Religion and Science

So God created all of this and then waited several hundreds of millions of years and multiple mass extinctions before our illustrious existence?
Right.

And I suppose he/she also created the hundreds of billions of stars in our galaxy and the hundreds of billions of galaxies for our eventual viewing pleasure.

Even if this were all true, who created the Creator?
If we couldn't have evolved and had to have been created, surely a much more complex and powerful entity couldn't have evolved either.
Who created the Creator's Creator, and so on........?

Man's time here has been a tiny drop in a very large bucket and it wasn't inevitable.
I'd say it's much more likely that it wouldn't have happened and a lot of lucky and random things had to happen for us to even be possible.
There will likely be several more mass extinctions including man before the sun expands and consumes the Earth in around 5 billion years or so.

Get over yourselves already.
You are not that relevant. :D
 
Notwithstanding your self-professed wisdom it is obvious that you do not have the intellectual ability to maintain any position with consistency. Hence engagement with you is futile and I will not waste my time any further. Good luck.
Look guy, believe all the fair tales you want. The fact that you do not have the reading comprehension to even read what I write in the posts you respond to says more about your lack on intelligence than anything I could say.
My point here is that I believe we've reached the point where it's time to move away from the fairy tales.
I hope you are right.
 
I hope you are right.

As would I, but I have my doubts. If conditions in the world start to go south, which is more than possible, I think people will cling to superstitions and fables more than ever.
 
As would I, but I have my doubts. If conditions in the world start to go south, which is more than possible, I think people will cling to superstitions and fables more than ever.
Hopefully, sooner rather than later, people will begin to realize that it is their superstitions and fables that cause the world to go south.

Perry
 
If you really want a bunch of quotes on Einstein and religion, I'd be happy to oblige.
However, you should be aware, Einstein TOTALLY disbelieved in any religions requiring a personal god - Judaism, Christianity, Islam, etc. You MIGHT be able to say he was a Spinozan - he believed in a "god" as representative of the nature of the universe, and not in any way remotely close to the way you probably mean. That is ABSOLUTELY as far as it went.

So ... try again.

Not sure if that was directed at me, however, in the event it was you should look back at my earlier posts in which I said that he did not necessarily believe in God in the Judeo-Christian understanding. I quite agree that his belief was more likely Spinozan.

“I believe in Spinoza’s God who reveals Himself in the orderly harmony of what exists, not in a God who concerns himself with fates and actions of human beings.”
 
If conditions in the world start to go south, which is more than possible, I think people will cling to superstitions and fables more than ever.

Perhaps too, as science and even everyday technology become more and more a matter beyond the average person's understanding, a belief in magic will not seem so discreditable.

Moreover, Perry Mason is right that there is a hunger for meaning for one's life and in this matter, materialism is a pretty thin gruel for most. Given that our early comprehension of the world probably proceeds in the way of an analogy from the operations of our infant bodies, it's understandable that we might never leave, or easily return to, beliefs in some underlying intelligence.

jwm
 
So where do religiously active scientists fit into that world paradigm? Or religious people from other disciplines who have no problems with science.

The paradigm you suggest does seem quite closed minded.


I said 'Religion and Science' belongs to the OXYMORON thread

I didn't use the word scientists or religious people

A human being can be a great scientist but still be moron enough to believe in god
 
I said 'Religion and Science' belongs to the OXYMORON thread

I didn't use the word scientists or religious people

A human being can be a great scientist but still be moron enough to beleive in god

Is it possible that a person who believes that a scientist who believes in god is a moron is a moron himself/herself?
 
Well how nice...it's looks like we've all come to some sort of happy state of consensus.

Thank God. So to speak.
 
To all those people who believe in God !

Fuck off else god will cut off your dicks :D
 
Under that definition of "religious", then all physicists, and probably almost all scientists are by definition "religious". Einstein believed that the very existence of physical laws defining the universe WAS God, not that they PROVED God.
Pretty weak. And not at all what almost all people would mean when they say religious.

Well I suppose that if you become the official arbiter of lexicography and epistemology you will be correct, however, until then it is open to each of us (and Einstein for that matter) to decide for himself/herself what they choose the definitions and understandings of religion and god to be.
 
Last edited:
Also, and IMHO, there can be conflict between organized religion and science, but science doesn't necessarily preclude the existence of God or belief in a deity.

Exactly. Just remember that by the same token it is just as likely that the universe was created by....anything. Maybe your mom created the universe and is hiding the fact for her own reasons.
 
I said 'Religion and Science' belongs to the OXYMORON thread

I didn't use the word scientists or religious people

A human being can be a great scientist but still be moron enough to believe in god
And as I said, the paradigm you suggest does seem quite closed minded.
 
I find interesting on page five, how many posters apparently never read the original article on page one.
 
LOL
Nice comeback. ;)
I stand by my statement - the VAST MAJORITY of the planet would totally disagree with your definition of religion.
Einstein didn't believe in god. Not in the way that 99% of the planet would define it. End of story.

I have not defined religion. I have simply observed that everyone is free to define his/her religion and/or religious beliefs and/or understanding of god and/or understanding of faith and or general belief systems as they choose and not how you or I believe they ought to understand those concepts or how you might wish to circumscribe their beliefs. End of story.
 
One thing I have learnt on Terb is that the same people that like debating politics tend to like debating religion. I am not sure why that is, but it is an observation I find interesting.
As would I, but I have my doubts. If conditions in the world start to go south, which is more than possible, I think people will cling to superstitions and fables more than ever.
I don’t know what will happen in the future. I like to think that over time, progress is a fact of life. The fact that religion has less and less influence in most Western countries (Canada, Europe, Australia, New Zealand, etc.) gives me cause for hope. However, the fact that it is still a powerful force, makes me think that it is too early to declare that god is dead (BTW, speaking of “god is dead”, although not the easiest read, I think “Joyful Wisdom” is an all time great book).
I find interesting on page five, how many posters apparently never read the original article on page one.
How many threads on terb don’t drift by page 5? Besides, I did not find a lot of the original article all that useful as it made some assertions such as the ones about the number of Christians at Oxford and Cambridge with no source other than someone’s statement. For all we know, his statement was based on personal observation of people he personally interacted with and may or may not be representative.

Much of the rest of it simply said that most religious people are in touch with reality enough to pick and choose the parts of the bible they want to believe in. I don’t really find that suprising. How many North American Catholics do you know that listen to the Pope about birth control? Given that Popasmerf is on this board, I assume that either he does not and I have meet many Catholics in real life that go to church regularly and practice birth control..