seen Stamkos going to bust?

21pro said:
you'd think with all of the fire power on Tampa Bay and all that PP time he'd have atleast an assist, no?



5 seasons in a row now I've been giving my preseason picks for Calder, Point Scoring, Goal Scoring, Prez trophy and Stanley Cup winner. some use it for debate, some use it for fantasy picks. some question why? :rolleyes back at you: lol!

I'm not anti-Stamkos... not even criticizing him. I just thought I'd position the issue in front of everyone to see their take. I said prior to his draft that I don't see the same level of talent in him as what Tampa Bay based their 'seen Stamkos' PR campaign on. He is much more Bobby Ryan than Sidney Crosby. If you remember, they went #1 and #2 in 2005. Tampa is basing the face of the franchise around this kid... Lecavalier is 10x's the star this kid will ever become.
I think Drew Doughty and Luke Schenn shoulda went higher than Stamkos... alone on this, i know... check back in 5 years and see how stupid this thread is.

You are not even giving this kid a chance. He is 18 years old for crying out loud. He might not be as big and strong as Lecavalier and it took Vince a few years to come around. He was not an immediate impact player. but this kid has loads of talent. He can flat out play the game. Have you ever seen him play or are you going by the stat sheet? I really hope he makes you eat your words.

BTW, Lecavalier had 28 points in 82 games in his first season. :eek:
Look how great he has become. Tampa Bay did suck royally back then but they sucked big time last year as well.

You seem to have quite the grasp of hockey knowledge but now I have my doubts.
 
lawyerman said:
You are not even giving this kid a chance. He is 18 years old for crying out loud. He might not be as big and strong as Lecavalier and it took Vince a few years to come around. He was not an immediate impact player. but this kid has loads of talent. He can flat out play the game. Have you ever seen him play or are you going by the stat sheet? I really hope he makes you eat your words.

BTW, Lecavalier had 28 points in 82 games in his first season. :eek:
Look how great he has become. Tampa Bay did suck royally back then but they sucked big time last year as well.

You seem to have quite the grasp of hockey knowledge but now I have my doubts.

Also, one should take into account his ice time so far.

Game 1 8.25 mins total (0.00 power play time)
Game 2 14.53 mins total (3.15 power play time)
Game 3 6.05 mins total (0.24 power play time)

Not sure why we are even having this discussion at this point? Hell, Joe Thornton had 7 points in 55 games for the Bruins during his rookie season.
 
blueline said:
Also, one should take into account his ice time so far.

Game 1 8.25 mins total (0.00 power play time)
Game 2 14.53 mins total (3.15 power play time)
Game 3 6.05 mins total (0.24 power play time)

Not sure why we are even having this discussion at this point? Hell, Joe Thornton had 7 points in 55 games for the Bruins during his rookie season.

You made very valid and great points blueline. Thank you.

I think I'm going to head to the Rail. :D
 
lawyerman said:
You made very valid and great points blueline. Thank you.

I think I'm going to head to the Rail. :D

Well, I may be headed out to the bridge sometime tonight........ lol
 
lawyerman said:
You are not even giving this kid a chance. He is 18 years old for crying out loud. He might not be as big and strong as Lecavalier and it took Vince a few years to come around. He was not an immediate impact player. but this kid has loads of talent. He can flat out play the game. Have you ever seen him play or are you going by the stat sheet? I really hope he makes you eat your words.

1. his ice time is where it should be. 15mins or less per game.
2. I've seen Stamkos play many times. As I said, he reminds me of Bobby Ryan.

keep in mind. the topic discussion posed was not a personal point of view.

I do think it is rediculous how the new TB owners based this season around this kid in all of their promo, etc... Not even Sidney Crosby was exposed to that in Pittsburgh... rather it was the Canadian media that went all over him.
 
I don't really care about how the new Tampa ownership group has promoted Stamkos. Again, he might nit be in the same league as a Lecavalier or Thornton but the kid is an offensive dynamo. I hope he translates that to the NHL game and I believe that he will be successful.

Give the KID a break. He will be better than Bobby Ryan. That is a guarantee.

To say that you have seen him many times and put him down like that is laughable. He dominated the O but I guess that's not good enough.

I do respect your posts 21pro and you seem to know quite a bit about the game but don't tell me that you have seen many games that Stamkos has played. If you really did see as many games as you claim you did then you would be impressed.
 
21pro said:
1. his ice time is where it should be. 15mins or less per game.
2. I've seen Stamkos play many times. As I said, he reminds me of Bobby Ryan.

keep in mind. the topic discussion posed was not a personal point of view.

I do think it is rediculous how the new TB owners based this season around this kid in all of their promo, etc... Not even Sidney Crosby was exposed to that in Pittsburgh... rather it was the Canadian media that went all over him.

Huh, can you explain your middle sentence, did someone break into your computer, use your handle and post this without your consent?:confused:
 
guyroch said:
Sorry if I am reapeating a post ... Haven't read previous page ...

Didn't the orginal Lighting owners refer to Lecavalier as the Micheal Jordon of
Hockey ... Lecavalier also started off slow and so lets give this situation time ... I think Sidney living up to the hype so fast makes us all think that all franchise players will do the samething ....

On the subject of " Bust "

Jiri Tlusty .... Is he still in the NHL ??? Oh yea I hear still plays for the Leafs : How about " Steen " when does potentional turn into Bust ..

Hey don't pick on Jiri. He is going to have an awesome career...... AS A PORN STAR!!!!

As far as Stamkos being a bust, that kind of talk is stupid. I have not seen the guy play in the NHL yet, but given that he was a stud in Junior and performed well in the WJC, I think it stupid to consider him a bust at this point. I am sure more was expected of him, and it is disappointing that he has not shown the coaches enough to earn more ice time... but a bust? Way too early...

Alexandre Daigle anyone... oh sorry... bad example...:p
 
BallzDeep said:
Huh, can you explain your middle sentence, did someone break into your computer, use your handle and post this without your consent?:confused:

well, i don't personally consider him a bust. but some are already in the media and in the tampa area. but, i do consider him to be a less than all-star talent. he is playing exactly as i expected him to.

big tall centers usually take a while to get coordinated in the nhl and hence why Thornton, Lecavalier and Jordan Staal have and are taking a while to develop. Stamkos is not in this group. he's under 200lbs and 6'1" not 6'4" or 6'5"... not to mention JT and VL started their careers in the 'clutch and grab' peak of the late nineties... Staal, in his rookie year, even managed to lead the league in short handed goals, break a record as the most shorthanded goals scored in 1 game, the youngest player ever to have scored a hat trick, record for most short handed goals as a rookie. Staal didn't even finish in top 2 for Calder votes and his play is better examplified as a rookie breaking into the post-lockout nhl era.

Stamkos is a bit more similar in size to Peter Stastny who got 6 pts in his first 4 games as an 18 year old. or Crosby (102 pts as a rookie), or Mike Richards (who was drafted 24th overall and got 4 points in his first 4 games as an nhl'er.)

Stamkos watch: 4 games played and 0 pts., -1.

36 rookies have already recorded their 1st nhl point this season. Stamkos is a goal scorer? 7 rookies already have multiple goals.

bendova said:
I guess Crosby is washed up. Only 2 pts in 4 games on pace for 40 pts. With all the firepower in Pittsburg should he not have more points than that. I guess no Hart for him....
Are you on crack? Crosby has 4pts in 5 games playing without his top 2 pointmen on D. he is not playing on the stacked PowerPlay Tampa Bay has right now.
 
Melrose trying hard to get this kid going:

getting over 2 minutes of Power Play time on Saturday night didn't do much, either.

*was the team highest TOI for PP.

he ended another game as a -2.

geez... and people in Toronto are saying Schenn should go back to jr?? I say Stamkos is the one that should need to be re-signed back to junior. If he was a movie premiere, I'd say--- you'r going straight to DVD, pal!

Regarding Luke Schenn:
guyroch said:
Can somebody please tell me why he anyone would want this guy to stay up ...

new2game said:
Schenn is physically not ready to handle the strength of good NHL grinders in the corners
lawyerman said:
Let the kid try and dominate the other kids in junior. This would (hopefully) help his offensive game to be a better all-around defenceman.

I don't understand what the rush is to bring him up ot the big club.
MojoRisin' said:
I love what the Leafs have in Schenn but he is not ready nor should they rush him. he is the one good thing they have done recently and putting him in this losing environment will not be good for him or the Leafs. he is playing well but he should not be in the NHL yet
gladheateher said:
the kid isn't ready yet.
tribunus said:
Send him back to the WHL. Nothing to be gained by keeping Schenn around.
plyrs99 said:
the leafs have up to 9 NHL games to keep schenn, and that is exactly what they should do. when those 9 games are up, send him back to junior, let him play regularly, give him his last chance to play in the WJC's.
 
21pro said:
Melrose trying hard to get this kid going:

getting over 2 minutes of Power Play time on Saturday night didn't do much, either.

*was the team highest TOI for PP.

he ended another game as a -2.

geez... and people in Toronto are saying Schenn should go back to jr??

I think that most people (myself included) are convinced that Schenn should stay up with the big club. He hs certainly earned it. I think that many people were scared to keep him up here because the Leafs are almost certain to tank this year, he is not offensive minded and this will crush his 18 year old ego. He has proven that he should be here to stay. The main problem with Schenn is his speed but he plays his position very well that he can overcome his hinderance at times. I can certainly tell that he will not burn up the ice with his speed. It will get him into trouble but the coaching staff seems to have a handle on him already.

As far as Stamkos goes, it is way too early to put the concensus on him.

As of right now, the Lightning has only scored 11 goals in 7 games. :eek:
That is dreadful and pathetic but they should break out of this slump sooner than later. They have some talent on this team and they need to find their niche. I still can't believe they brought in Barry Melrose who was crap 15 years ago and is still crap today.

They are playing the Leafs tomorrow and many people don't realize (or forget) that the opposing teams really get pumped playing against the Leafs because of the coverage the Leafs get and how much family will be watching the game whether it be live or on television.

It will be interesting to see how Stamkos plays. I haven't seen him play much this year so I can't judge just yet.
 
perhaps I should say that for all of the reasoning behind the arguments to send Schenn back to the WHL, I agreed with your points the most. ie, what's the rush? but, I do agree - he has fully earned his spot. That won't mean that he will be without many tribulations and tests he'll have to overcome. Surely, these will just come quicker.

and as for Tuesday night, expect the unexpected... whatever that means. :rolleyes:

Stamkos should get on the scoreboard, if not for anything- his local Canadian crowd...

with Schenn- yeah, he's not fast, but either is Nick Lidstrom. (not a comparison by any stretch, of course)... but, both do have a mastery over controlling angles. they both excel at slowing down the opposition's entry. For Schenn to know how to time this in the NHL already is quite amazing.
 
Schenn has been such a pleasant surprise and I really had no doubt about his abilities. It took me by surprise that he is playing well so quickly.

I believe that people wanted him to go back is because we have seen Leafs management and coaches ruin the confidence of potentially very good young players and we did not want to see the same thing for Schenn. I know that's the way I felt.
 
This post is for all the Yahoos who wanted the Leafs to Tank Last Season

This post is one of the reasons why tanking games to get the 1st pick is a fools errand. Insert Forrest Gump Quote Here
 
slowandeasy said:
This post is one of the reasons why tanking games to get the 1st pick is a fools errand. Insert Forrest Gump Quote Here

How about - 'Stupid is as stupid does'. :p
 
or how about Schenn > Stamkos and Fletcher did his job.
 
King Elessar said:
Is it remotely possible that it's too early to make this call?


my thoughts exactly. stamkos has been put in a situation where he can only fail. with schenn, he has no pressure on him at this time. i am not talking about the player's skill or if they deserve to be in the NHL, AHL or junior's, just stating a fact.

melrose is in a bind, as with the money the new owners in TB have spent, they are expecting to win, and do it NOW. if melrose is looking out for himself, then he has to rely on the vets, and work stamkos in slowly. obviously, this does not work out for stamkos. either he gets quality ice time consistently, or send him back.

Plyrs99
 
Stamkos is on a friggin' power play with Vinny Lecavalier, Martin St. Louis, Vinny Prospal, etc...

Stamkos put in a situation where he can only fail?

and Schenn playing in Toronto is in a market with absolutely no pressure?

wtf?