Religion and Science

I misunderstood your post then. Sorry.

I find that more and more, the word atheist is used for agnostic. Indeed, I suspect that the number of literal atheists in the word is extremely small and most are technically agnostic, but just place an extremely small probability on the existence of a god.
Of course it is impossible to prove there is no god(which Dawkins admits), so I suppose you could claim that all atheists are really agnostics. But we also can't prove that Islamic martrys won't get their seven virgins in Paradise, and many other rather unlikely things that rest upon not a single shred of evidence of any kind..
 
That is not what I said!

I said that the ancients already knew what we are discovering today through our studies and understanding of quantum mechanics, etc. You will find it in The Vedas, Kabbalah, Sufism, The Kybalion, Tantra, Tao, Gnosis...

Perry

I'm sorry. Could you be specific? I don't remember having read anything in the Feynman Lectures that was also discussed in any religious texts. The only way you could even come close to defending your argument is with the most vague philosophical analogies.

If you think otherwise, some specific examples would be useful.
 
I'm sorry. Could you be specific?
Your comments show that you have no clue what I am talking about... except that you want to argue about whatever you can find to argue about.

Thanks, but no, thanks.

If you want to know what I am talking about, I gave you enough clues... now go and learn! Even a simple Google search on any of these clues would get you well started.... I am not here to prove or teach you anything!

Bye bye, basketcase (at least you know who/what you are!)! I choose not to respond to you again!

Perry
 
How am I supposed to have any idea what you are talking about when you are being purposely vague. You make some claims but refuse to enlighten me as to how they apply or provide any support for your arguments. Do you expect me to take your word for it just because you tell me it's true? I guess that is appropriate in a discussion of science and religion.

Your lack of comment speaks volumes. Just admit you believe what you believe and that it has nothing to do with science.

Any belief that quantum mechanics applies to anything beyond the quantum level is completely without scientific basis.
 
How am I supposed to have any idea what you are talking about when you are being purposely vague. You make some claims but refuse to enlighten me as to how they apply or provide any support for your arguments. Do you expect me to take your word for it just because you tell me it's true? I guess that is appropriate in a discussion of science and religion.

Your lack of comment speaks volumes. Just admit you believe what you believe and that it has nothing to do with science.

Any belief that quantum mechanics applies to anything beyond the quantum level is completely without scientific basis.

Don't take it too personally BC, PM realized he was out on a limb and couldn't or wouldn't support his position so he gets all indignant and leaves. It's tactic used by a few on this BB. It could be called Fuck Up and Run.
 
Sorry basketcase.... I owe you an apology.

I confused your name with blackrock's and thought you were blackrock insisting on getting me into one of those debates that I abhor... :o

That being said, the subject matter is very broad and deep... and not the kind of topic suited for a discussion board like this...

Some scholars spend years (sometimes lifetimes) delving into the subtleties of these issues and that is one of the reasons why I consider a knock-em-down debate less than useful. That, also, is one of the reasons that I put what I said as a take-it-or-leave-it proposition... I wanted to present the ideas (which I am fully prepared to defend in another place and time) and let the reader decide what to do with them... if anything!

In the meantime, the resource materials I listed are a good place to start.

The fundamental issue between scientists and spiritual/mystic people (not religionists because religion is solely a question of belief and dogma, not of reason, intelligence or experience) are questions about ultimate reality or metaphysics... and the references I listed are a good place to learn about the ideas of our ancients.

Perry
 
Sorry basketcase.... I owe you an apology.

I confused your name with blackrock's and thought you were blackrock insisting on getting me into one of those debates that I abhor... :o

That being said, the subject matter is very broad and deep... and not the kind of topic suited for a discussion board like this...

Some scholars spend years (sometimes lifetimes) delving into the subtleties of these issues and that is one of the reasons why I consider a knock-em-down debate less than useful. That, also, is one of the reasons that I put what I said as a take-it-or-leave-it proposition... I wanted to present the ideas (which I am fully prepared to defend in another place and time) and let the reader decide what to do with them... if anything!

In the meantime, the resource materials I listed are a good place to start.

The fundamental issue between scientists and spiritual/mystic people (not religionists because religion is solely a question of belief and dogma, not of reason, intelligence or experience) are questions about ultimate reality or metaphysics... and the references I listed are a good place to learn about the ideas of our ancients.

Perry

So, again you say you bring up a topic on this BB and make a brief statement about that topic, followed by a pearl of a comment that the topic is too broad and complicated for this forum and then leave it at that, expecting everyone to just read and forget. Kind of useless, unless the whole idea was to just bring a spotlight on you for a moment, however brief and however small, then leave.

Bye!
 
I guess I shouldn't be surprised to find that idiotic comments followed an idiotic premise.

Science and Religion are inherently incompatible you boobs. From the get go. One develops knowledge, or sees the world, through faith. The other seeks to know through scientific inquiry. You can't get more opposed or incompatible than that.
 
I guess I shouldn't be surprised to find that idiotic comments followed an idiotic premise.

Science and Religion are inherently incompatible you boobs. From the get go. One develops knowledge, or sees the world, through faith. The other seeks to know through scientific inquiry. You can't get more opposed or incompatible than that.
So if you read the article, therefore many academic insitutions such as Oxford and Cambridge are filled with boobs?
 
So if you read the article, therefore many academic insitutions such as Oxford and Cambridge are filled with boobs?

Yup. When I see a scientist resort to methods that betray scientific method in order to substantiate personal superstitions, then yes, "boob" is a fair and accurate description.

I was wrong in at least one case about the comments on this thread though. Perry Mason's pronouncements aren't boobish. They go way way beyond that. They entered the realm of the moronic, sped up, and never looked back.
 
I guess I shouldn't be surprised to find that idiotic comments followed an idiotic premise.

Science and Religion are inherently incompatible you boobs. From the get go. One develops knowledge, or sees the world, through faith. The other seeks to know through scientific inquiry. You can't get more opposed or incompatible than that.

You are the boob in that you are trying to make the two the same in order to prove your point.


Why is it that you are entitled to your opinion but others are not?
 
I am not denying anyone the right to an opinion. I'm simply commenting on the quality of that opinion.

What "two" am I trying to make the same?

SCM tries to ornament his argument with scientific language, but it really just boils down to the same tired old creationist stance--namely that if we can't explain every aspect evolution, then the unexplained must be proof of God's existence. You can replace God in that argument with anything - a 57 Chevy, me, a teapot, and there'd be just as much proof for the Creationist argument. SMC's argument is a tortured one. He is Christian, and wants to find support for his religious views, so he selects some facts and ignores others. That's bad science.

The history of science, especially since Darwin, is an uninterrupted retreat by the Creationists. Bit by bit, they've lost every bit of ground they've stood on.
 
I was wrong in at least one case about the comments on this thread though. Perry Mason's pronouncements aren't boobish. They go way way beyond that. They entered the realm of the moronic, sped up, and never looked back.
Oh, lucky, I am so hurt and wounded that I think I am going to cry!!!

"If you would be a real seeker after truth, it is necessary that at least once in your life you doubt, as far as possible, all things." Rene Descartes... I guess he was also a boob! :p

Perry
 
Expecting you to cry would suggest I think you have the capacity to be embarrassed by what you've written here. That's obviously not the case for either of us.
 
'Religion and Science' belongs to the OXYMORON thread

thread closed
 
Well, the terms are not technically oxymorons, but I sympathize with the temptation to use at least part of that word.
 
'Religion and Science' belongs to the OXYMORON thread

thread closed

I guess that Einstein was a moron by your definition when he said:

"Science without religion is lame. Religion without science is blind."

"Every one who is seriously involved in the pursuit of science becomes convinced that a spirit is manifest in the laws of the Universe-a spirit vastly superior to that of man, and one in the face of which we with our modest powers must feel humble."

No offense but given a choice between you and Einstein as the arbiter of what is moronic I will choose Einstein.
 
I agree with Einstein's take on religion. He didn't believe in a personal god. His religious beliefs were almost secular, worshipping whatever nature is behind cosmic order. No old man (judeo Christian perspective ) with a big beard figure for him.