Religion and Science

No offense but given a choice between you and Einstein as the arbiter of what is moronic I will choose Einstein.
Interesting that you should say this, given that Einstein wrote:

“The word god is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weaknesses, the Bible a collection of honourable, but still primitive legends which are nevertheless pretty childish. No interpretation no matter how subtle can (for me) change this."
http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2008/may/12/peopleinscience.religion

As LuckyJackson said, Einstein was clearly not a theist. At most he was a deist.
 
Interesting that you should say this, given that Einstein wrote:

“The word god is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weaknesses, the Bible a collection of honourable, but still primitive legends which are nevertheless pretty childish. No interpretation no matter how subtle can (for me) change this."
http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2008/may/12/peopleinscience.religion

As LuckyJackson said, Einstein was clearly not a theist. At most he was a deist.

I think you have to look at the time in his life that he made certain statements. I believe that as he got older he became more religious although i do think that you are correct that he did not necessarily believe in a God in the Judea-Christian understanding.
 
I think you have to look at the time in his life that he made certain statements. I believe that as he got older he became more religious although i do think that you are correct that he did not necessarily believe in a God in the Judea-Christian understanding.

Stop it. So he wrote the letter in 54, and the next year when he died had changed his mind? That's like folks who spread the nasty rumour that Darwin recanted on his deatbed...a view also clearly dispelled by letters written by his wife and family. The religious must simply accept that Einstein was not one of them.
 
Stop it. So he wrote the letter in 54, and the next year when he died had changed his mind? That's like folks who spread the nasty rumour that Darwin recanted on his deatbed...a view also clearly dispelled by letters written by his wife and family. The religious must simply accept that Einstein was not one of them.

Why is that you think that it is up to you to determine when and at what point in their lives people can choose their belief system. Doe that fact that he was a late believer make the fact of his belief less valid. His belief system was summed up I think in the following statements:

"My religion consists of a humble admiration of the illimitable superior spirit who reveals himself in the slight details we are able to perceive with our frail and feeble minds."

"That deep emotional conviction of the presence of a superior reasoning power, which is revealed in the incomprehensible universe, forms my idea of God... "

"We are in the position of a little child entering a huge library filled with books in many different languages. The child knows someone must have written those books. It does not know how. It does not understand the languages in which they are written. The child dimly suspects a mysterious order in the arrangement of the books but doesn't know what it is."
 
I think you have to look at the time in his life that he made certain statements. I believe that as he got older he became more religious although i do think that you are correct that he did not necessarily believe in a God in the Judea-Christian understanding.
It is possible that in his last year of life, the fear of death my have led him to become more religious. Indeed, it is an empirical observation that religious activity increases with age (not counting childhood religious activity that is usually determined by parents). Sometimes, this is jokingly referred to as “cramming for the final”. However, you have not presented any evidence of this and the quotes in your later post could very well be taken as being metaphorical. Even if you are right in claiming that in the last year of life, he became more religious, I would not hold that against him. The fear of death is a powerful force.
 
There isn't any indication that his beliefs changed late in life. None. What he wrote in 54, in a private letter, can be seen as consistent with the quotes you've posted. He didn't want to offend the little chickadees who would get upset if he laid out his beliefs in plain language. He was a nice guy and hated the arrogance with which atheists laid out the truth.

The way I see it, superstitious religious types have been cut slack for long enough. They are a brake on development and the quicker they are marginalized the better off society will be. There's plenty of mystery, wonder and beauty in this life without having to make up fairy tales.
 
'Religion and Science' belongs to the OXYMORON thread

thread closed
So where do religiously active scientists fit into that world paradigm? Or religious people from other disciplines who have no problems with science.

The paradigm you suggest does seem quite closed minded.
 
It is possible that in his last year of life, the fear of death my have lead him to become more religious. Indeed, it is an empirical observation that religious activity increases with age (not counting childhood religious activity that is usually determined by parents). Sometimes, this is jokingly referred to as “cramming for the final”. However, you have not presented any evidence of this and the quotes in your later post could very well be taken as being metaphorical. Even if you are right in claiming that in the last year of life, he became more religious, I would not hold that against him. The fear of death is a powerful force.

What better evidence could there be then the word of Einstein. So I take it that not only is his belief if formed towards the end of his life not valid but you know better than he as to what he meant by his own words. I am in the presence of greatness. You are obviously much wiser than Einstein.
 
The way I see it, superstitious religious types have been cut slack for long enough. They are a brake on development and the quicker they are marginalized the better off society will be.
Oh come on. If some fundamentalist said this in reverse you'd be among the first to post how stupid the sentiment was.
 
Well of course I would...the difference between us being that I have history on my side. Thank you for reminding us that right is the opposite of wrong.

Like I said, I respect their right to hold an opinion, but not the opinion itself.
 
What better evidence could there be then the word of Einstein.
And I have provided a well known quote where he clearly expressed his views in a way that could not be metaphoric.
So I take it that not only is his belief if formed towards the end of his life not valid but you know better than he as to what he meant by his own words. I am in the presence of greatness. You are obviously much wiser than Einstein.
I would not say that, but I am clearly wiser than you are.
Oh come on. If some fundamentalist said this in reverse you'd be among the first to post how stupid the sentiment was.
I don’t see how arguments by a fundamentalist matter. LuckyJackson could be right or wrong. The main argument against him is that for some reason most societies have developed religious superstitions. Thus, the economist in me says there must be a reason for this. E.g. it must somehow be efficient. However, LuckJackson is at least basing his statement on his interpretation of the evidence. The fudalmentalist would be basing his argument on a book of “primitive legends which are nevertheless pretty childis” written thousands of years ago for a more primitive people. Thus, although, LuckyJackson’s conclusion may or may not be correct, I think it is unfair to compare it to a fundamentalist.
 
What did I say that could be contested? ;)

I'm willing to concede the statement about they're being a brake on development is arguable...but only if I don't qualify it. If I do, by saying that they've been a brake on scientific development, then it' not even controversial. I'd go further, and say that religion has done more to slow or retard ethical development than it has done to develop it.
 
And I have provided a well known quote where he clearly expressed his views in a way that could not be metaphoric.

I would not say that, but I am clearly wiser than you are.

You may well be wiser than me. That may not be saying much. However, it is simply hubris to suggest that you are wiser than Einstein and that he could not change his views because you were able to find and earlier quote of his.
 
Look, I'm not against people looking for deeper meaning in their lives, but I think it's a waste to do so by clinging to books like the Quran and Bible as answers. They're not. They contain wisdom, parts are beautiful, but other parts should serve to make us sit up and say, "we don't believe that shit anymore. Our anscestors didn't know any better, we've come a long way, and we've learned."
 
What did I say that could be contested? ;)

I'm willing to concede the statement about they're being a brake on development is arguable...but only if I don't qualify it. If I do, by saying that they've been a brake on scientific development, then it' not even controversial. I'd go further, and say that religion has done more to slow or retard ethical development than it has done to develop it.
But the fact is that societies devote real resources to religion. Historically, the resources have sometimes been very great. Thus, there must be some benefit. One possible benefit is simply the comfort the fairy tails give people. E.g. now matter how bad this life gets, perhaps the next one will be better. Perhaps one reason western countries are becoming less religious (with the partial exception of the U.S.) is because life is becoming better. To be honest with you, I am really not sure of what the benefits could be. However, when societies have at times devoted large resources to religious activities, I have to think there must be some benefits. Otherwise, those societies should die out in favour of less religious societies.
You may well be wiser than me. That may not be saying much.
We agree on something.
However, it is simply hubris to suggest that you are wiser than Einstein
Which if you even read the post your responded to , you will realize that I did not say that.
and that he could not change his views because you were able to find and earlier quote of his.
Read the post you are responding to.
 
But the fact is that societies devote real resources to religion. Historically, the resources have sometimes been very great. Thus, there must be some benefit. One possible benefit is simply the comfort the fairy tails give people. E.g. now matter how bad this life gets, perhaps the next one will be better. Perhaps one reason western countries are becoming less religious (with the partial exception of the U.S.) is because life is becoming better. To be honest with you, I am really not sure of what the benefits could be. However, when societies have at times devoted large resources to religious activities, I have to think there must be some benefits. Otherwise, those societies should die out in favour of less religious societies.

I know this will sound hypocritical, but my undergrad degree, one of them, is in eastern religion. So I agree. One of the central characteristics of our species is to want to know and understand. Before we had science, only religion was offering up any answers. It got some right, it got many wrong. My point here is that I believe we've reached the point where it's time to move away from the fairy tales.
 
Lots of confusion here...

Religion is a matter of belief... of dogma accepted as an act of faith.

Many people who are not in the least bit religious but think deeply about these things ultimately reach what appears to be an irresistible conclusion: there must be some "energy" or "power" "out there," some Spirit that is responsible for and explains the order and design that we see more and more evident as our knowledge and understanding of the Universe expands.

Still others personally experience something that can only be explained as a mystical experience of a Spiritual dimension.

All of them may use the word "God," but they each mean something quite different.

Einstein started out as a non-believer... he rejected religion and, in that sense, was an atheist. But as his own understanding of the Universe expanded over the decades, he became very much a spiritual person...

Carl Jung said he did not have to believe, because he knew it from his own experience.

Perry
 
We agree on something.

Which if you even read the post your responded to , you will realize that I did not say that.

Read the post you are responding to.

Notwithstanding your self-professed wisdom it is obvious that you do not have the intellectual ability to maintain any position with consistency. Hence engagement with you is futile and I will not waste my time any further. Good luck.