Responding to aliens a really, really bad idea

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
Responding to aliens is a really, really bad idea - Stephen Hawking
Published time: 23 Sep, 2016 19:14

Stephen Hawking has advised us earthlings to be extremely wary about answering any signals from aliens when they eventually come calling.
Hawking made the comments during his new online show ‘Stephen Hawking’s Favourite Places’. In the programme, the renowned astrophysicist ‘visits’ the potentially habitable Gliese 832c, a planet located some 16 light-years from Earth.
“As I grow older I am more convinced than ever that we are not alone,” says Hawking.

Hawking believes there could very well be life on Gliese, but imagines a meeting between the two civilizations as something that would resemble Christopher Columbus meeting Native Americans, saying, “that didn't turn out so well.”
"One day we might receive a signal from a planet like this, but we should be wary of answering back,” he cautions.

In the program, Hawking references ‘The Breakthrough Listening Project’, a 10-year $100 million initiative, which has Hawking on board, and funded by Russian Billionaire Yuri Milner.
“After a lifetime of wondering, I am helping to lead a new global effort to find out,” Hawking said of the initiative.

The project is the biggest alien-hunting exercise ever undertaken and plans on using the world’s most sensitive radio telescopes to listen in on 10 times the amount of sky than similar enterprises have achieved in the past.
But don’t start packing your bags just yet. On Gilese, a year lasts only 36 days, the atmosphere is thick with fog “or worse”, and one side is constantly facing its sun.
 
Other astrophysics disagree

One argument is for a species to explore the universe they have evolved past being warrior like or they would have extinguished themselves
 
Unless they have an imperialistic culture and are pursuing expansionism. Not that humans would ever do something like that...
 
We could be ringing the intergalactic dinner bell.

My thought is that anyone that advanced would be more inclined to be peaceful .. at least until they land in red neck zone and are summarily killed and barbecued (or deep fried).
 
mvhG8UP.png
 
If you were an alien observing President Trump, would you follow the Prime Directive?
 
I think Hawking got it backwards. Should be:
Responding to humans a really, really bad idea
 
He doesn't want to see the aliens end up in the chinese black market being slaughtered and sold as some believed to be immortality soup.
 
It's going to boil down to whether the galactic empire we encounter is resource constrained and whether we would be competing for those resources.

Earth is resource constrained. We fight wars mostly over who will get what.

Is the ratio of life in the universe such that there will be a galactic scramble to control the best stars and planets?

One problem: the universe is expanding. Everything is getting further away from us very quickly. It may be that the nearest life is far enough away that the expansion of the space between here and there makes it mathematically impossible for them to get to us.
 
It's going to boil down to whether the galactic empire we encounter is resource constrained and whether we would be competing for those resources.

Earth is resource constrained. We fight wars mostly over who will get what.

Is the ratio of life in the universe such that there will be a galactic scramble to control the best stars and planets?

One problem: the universe is expanding. Everything is getting further away from us very quickly. It may be that the nearest life is far enough away that the expansion of the space between here and there makes it mathematically impossible for them to get to us.

If they are resource contrained they would not be able to afford the energy costs to send even a gram of material to threaten earth. If they are not resource constrained then they can manufacture their own planets, moons, and probably their own stars. Of course this is predicated on our current understanding of physics, if aliens have methods of cheaply travelling the stars then they could be very well be a threat but if that was possible then that implies to me that earth is already conquered and we just do not know it yet. Security through obscurity, either it is the best form of security (earth has not been found) or it is the worst form of secuirty (earth has been found long ago and under alien control and we think we are free).
 
We are scary aliens ourselves. We don't need to contact any...

However, I think he ( Stephen Hawking ) has a point. Nature in general is about survival of the fittest. Are we fit enough to host any other life form?
 
And now you are facing the choice of choosing the blue pill or the red pill.

It can go two ways ...
The good ..
alien-breast-7-of-9.jpg


Jolene-Blalock-star-trek.jpg


The bad ..
10-of-the-creepiest-aliens-in-hollywood-8.jpg


aliensjpg1.jpg


If you are curious on what an encounter of the later would be like .. buy me a stiff drink and I'll tell you about my last marriage.
 
Thankfully the chance of any signal reaching us is so remote...

Without some kind of faster than light receiver we are left with only radio or other EM signals. The time it would take for them to travel to us from the immense universe and the loss of power as they travel would make it next to impossible for us to hear them. Then there is the problem with sending a return signal with enough power to get back to them. But on the good side, the signal would take so long to get back that we would have time to advance further.
 
I think part if it is how many planets are considered in the goldilocks zone and are actually inhabitable. And how this ratio reflects on the number that actually developed sentient life.

Finally remember we have only had a semblance of civilization for what 10,000 years? That's a blip really. A lot would depend on whether a nearby planet hadn't already burned out/its life forms killed eachother/other cataclysm. Really timing coupled with proximity and interstellar capability.

I think it's out there but I wonder whether any life form can develop the capability within the time frame a species would have.