. His comment that "he doesn't care about the rights of law abiding gun owners", "there is no real purpose of a hand gun" and "human beings should not have a right to have a hand gun" are his opinions.
So, lets take it one step further. Are we going to disarm Brinks and ATM employees? Are we going to stop Canada customs officers from carrying hand guns and what about Ontario Park/Conservation officers and private citizens that work in remote Northern Ontario and legally carry hand guns for protection from wild animals? As Judas H states, "human beings should not have a right to have a hand gun". Maybe we should take them all away from the humans and give them to the animals.
 
oldjones said:
Just a question. First of all: the new law's not passed yet, so you're wrong about the Yonge St. stuff. Second: As long as I've been aware, and as other's have pointed out, one could only own a handgun in this country if you obtained a special permit to do so. So just when was this wonderful time when we could own handguns and Yonge St had no shootings? 1837?


OK I can see I need to spell this out . I meant we could always own handguns as long as we passed the test and obtained the proper license , I didn't mean we could just walk in to Macs milk and buy one . I thought this was obvious but I guess not. And during all this time since I was a kid and used to hang around downtown , which was over 35 yrs ago did they ever have shootings .
 
Fuck You're good, a worthy opponent...

onondaga said:
So, lets take it one step further. Are we going to disarm Brinks and ATM employees?

No, Special requirements will be needed for these people.

onondaga said:
Are we going to stop Canada customs officers from carrying hand guns
As far as I know Custom officers aren't allowed to have hand guns. These are the very people that should be carring hand guns, They are protecting our border.
onondaga said:
and what about Ontario Park/Conservation officers and private citizens that work in remote Northern Ontario and legally carry hand guns for protection from wild animals?
Why can't these people use a rifle and a knife, What need do they have for a hand gun?

onondaga said:
As Judas H states, "human beings should not have a right to have a hand gun". Maybe we should take them all away from the humans and give them to the animals.
The only animal I trust with a gun is a fish...I agree lets give them to the fish.
 
booboobear said:
OK I can see I need to spell this out . I meant we could always own handguns as long as we passed the test and obtained the proper license , I didn't mean we could just walk in to Macs milk and buy one . I thought this was obvious but I guess not. And during all this time since I was a kid and used to hang around downtown , which was over 35 yrs ago did they ever have shootings .
Fine. Nothing significant about owning/buying/permitting handguns has changed since then—so 'splain please howcum this has any connection at all to what happened on Yonge Street.
 
In response to your comment, Judas H re " there is no real purpose of a hand gun" I would like to comment as follows:

I have talked to numerous land surveyors, forestry workers, prospectors, trappers and landowners who work in remote areas of Northern Ontario and other parts of Canada. They tell me that while carrying a heavy backpack and other equipment, they find that carrying a long gun is impractical. Now remember, these are private citizens that have gone thru extensive government imposed training as required under present Canadian law. These workers have been granted an ATC for the purposes of protecting their lives while working in remote areas of the province. Their weapon of choice is a heavy magnum hand gun. If I were staring down a 250 pound black bear at less than 30 feet, I would certainly like to have the privilage (not the right) to carry a hand gun, especially after the numerous/recent black bear attacks in the province.
 
onondaga said:
In response to your comment, Judas H re " there is no real purpose of a hand gun" I would like to comment as follows:

I have talked to numerous land surveyors, forestry workers, prospectors, trappers and landowners who work in remote areas of Northern Ontario and other parts of Canada. They tell me that while carrying a heavy backpack and other equipment, they find that carrying a long gun is impractical. Now remember, these are private citizens that have gone thru extensive government imposed training as required under present Canadian law. These workers have been granted an ATC for the purposes of protecting their lives while working in remote areas of the province. Their weapon of choice is a heavy magnum hand gun. If I were staring down a 250 pound black bear at less than 30 feet, I would certainly like to have the privilage (not the right) to carry a hand gun, especially after the numerous/recent black bear attacks in the province.

Let them learn hoe to use a blow gun with poisonous darts...These things are light enough to carry on a back pack.

Someone in that position will figure out a way to adapt if a shotgun is too heavy.

NEXT....
 
Wow...

...seems like every time I jump in here these days you guys north of my border are just getting heavily into some of the issues that your friends to the south have dealt with, learned from and frankly, have often gotten wrong. Learn from your American friends!!!! Guns are not the problem....CRIMINAL intent is!!!!!! Gun control simply is not the solution. Please, please, take that as contructive advice from a well meaning, liberal friend from the US. Yes, I am a liberal, I believe that gun toting fools are often just that...fools. But the statistical evidence does not support the efficacy of gun laws significantly reducing violent crimes. I was very saddened at the ridiculous news that Toronto has had as many killings as it has this year. We are very accostomed to such in the major cities in the states, and now it is creeping northward. I agree with some, that maybe enforcement of current laws, or stricter sentencing is a partial solution, but immigration (that nasty 11 letter word) and culture is another big problem. And that is the war we are now deeply involved in in the states. And that is NOT to say that this is a racial issue, because it's not. Canada has had many different groups from different backgrounds living side by side without problem for years & years. The common thread was that they shared a belief system that emphasized respect, basic decency & a live & let live attitude (and that is by people of all colors). Now what has been introduced as of late is a new culture that does not share those values, and some of it is brought from the outside by people immigrating to your great country, and by some people that profit and make their way around this world by creating cancerous cultures (and that is by people of all colors). Assimilation of this new culture and immigrant population that obviously is not living by the standards that make your country what it is, needs to be done with all deliberation, care & attention to the real problems it brings. In the US, we threw money (school systems, after school programs, social programs), jail time, death penalties, gun laws, speedier judicial adjudication, self-righteousness, bulletin boards, fire & brimstone speeches to help curb the problem of violence. But we never addressed problems of culture and immigration bringing values that were out of step with a healthy, productive, RESPECTFUL and safe society we claimed to cherish. Careful understanding and assimilation of cultures and diverse new populations is critical.
 
oldjones said:
Fine. Nothing significant about owning/buying/permitting handguns has changed since then—so 'splain please howcum this has any connection at all to what happened on Yonge Street.


Exactly that's the whole point nothing has changed for people who own guns legally . The difference is now criminals are shooting people on Yonge street and people think that by stopping LEGAL handgun ownership it will stop the crooks.
I think we need to look at why it is happening now and stop blaming legal handguns I think the smart people realize that this is another political answer to crime. How about real punishment for someone caught with an illegal gun like flogging , maybe these punks would like to see how it feels to be on the receiving end.
 
onondaga said:
In response to your comment, Judas H re " there is no real purpose of a hand gun" I would like to comment as follows:

I have talked to numerous land surveyors, forestry workers, prospectors, trappers and landowners who work in remote areas of Northern Ontario and other parts of Canada. They tell me that while carrying a heavy backpack and other equipment, they find that carrying a long gun is impractical. Now remember, these are private citizens that have gone thru extensive government imposed training as required under present Canadian law. These workers have been granted an ATC for the purposes of protecting their lives while working in remote areas of the province. Their weapon of choice is a heavy magnum hand gun. If I were staring down a 250 pound black bear at less than 30 feet, I would certainly like to have the privilage (not the right) to carry a hand gun, especially after the numerous/recent black bear attacks in the province.
Ya, urban development sucks, poor bears :(
 
booboobear said:
Exactly that's the whole point nothing has changed for people who own guns legally . The difference is now criminals are shooting people on Yonge street and people think that by stopping LEGAL handgun ownership it will stop the crooks.
I think we need to look at why it is happening now and stop blaming legal handguns I think the smart people realize that this is another political answer to crime. How about real punishment for someone caught with an illegal gun like flogging , maybe these punks would like to see how it feels to be on the receiving end.
Only idiots blame legal or illegal handguns for what's happening. Any connection's as spurious as your earlier assertion that "For years when we could own handguns people did not run around Yonge street shooting people ." Or imagining that bizarrely cruel punishment (or any threat of punishment) deters anyone stupid enough to carry a gun. It's all just rhetoric tuned to impress people who don't think.

Now ask me if I think any private person should be permitted to own a hand gun. Answer: No. But don't assume I'm dumb enough to think that solves some kinda crime problem.
 
As for Judas, well thanks for not replying to my reply.

But I had to say something. Before meeting these new friends of mine, I was of the same mindset, ban all guns, etc,etc.
But after meeting them and seeing how they handle them and the kind of care and responsibility they show. I am not anti-gun anymore, but I'm not pro-gun either. I'm just more along the lines of, every person has their rights. If they're responsible enough and pass the required tests and certifications.
Step 1. PAL (Possession Aquisition License)
Police organized, with background checks. An 8½x16 sheet of multiple papers, with various questions. Sent to the CFO, who approves or disapproves the application. If you get it, see step 2.
If you answer a question improperly have any sort of criminal act, etc, they may deem you unfit.
Also, if for example say you had a recent divorce, got fired, had a recent litigation in which you lost, etc, etc.
(talking to my friend as we speak typing this).
Step 2. Join a club - you have to go through a safety course at the club (12 weeks is the norm).

So you see the steps, required?
Also, the gun can ONLY be in the car, when going TO AND FROM the club, nowhere else.
If you're at a buddies house and regardless if you take the gun with you inside his house. If you're caught, you will get charged.
It has to be in the trunk while driving to the club and back home. (no stopping at a restaurant for a dinner either).
Rules are pretty strict.

Like I said, I'm not pro-gun or anti-gun. I was anti-gun, till I saw the kinds of responsibilities that came with it and experienced it first hand.
 
Hey Judas

Now come-on Judas H, that latest reponse of your's re blow-guns and darts is totally out of character for you. Up until now I have enjoyed debating this topic with you and have respected your position on this matter, however if you are going to make silly comments, I'm inclined to take booboobear's and CuteCob's postion and end my participation in this debate. It's been a blast (no pun intended) Bye-Bye for now.
 
onondaga said:
Now come-on Judas H, that latest reponse of your's re blow-guns and darts is totally out of character for you. Up until now I have enjoyed debating this topic with you and have respected your position on this matter, however if you are going to make silly comments, I'm inclined to take booboobear's and CuteCob's postion and end my participation in this debate. It's been a blast (no pun intended) Bye-Bye for now.

What do you want me to say, How many attacks have bears have attacked land surveyors in this past year?

You are worrying about something that rarely happens. I believe that HAND GUNS and AUTOMATIC WEAPONS should be banned. Not all weapons!
 
There's no hope for Judas.
Just sticking to his guns, regardless of the points set before him.
Oh the sticking to his guns, pun intended. :)
 
CuteCob said:
As for Judas, well thanks for not replying to my reply.

But I had to say something. Before meeting these new friends of mine, I was of the same mindset, ban all guns, etc,etc.
But after meeting them and seeing how they handle them and the kind of care and responsibility they show. I am not anti-gun anymore, but I'm not pro-gun either. I'm just more along the lines of, every person has their rights. If they're responsible enough and pass the required tests and certifications.
Step 1. PAL (Possession Aquisition License)
Police organized, with background checks. An 8½x16 sheet of multiple papers, with various questions. Sent to the CFO, who approves or disapproves the application. If you get it, see step 2.
If you answer a question improperly have any sort of criminal act, etc, they may deem you unfit.
Also, if for example say you had a recent divorce, got fired, had a recent litigation in which you lost, etc, etc.
(talking to my friend as we speak typing this).
Step 2. Join a club - you have to go through a safety course at the club (12 weeks is the norm).

So you see the steps, required?
Also, the gun can ONLY be in the car, when going TO AND FROM the club, nowhere else.
If you're at a buddies house and regardless if you take the gun with you inside his house. If you're caught, you will get charged.
It has to be in the trunk while driving to the club and back home. (no stopping at a restaurant for a dinner either).
Rules are pretty strict.

Like I said, I'm not pro-gun or anti-gun. I was anti-gun, till I saw the kinds of responsibilities that came with it and experienced it first hand.
For Judas, once again, in case you missed it.
 
CuteCob said:
For Judas, once again, in case you missed it.



Once again in case you missed it.

So what if they have to take precautions...It doesn't make a difference to me if they have to lock it and double stamp it with no erasies.

A teenager can get to that gun and so can a criminal.

I think ALL guns should be banned.
 
Judas H said:
Once again in case you missed it.

So what if they have to take precautions...It doesn't make a difference to me if they have to lock it and double stamp it with no erasies.

A teenager can get to that gun and so can a criminal.

I think ALL guns should be banned.

You have no idea how hard it is to break into a safe do you?
Plus the case with a lock, then there's the trigger lock.
You have got to wake up and stop thinking in a one track mindset.
It's NOT THE LEGIT guns that are doing the killings.
Btw, people kill not guns.
 
Judas H said:
Let them learn hoe to use a blow gun with poisonous darts...These things are light enough to carry on a back pack.

Someone in that position will figure out a way to adapt if a shotgun is too heavy.

NEXT....


Maybe you could reason with the bear and he won't attack. Or just tell him you don't believe in handguns.