Religion and Science

I should clarify what I mean by religious beliefs. I do not consider the bible (or any other
documents prepared by religious organizations) factual.

By religious beliefs I only mean the idea that a higher, omnipotent being created the
universe and/or the rules that govern the universe. (PS: that is not to say that
I necessarily believe it myself)
I think that is an important point. As evidence of surveys of the American National Academy of Science indicate, only a fairly small proportion of even the minority of those who are religious are theists. Once you get away from theism, almost anything is possible (although it still leave the problem of where the god came from). However, it seems to me that once you get away from theism, religion becomes completely irrelevant. It seems to me that Deism means that there is no reason to really care one way or the other about religion.
 
I never really had a problem with the concept of a higher being, I do ahve big problems with people who claim to speak for said higher being.

The question I always had about the higher being is did that being wear a lab coat.......
 
To me, evolution as interpreted by Darwin is a crock because it is a tautology: of course the fit survive... because that is what survival means!

And Natural Selection is equally a tautology.

Also, there is no evidence that inheritance of acquired characteristics (which is really Lamarck, not Darwin!) is true... if it were, then after 3,000 years one might expect Jewish boys to be born without a foreskin!!!

On the other hand... what we are learning from quantum mechanics is so similar to what was told by ancients and mystics that it is scary... the ancients seem to have known most of our recent discoveries... the fact that the act of observing by an observer can change the observed, for example... or that mass and energy are but different aspects of one and the same thing and depend on the observer...

"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, Than are dreamt of in your philosophy."

Perry

Sorry blackrock... I don't feel a need "to be right" so I am not inclined to engage in an I-am-right-you-are-wrong type of debate with you (or anyone else).

I have expressed some (perhaps controversial?) views that you can accept or reject as you choose... it's up to you and you can take them for what you think they are or are not worth.

On the other hand, I suggest you read a bit on quantum mechanics, whole systems sciences, holism, Heisenberg, holography, cybernetics... you might change your mind about some of your comments... or, again, you may not! :cool:

Perry

So, in a discussion forum you make a statement even you offer as 'possibly controversial' and that's it. No back up, rebuttal, or continuing discussion. Talk about a drive by fruiting. Then you say you 'don't feel a need to to be right' as if you can say anything and we should allow it unchallenged somehow, even if it's felt to be incomplete, inaccurate, or totally off the wall.

Your foreskin analogy is nuts and your concept of the the knowledge of the ancients is skewed or incomplete.

I'll admit your study list contains references that play very little part in my professional or personal life and so I don't know a great deal about them and I suspect I'm not alone in that on this BB. I'm not sure what connections exist between cybernetics and holography and what they have to do with the knowledge possessed by the ancients. Theoretical Physics tends to be akin to voodoo to me and again probably to most Terbites, although let me confess,totums and juju do grab at my curious bone on dark and stormy nights sitting around a campfire inside a boma. I do find string theory of some interest, but don't spend too much time on it as it can make my eyes roll back after a 30 minute read or discussion and yet I do know who Heisenburg was.

So to speak up, say something controversial and then leave it there is kind of a waste, but hey, whatever floats your boat.
 
I thought the article was interesting as it is written from what in fact is the majority viewpoint.
It seems that even the Templeton foundation (an institution more or less set up to support the passage in the first post) would disagree with your statement that it represents a majority viewpoint. However, they do argue that it may have more to do with self selection than training:

“A survey conducted between 2005 and 2007 by Elaine Ecklund of University at Buffalo, The State University of New York and funded by the Templeton Foundation found that over 60% of natural and social science professors are atheists or agnostics. When asked whether they believed in God, nearly 34% answered "I do not believe in God" and about 30% answering "I do not know if there is a God and there is no way to find out,"[59] According to the same survey, "[m]any scientists see themselves as having a spirituality not attached to a particular religious tradition."[60] In further analysis, published in 2007, Ecklund and Christopher Scheitle conclude that "the assumption that becoming a scientist necessarily leads to loss of religion is untenable" and that "t appears that those from non-religious backgrounds disproportionately self-select into scientific professions. This may reflect the fact that there is tension between the religious tenets of some groups and the theories and methods of particular sciences and it contributes to the large number of non-religious scientists."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relati...nce#The_scientific_community.27s_perspective]

On a related note from the same source: “Among leading scientists — defined as members of the National Academy of Sciences — 72.2% expressed disbelief and another 20% were agnostic concerning the existence of a personal god who answers prayer. [58]
 
As a document setting out the basis of faith in an eternal God it is a wonderful work. The bible as a series of parables or morality plays is very valuable, however for those that choose to read it literally as an historical document most of it flies in the face of science and can be demonstrated to be false.
 
. It seems to me that Deism means that there is no reason to really care one way or the other about religion.

Agree. In fact there is no real difference betwen a deist and an atheist or agnostic.
 
Someone - to clarify, the majority of Christians and the majority of people in North America. I believe the Scheitle's 2007 study that "the assumption that becoming a scientist necessarily leads to loss of religion is untenable" and that "t appears that those from non-religious backgrounds disproportionately self-select into scientific professions."

However, as I've mentioned in the past, I've had the experience of knowing several very eminent life scientists who were devout Christians.
 
As a document setting out the basis of faith in an eternal God it is a wonderful work. The bible as a series of parables or morality plays is very valuable, however for those that choose to read it literally as an historical document most of it flies in the face of science and can be demonstrated to be false.
For most Western and a great many (probably most) Eastern Christians the Bible particularly the "Old" Testament is not to be read literally. So I'd agree with your statement.
 
Someone - to clarify, the majority of Christians and the majority of people in North America.

I misunderstood your post then. Sorry.
Agree. In fact there is no real difference betwen a deist and an atheist or agnostic.
I find that more and more, the word atheist is used for agnostic. Indeed, I suspect that the number of literal atheists in the word is extremely small and most are technically agnostic, but just place an extremely small probability on the existence of a god.
 
Science and religion are not necessarily incompatible. There are many scientists who are very religious and observant although not too many who take the bible literally. Einstein in his later life apparently became a believer, not so much in a particular God but in the possibility of the unknown and a higher spiritual force.
 
Science and religion are not necessarily incompatible. There are many scientists who are very religious and observant although not too many who take the bible literally. Einstein in his later life apparently became a believer, not so much in a particular God but in the possibility of the unknown and a higher spiritual force.

This statement seems to contradict your previous post
There is no conflict only if you believe that the earth is 5,000 years old.


So which is it that you really believe?
 
Also, there is no evidence that inheritance of acquired characteristics (which is really Lamarck, not Darwin!) is true... if it were, then after 3,000 years one might expect Jewish boys to be born without a foreskin!!! :eek:
[/I]

Perry

This has got to be one of the most idiotic comments I have read in this forum in a long time. So expanding your argument, you would also say that if people started loping off their earlobes then in a few thousand years or so their offspring would be born without them? Really, really dumb.
 
This statement seems to contradict your previous post



So which is it that you really believe?

Regardless of what I personally believe i do think that if one does not take the bible as a literal history of the world but rather a series of morality plays and parables one could have faith in a higher being and still believe in science.

I do not believe that one can believe both in science and accept the bible as the literal history of the world.
 
...
On the other hand... what we are learning from quantum mechanics is so similar to what was told by ancients and mystics that it is scary... the ancients seem to have known most of our recent discoveries... the fact that the act of observing by an observer can change the observed, for example... or that mass and energy are but different aspects of one and the same thing and depend on the observer...
...

I have a working knowledge of modern physics and a decent background in a number of religions so I'll bite.

Could you describe what ancient knowledge predicted quantum mechanics (without relying on wrongly applied analogies)?
 
was this article serious?...ask any credible scientist...there is no GOD...

Very wrong. What any credible scientist will say is that there is no scientific basis for the existence of god. They will also admit that it is possible that there is some sort of godly being pulling the strings, they try and explain the results of gods work beyond just saying 'god did it.'
 
Very wrong. What any credible scientist will say is that there is no scientific basis for the existence of god. They will also admit that it is possible that there is some sort of godly being pulling the strings, they try and explain the results of gods work beyond just saying 'god did it.'

That is why they call it faith.
 
Belief stands outside of proof since if something is provable like gravity or electricity you don't need to believe in it or have faith in it, - you can see it, experience it, and know it.

I think a lot of scientists have a perception that goes something like this:
I am here right now and I have consciousness and awareness. The only way this could possibly happen is if the universe has a creative generative power.

And, this creative generative power in the universe is what you call "God".
What the properties and characteristics of god are is open to speculation.
 
I think a lot of scientists have a perception that goes something like this:
I am here right now and I have consciousness and awareness. The only way this could possibly happen is if the universe has a creative generative power.

And, this creative generative power in the universe is what you call "God".
What the properties and characteristics of god are is open to speculation.

Let me see, we have a primordial swamp/soap, a few amino acids and a bolt of lightning. ZAP!!!!!!! It's alive or is it a life. I dunno!

Is there a God? I'm not sure, but leaning towards no.
 
This has got to be one of the most idiotic comments I have read in this forum in a long time. So expanding your argument, you would also say that if people started loping off their earlobes then in a few thousand years or so their offspring would be born without them? Really, really dumb.
Hey! Don't blame me! I didn't invent this theory, Lamarck did!

I agree with you! :D

Perry
 
Could you describe what ancient knowledge predicted quantum mechanics (without relying on wrongly applied analogies)?
That is not what I said!

I said that the ancients already knew what we are discovering today through our studies and understanding of quantum mechanics, etc. You will find it in The Vedas, Kabbalah, Sufism, The Kybalion, Tantra, Tao, Gnosis...

Perry