seen Stamkos going to bust?

Stamkos was quoted today:

"For the first time in my life

I hope the leafs Lose"




21pro - don't worry 'bout Stevie S he'll be fine. It's way, waaaay to early in his career to even ponder him being a bust.


.
 
21pro said:
Stamkos is on a friggin' power play with Vinny Lecavalier, Martin St. Louis, Vinny Prospal, etc...

Stamkos put in a situation where he can only fail?

and Schenn playing in Toronto is in a market with absolutely no pressure?

wtf?

I was thinking the same thing 21pro.

Stamkos has been given opportunities and even though I might not agree with the ice time that Melrose has been giving the kid, he has been given a pretty fair shot.

Like I said before, playing in Toronto is like playing under a microscope. It is the most difficult city to play in. I am not trying to defend the poster but he might have meant that Tampa is brutal even with some of the players they have now and the Leafs expectations this year.......well, they are really not expected to do anything this year but the Leafs gave up quite a bit to move up in the draft order to draft Schenn so there is pressure on him to succeed. In addition, he is with the big club now and that means many people are expecting big things from Schenn.
 
For a second, look at the league's youngest ever player Jordan Staal's rookie season. He played less than Stamkos' ice time... didn't play with Crosby or Malkin and most of his time was played on a 4th line with checkers and a little specialty time on the PK. And, Staal wasn't a 1st overall pick.

I don't want to make a Staal/Stamkos comparison, but I'm making an argument for the fact that Melrose is giving Stamkos more than fair ice time.

rayfinkel said:
It's way, waaaay to early in his career to even ponder him being a bust.
bust for rookie of the year, a bust for all of the 'Seen Stamkos?' promo bs, a bust for all the media guys saying that he's going to get 100pts in his rookie campaign, etc.... not a bust for his entire career. That is my point.
 
21pro said:
For a second, look at the league's youngest ever player Jordan Staal's rookie season. He played less than Stamkos' ice time... didn't play with Crosby or Malkin and most of his time was played on a 4th line with checkers and a little specialty time on the PK. And, Staal wasn't a 1st overall pick.

I don't want to make a Staal/Stamkos comparison, but I'm making an argument for the fact that Melrose is giving Stamkos more than fair ice time.


bust for rookie of the year, a bust for all of the 'Seen Stamkos?' promo bs, a bust for all the media guys saying that he's going to get 100pts in his rookie campaign, etc.... not a bust for his entire career. That is my point.

Staal was getting a fair share of ice time with the Pens but he wasn't getting practically any power play time. Spare me with the crap about Staal not being a first overall pick. He was second overall that could have easily been first overall.

Stamkos never asked to be promoted the way that he is. I'm not sure why you don't like him. He is very talented and should break through soon enough.
People expect so much and it's only the beginning of the season. I never expected to get 100 points this year but I think he will be fine.
 
guyroch said:
Well 2 goals and 1 assists in just 13 mins ... Give this guy some ice timeand lets see what he can do ... Lets not forget this guy isn't used to sitting on the bench for long periods of time and then always going out their cold ...

Even LeCavalier's ice time is low. Many nights he has been under 20 minutes. Pierre Maguire was commenting on that the other night and even asked LeCavalier about it during an interview.
 
lawyerman said:
Staal was getting a fair share of ice time with the Pens <October 2006 average TOI was 5:53 minutes per game>but he wasn't getting practically any power play time <you are correct - but where do most points come from?>. Spare me with the crap about Staal not being a first overall pick. <sorry, i thought i was correct that Staal was picked #2 and rated #6.>He was second overall that could have easily been first overall.

Stamkos never asked to be promoted the way that he is. I'm not sure why you don't like him. <Oh, I do like him, but don't like how he was touted to be a star in the league when he clearly won't be> He is very talented and should break through soon enough.
People expect so much and it's only the beginning of the season. I never expected to get 100 points this year but I think he will be fine.
It is fun debating with you, but don't get the wrong idea of me... I do like Stamkos as a 40 point guy as a rookie- but not a 40 goal scorer like he's expected to do. I could be wrong, but that happens on occasion... fortunately for you, it happens to me alot ;)

How much do you expect him to get? the top rookie forwards of the last few seasons have all been +60 point players... is he in this cohort?

to put things in perspective for now, Stamkos is playing as well as Kyle Wellwood, who was put on waivers 2 weeks ago. They are also similar in size and similar in their respective roles to their team(s)

Wellwood 6gp 3g 1a 13:39 minutes per game
Stamkos 9gp 2g 2a 11:39 minutes per game
 
Last edited:
21pro said:
It is fun debating with you, but don't get the wrong idea of me... I do like Stamkos as a 40 point guy as a rookie- but not a 40 goal scorer like he's expected to do. I could be wrong, but that happens on occasion... fortunately for you, it happens to me alot

How much do you expect him to get? the top rookie forwards of the last few seasons have all been +60 point players... is he in this cohort?

to put things in perspective for now, Stamkos is playing as well as Kyle Wellwood, who was put on waivers 2 weeks ago. They are also similar in size and similar in their respective roles to their team(s)

Wellwood 6gp 3g 1a 13:39 minutes per game
Stamkos 9gp 2g 2a 11:39 minutes per game

I think that this is a very good debate. I am not expecting 40 goals from Stamkos but I think he should be able to score more than 40 points.

I'm not sure where Wellwood sits in the equation. :confused: Stamkos is just starting out and you are comparing him to a guy that played as an overage player in juniors and could not make it with the big club right away either.
Wellwood starting playing with the Leafs when he was about 22 years old.
Stamkos is 18.

Forget about the comparisons. I just think that Stamkos should be a hell of a player in this league. He has decent strength, plenty of speed, puckhandling skills, great passer and he can fire the puck.

I don't want to compare him with anyone. I don't think he will take over the league but he should be successful.
 
you might find this ironic, though- in 5-6 years I can see Stamkos in the top 3 in goal scoring for a few seasons. He is, afterall, a natural goal scorer.
 
21pro said:
you might find this ironic, though- in 5-6 years I can see Stamkos in the top 3 in goal scoring for a few seasons. He is, afterall, a natural goal scorer.

I'm not saying anything yet but I have seen him play quite a bit and I am impressed. If he can build his strength, he should be a high calibre NHLer.
 
Through the club's cutesy "Seen Stamkos?" promotional campaign, he was essentially touted before stepping on the ice as the next Sidney Crosby, not that different than the day when another Lightning owner called Vincent Lecavalier hockey's Michael Jordan. The former Sarnia Sting forward is already being heralded as a contender for this year's Calder Trophy.

...gaining a little momentum now- i'm glad to see.

4pts in 10 games - now on pace for 30 points. 18th in rookie scoring.
 
I looked into my crystal ball and it says he's going to have 8 or 9 seasons where he gets 80 or 90 points and then slow decline. He'll be fine.
 
... like Alexandre Daigle, right?
 
Stamkos playing even LESS ice time now in post-Melrose Lightning world.
 
hey 21pro,

when i made my statement that stamkos was put in a situation where he could only fail, what was so hard to understand about it? the promotions TB made with him all summer long, the fact they basically tanked the end of the year to get him, the fact that he was hands down the consensus number one in his draft year, all year long. if he didn't produce about 20-25 goals along with 75-80 points in his rookie year, he will have been seen as a dissappointment. playing in that mess that is TB is definitely not helping him.

as for schenn, he came in with nobody expecting him to be "the man", the last piece of the puzzle, etc;. expectations this year were low for the team in general, and hopes for schenn were only that the leafs did not ruin him as they had done with other top defensemen prospects over the years. anything schenn would do if he stayed up, would be deemed a success. the fact that he has played as he has, being in all likeliness, the leafs best defensive d-man so far, is all a bonus for the team this year. the leafs outlook for schenn was for him to one day be their anchor on the blueline, but for the future, not this year. i think if the leafs squad the last few years prior to this had drafted schenn, then yes, he would have had the pressure on him amplified.

comparing stamkos and schenn is not easy either, as stamkos will always be gauged purely on stats, while the schenn, on defensive prowess. schenn will never be a prolific scorer on the blueline.

the comparisons with daigle are not fair either. daigle was immensely talented, but was not in love with the game of hockey. remember when he left the game for awhile? he stated he didn't have the passion for the game. stamkos cetainly enjoys the game, there is no issue there. how did "jumbo" joe thornton do in his first year?

Plyrs99
 
plyrs99 said:
how did "jumbo" joe thornton do in his first year?

about as good as any 6'4" lanky playmaker / passer is expected to...

pure goal scorers, though... they simply should be scoring.... some just don't get the big NHL game.

Stamkos hasn't improved with more ice time over the 1st half season. When's he gonna break out and become the expected consensus rookie of the year?
 
21pro said:
about as good as any 6'4" lanky playmaker / passer is expected to...

pure goal scorers, though... they simply should be scoring.... some just don't get the big NHL game.

i know that they say bigger guys take time to grow into themselves, that you have to be more patient.

what do you think of these stats though?

55 games played
3 goals
4 assists
7 points
plus/minus -6
penalty minutes 19

not impressive at all for a guy who gets picked first overall, joe thornton. by the end of his first year, people (hockey experts) were not saying to have patience, they were calling him a complete bust. stamkos already has one more goal, and 7 more points than joe in only 40 regular season games, with a hell of alot less ice time than joe got in beantown his first year.

now when it comes to thornton and stamkos, i think joe has so much more talent than stamkos, but the point is, have a little patience with the kid. i don't know of many players who are thriving in tampa with all the turmoil that franchise has, let alone a fresh-faced 18 year old.

Plyrs99
 
21pro said:
Stamkos hasn't improved with more ice time over the 1st half season. When's he gonna break out and become the expected consensus rookie of the year?
It took Lanny about 2 seasons to find his groove.
 
I dont know much about this Stamkos guy , I dont follow hockey that much but we should never evaluate a player based on a few games or even a rookie season for that matter. Look at Mario Williams , some were saying Charly Casserly made a mistake for picking him #1 overall a few years ago. Now he is one of the premier pass-rushers in football in a division where a pass-rush is vitally important.