Seems like the whole case was a set-up from the start. Reporters tracked down the gay guy who wanted a website that she refused as listed in the court filings. Turns out he's a straight guy, been married for 15 years, and is a web designer himself.
Didn't conservatives used to rail against the "activist court"??The ruling was based on an event that never happened.
Didn't conservatives used to rail against the "activist court"??
Didn't conservatives used to rail against the "activist court"??
Our judges say that's OK! They like queer jokes too!! Think I'll go roll a big joint...Activism is in the eye of the beholder.
And SCOTUS still can’t understand why they have a credibility problem. No one should feel compelled to respect any rulings from this shit stain of a “court”.Seems like the whole case was a set-up from the start. Reporters tracked down the gay guy who wanted a website that she refused as listed in the court filings. Turns out he's a straight guy, been married for 15 years, and is a web designer himself.
Between Roe v Wade and now this, I was concerned we were seeing the end of American jurisprudence. Afterall, isn't the job of SCOTUS to make final, binding rulings?
But then I liked it up and it turns out SCOTUS overturns it's own cases with sufficient regularity, that we're actually seeing them do it less often. So while I think this is a horribly partisan decision and SCOTUS has f'd up, I don't really think the overturning of its own previous precedent is still bad anymore.
And so if anyone says I'm subject to an echo chamber and blindly believe things without researching with an open mind in future, I'll point to this and say, "Nah. I had heard things that agreed with my world view and part of me wanted to be true, but I looked it up and it turned out to be wrong. So I accepted that."
So basically: If I'm a bigot and I hate gays, I can't withhold services.
I can only speak about myself, and that's what I did. And I was very clear I was only speaking for myself. To talk about "except other people" is to either strawman me or pull me into a while new debate, and whichever it is I'm not interested in either. My comment stands for what it is: an expression of my own thoughts and feelings.Except people aren't upset that the SC overturned their own decision, they're upset that some shady billionaire brought an entirely fake case to the court and they ruled on it.
Its bad enough that Alliance Defending Freedom can directly bring cases to the SC but the fact that the court ruled on an event that didn't happen to change laws nationally is shameful.
I can only speak about myself, and that's what I did. And I was very clear I was only speaking for myself. To talk about "except other people" is to either strawman me or pull me into a while new debate, and whichever it is I'm not interested in either. My comment stands for what it is: an expression of my own thoughts and feelings.
Does the U.S. have something similar to Canada where the high court can be asked to render an opinion on a hypothetical set of facts?
I can think of one significant example in Canada and that is the Clarity Act.
Clarity Act - Wikipedia
Between Roe v Wade and now this, I was concerned we were seeing the end of American jurisprudence. Afterall, isn't the job of SCOTUS to make final, binding rulings?
But then I liked it up and it turns out SCOTUS overturns it's own cases with sufficient regularity, that we're actually seeing them do it less often. So while I think this is a horribly partisan decision and SCOTUS has f'd up, I don't really think the overturning of its own previous precedent is still bad anymore.
And so if anyone says I'm subject to an echo chamber and blindly believe things without researching with an open mind in future, I'll point to this and say, "Nah. I had heard things that agreed with my world view and part of me wanted to be true, but I looked it up and it turned out to be wrong. So I accepted that."