red said:Your comment re Dion is merely partisan nonsense.
It would be if I was partisan.
My concerns about Dion come from a history of good judgement and common sense.
We'll see if I was wrong about him soon enough.
red said:Your comment re Dion is merely partisan nonsense.
lookingforitallthetime said:It would be if I was partisan.
lookingforitallthetime said:It would be if I was partisan.
My concerns about Dion come from a history of good judgement and common sense.
We'll see if I was wrong about him soon enough.
red said:I will take you at your word, but I would believe it more if you used his correct name.
ggaleazz said:save democracy by keeping Stephen Harper in power. That's rich
Thanks for the laugh
Bear669 said:.
Among other issues, those in the other 9 provinces- that sucking sound is your $ going to Quebec!![]()
red said:The GG is appointed by the PM, so the break from england is there already.
landscaper said:bet on prorouging the parliment
fuji said:Nope. He lacks the constitutional power to call elections. It is up to Michaelle Jean, our Governor General, to decide if and when we will have an election. The best Harper can do is plead with her to call an election. However she is essentially required to follow precedent, and precedent dictates that rather than call an election she must give the Opposition a chance to form a government.
Wrong. It is up the Members of Parliament to determine who will govern the country. It is up to us to elect MP's that will make sensible decisions on our behalf.
The Cunning Linguist said:fuji...there's been a lot of replies insulting you, and other posts, but I do believe you were being deliberately obtuse, as you knew exactly what I was suggesting.
Unless you can provide an example, I don't believe there has ever been a case in the modern era where the GG refused the PM's request to call an election. She basically is just a rubber stamp.
Cinema Face said:A coalition of Lieberal, NDP and separatist is a match made in hell. Anyone who thinks that is a better alternative to the party in power is a complete idiot.
Fuji, I've agreed with most of what you've said, including that looking conceded the debate. However, I'm sure you'd agree that the "reserve power" that you speak of is theoretical, rather than practical. I've never heard that the GG could declare war unilaterally, and I'm not buying it unless you can support the point. It makes sense to me that Parliament would have to pass a declaration of war, as it did against Germany in WW2.fuji said:Harper does not have the power to do away with the GG. If anythign the GG has the power to do away with Parliament.
Seriously.
The GG hs far more "reserve power" than most peope realize and could easily precipitate a massive constitutional crisis were she/he ever to use it.
For example the GG can unilaterally declare war and order the Canadian army into the field, without any regard to how Parliament feels about it.
At any rate Harper by hismelf does not have the power to change Canada from a Dominion to a Republic. That would take massive multi-party co-operation and the support of a majority of the provinces.
BKool said:It's far more complicated than that. While we may physically put an X next to an MP's name, a myriad of factors go into making the decision who that MP will be. Many Canadians vote strategically and considering how close Harper came to a majority it would be completely ridiculous to dismiss the very real possibility that a lot of those Lib X'es would have gone to the conservatives MP's had those voters known about this unholy alliance with the NDP and the Bloc.
Aardvark154 said:Very good Historical Constiutional points Fuji.
That still doesn't change the fact that I hate this!
RandyAndy2 said:However, I'm sure you'd agree that the "reserve power" that you speak of is theoretical, rather than practical.
I've never heard that the GG could declare war unilaterally, and I'm not buying it unless you can support the point.
suppose Harper asks the GG to prorogue or dissolve Parliament and the GG refused. At that point couldn't Harper recommend to the Queen that the GG be replaced
RandyAndy2 said:Fuji, I've agreed with most of what you've said, including that looking conceded the debate.
lookingforitallthetime said:I didn't debate anything.