Rent to own

gentle_lover

Banned
Mar 5, 2005
2,077
0
0
I always interested on this concept. Anyone have experience or info about this "Rent to own" concept on buying a house or condo? Is there a catch?

GL
 
gentle_lover said:
I always interested on this concept. Anyone have experience or info about this "Rent to own" concept on buying a house or condo? Is there a catch?

GL

Well I am not sure what the catch is I do know that you must have no debt. I looked in to this recently and found out that because I have osap and a car loan i would not be able to do it.
 
you'll notice it is most common in areas where significant demographics point to religious cultures that 'forbid' their following from borrowing money. thus, rent to own is a way to get around a mortgage... ie, the requirements of 'no debt' as mentioned ^^^

i guess in some small instances, it also helps the uncreditworthy... usually that is a single home investor that offers that product, and not a large homesite builder, there's more to it, but, that's my briefs... hehe.
 
I've never actually heard of "rent to own" property. Appliances, electronics and furniture etc, but not property.
 
I've actually invested in a few rent-to-own properties, so I'll explain. The basic concept is that you get into a home you want now and buy it later, at an agreed-upon price. While you are in it now you rent it, and then you have the option to purchase it at a later date, usually two to three years from now.

The arrangement is good for people who do not qualify for a mortgage now, but will in the future - their finances/credit may be better in a few years from now. Your credit will be checked now, and as well as an opinion given about your ability to afford the house in the future. While JessiMai may have been turned down, there are some who can get into lease-to-owns without perfect credit, or with some present balances (small credit card debt, some minor late payments). However, student loans will generally prevent lease-to-own.

In terms of more detail, when you move-in now under the rental portion, you agree to pay the landlord (or the rent-to-own investor) an option-price, usually about $4,000 to $7,000. This enters you into a contract that will allow you to buy the property at a certain time in the future for a specified price. Now before everyone gets uppity about paying this amount of money, there are two things. First, if you exercise the option to buy the house, the money gets credited to the purchase price so you will get it back. However, if you do not go through with the purchase and decide to move out, you do not get the money back - and you need to look at it from the point of view of the investor, who is now sitting on a house that is vacant. That option price will help the investor pay the mortgage while the house is vacant or allow him to make repairs to make it salable. Basically the option payment is there to make sure that everyone goes through with the deal. You can, however, consider this a "catch" if you want to.

Now, in terms of rent, the rents tend to be slightly higher than market value because the investor will set-aside a certain portion of the monthly rent also for the down payment on the house when you purchase it in the future. Again, if you walk away from purchasing the house, the investor keeps the extra money.

When you transfer from the renting to owning, the investor will apply all the extra money collected towards the down payment on the house, which will usually work-out to be 8% to 12% of the price. You can, of course, add-in any extra money for down payment you want.

There are two other things to keep in mind. You will rent the house today, but buy it at a price that is higher tomorrow. Typically an investor will appreciate the house by about 5% per year, depending on the part of the city. So if you move into a $250,000 house you'll pay $275,625 for it in two years, and you are locked-in to that price contractually when you sign the lease to own contract. With all the prognostication about a "crash" in the housing market, you could be in a position to buy a house at higher than market prices in the future! However, get independent advice on whether or not the market will bottom-out. This does present a catch in a way, because if you walk out of purchasing the house, you will forfeit the thousands in option money and extra rent you have paid. An investor will not let you out of the contract or reduce the price because the house appreciation is how they make their money.

Second, you need to consider your housing needs for the future. Typically lease to owns are done on houses in the $200,000 - $325,000 range because the rent is based on the price of the house, so people cannot to pay rent on houses that cost much more than this. That means the houses will be in areas outside the GTA, and they will be starter homes or slightly above starter, depending on the market. In two or three years from now when you purchase the home, will you want to be in a starter home still, or will your needs have changed to a bigger home? Will you want to be in another area of the city?
 
Sorry 3Tees but I don't get the upside??

You pay money up front and a higher than market "rent"
or
You rent, you pay market rates and a have a refundable deposit that collects interest.

The price continues to escalate until you exercise the option to purchase.
No difference

You have to qualify up front.
or
If you rent you qualify when you buy

You're locked into buying the house you're in
or
You rent & when its time to buy you find the best property at that time and negotiate like a buyer who has other options.

All that being said, you can get 100% financing today, so if you really want to buy, why not do it at today's market value?

Rent to own might make sense when prices are increasing at double digit rates but I fear that may be changing real soon.
 
This is the first I've heard of it but I can see a couple of immediate benefits to both parties (to the seller, its pretty obvious)
1) As stated, if you dont' qualify now, but will in the future you can lock in the house you want
2) Sounds like you can lock in the price of the house as well and with the volatile housing market in toronto, I can see the benefits of this.
3) Instead of simply renting until you can afford to move or purchase, this way a portion of your rent goes towards your future purchase of the property.
4) That 5 - 7K "bonus" for the seller isn't really that much when you consider if you purchased now, you'd probably pay that in interest in 2 or 3 years anyways.

Not the best way to buy a home but certainly I can see it being viable for some.
 
HafDun said:
Sorry 3Tees but I don't get the upside??

It's not for everyone. The fact that you have questions means that I have done a good job of presenting an unbiased view.

HafDun said:
You pay money up front and a higher than market "rent"
or
You rent, you pay market rates and a have a refundable deposit that collects interest.
I'm pretty sure that the rent differential is higher than the refundable deposit. Also, many investors will give an extra $200/month bonus towards the purchase of the house. This is above and beyond the above the increased market rents, and comes right out of the investor's profit. This off-sets the refundable deposit.

HafDun said:
The price continues to escalate until you exercise the option to purchase.
No difference
Not sure what you mean. The final purchase price of the property is fixed. There is a fixed exercise date on the option. What I meant to say is that the investor will price the future value of the house by appreciating it by x% for the fixed amount of time. The option must be exercised at a specific time, for a specific purchase price. There is no continuing escalation.

HafDun said:
You have to qualify up front.
or
If you rent you qualify when you buy
Yup - but mortgage brokers will let some blemishes slide when you qualify up-front. They will also look to see if you will qualify in the future. Typically, you should have two years of stable employment, and self-employed individuals need to show two years worth of financial statements. So some people may not have these now, but will in two years. Key benefit here is that you can have somewhat spotty/unproven credit or financials AND BE IN THE HOUSE YOU WANT NOW, as opposed to waiting for two years while renting. Then when you consider the forced savings as a result of the option price and extra money given at the time of closing, it does pay to do it this way.

HafDun said:
You're locked into buying the house you're in
or
You rent & when its time to buy you find the best property at that time and negotiate like a buyer who has other options.
Agree - this is a disadvantage. Again though, if you want to be in a house now, and know that the rent to own house is the house you want for many years, then it is viable. So I'd only get involved with people really ready to commit to that particular house.

HafDun said:
All that being said, you can get 100% financing today, so if you really want to buy, why not do it at today's market value?
Can I get a show of hands from people who are experienced with finance who think that a 100% mortgage is a good idea? I've had experienced investors say to me, and I agree, that anyone who takes out a 100% mortgage or a 40 year mortgage should have a bullet put through their head. Having some sort of down payment or equity in a house is always a good idea. If the real estate market drops appreciably, anyone with a 100% mortgage is an a reverse equity situation - they owe more than the house is worth. If you feel that the market is going to drop appreciably a 100% mortgage screams "take my house, please" to the bank!

HafDun said:
Rent to own might make sense when prices are increasing at double digit rates but I fear that may be changing real soon.
Don't understand this either. If prices are increasing by double digits, the investor will increase the future price of the house by double digits. I used 5% as a number I pulled out of thin air. If housing prices are expected to increase by 15% per year for the next three years, the investor will set the future price accordingly.

Look, lease-to-own is not for everyone, and it needs to be considered carefully. As an investor in things like this, the last thing I want to do is rope someone who does not understand all the facts. It is, as I have pointed out not for everyone.
 
tboy said:
This is the first I've heard of it but I can see a couple of immediate benefits to both parties (to the seller, its pretty obvious)
1) As stated, if you dont' qualify now, but will in the future you can lock in the house you want
2) Sounds like you can lock in the price of the house as well and with the volatile housing market in toronto, I can see the benefits of this.
3) Instead of simply renting until you can afford to move or purchase, this way a portion of your rent goes towards your future purchase of the property.
4) That 5 - 7K "bonus" for the seller isn't really that much when you consider if you purchased now, you'd probably pay that in interest in 2 or 3 years anyways.

Not the best way to buy a home but certainly I can see it being viable for some.

Very fair summary.

For #2 though, with prices being volatile, and possibly going down in two years, a buyer will be locked in to paying a higher price (how else does the investor make money but through the appreciation of real estate). If prices are predicted to go down, a locked-in higher price is not a good idea. The renter can always walk away from the contract, but lose the option deposit, but it may be worthwhile to lose the option price than exercise it at the agreed-upon price.
 
tboy said:
This is the first I've heard of it but I can see a couple of immediate benefits to both parties (to the seller, its pretty obvious)
1) As stated, if you dont' qualify now, but will in the future you can lock in the house you want
2) Sounds like you can lock in the price of the house as well and with the volatile housing market in toronto, I can see the benefits of this.
3) Instead of simply renting until you can afford to move or purchase, this way a portion of your rent goes towards your future purchase of the property.
4) That 5 - 7K "bonus" for the seller isn't really that much when you consider if you purchased now, you'd probably pay that in interest in 2 or 3 years anyways.

Not the best way to buy a home but certainly I can see it being viable for some.

1. I don't see much advantage to commiting to buying a particular house now. Typically a new home in a new subdivision. There is almost always a good inventory of resale homes on the market. The market is always cyclical & seasonal so try looking in early summer after the winter/spring market has calmed.

2. According to 3tees, the price continues to escalate. As I stated before, that might have been good in a fast market, but the world has changed in 2008. If you think we are totally immune from the problems in the US, you are way to optimistic. The target demographic for this type of arrangement are the last people who can afford to speculate that the market won't turn.

3. The portion that goes towards the purchase is over and above the rent you pay. This is a way for the builder to squeeze additional profit out of a house. Not too many builders I know are that charitable.

4. The bonus for the seller is exactly that...A bonus for the seller. I'll gladly take $7K from someone on the premise that they can buy a house in the future at market value.