Does anyone really imagine they're making a positive contribution by denouncing a post or poster with a label such as 'shill'? Surely not.
Anyone likely to believe the judgment already reached that conclusion themselves. Without evidence, no undecideds will be persuaded. The end result is most often a poorer reflection on the name-caller.
From time to time some folks have used humour to suggest we shouldn't take some post at face-value, and I can see that as making an actual contribution. But no one has credentials as a Certified Shill Assessor, and credibility is lessened by anger, not increased.
But it probably feels good to vent some of the envy and bitterness.
Anyone likely to believe the judgment already reached that conclusion themselves. Without evidence, no undecideds will be persuaded. The end result is most often a poorer reflection on the name-caller.
From time to time some folks have used humour to suggest we shouldn't take some post at face-value, and I can see that as making an actual contribution. But no one has credentials as a Certified Shill Assessor, and credibility is lessened by anger, not increased.
But it probably feels good to vent some of the envy and bitterness.

