Racism on TERB

papasmerf said:
Untill people get past race there will be racism. Would you hire a white person if they were the most qualified for the job?
The question is, if there were two equally qualified people - one white, one black - and only one position, which would you hire?



My choice, the one with the biggest boobies. :D

P.S. Ah, as those who have met me can atest, I'm a cranky old white guy who loves chocolate ladies! Vanilla is sooooo boring.

P.P.S. Does that make me a racists? It's true you know, "Once you've tried black...."
 
Meister said:
I am not talking about you being white and your neighbour being Korean. On a global scale the western society is going to loose power and influence. This is a slow process and there is nothing you and I can do about it.
The industrial revolution in the 19th century showed that the resulting economic power (for mostly white people) was the envy of the world. Economic power is shifting to Asia and will become the envy of the world.

I am not disillusioned about it and I am white.
To a point I think I'd have to agree with you. In N.America over the last decade or two there has been more emphasis on intellectual values - selling ideas and knowledge. This is in part, I think, because the third world nations are gaining better control over the raw materials within their own lands which fuel the industrial economy.

This trend may turn into the driving force behind first world nation's development of space - to gain access to raw materials needed to support the industrial economy - without having to increase the relience on or share more power with third world nations.
 
True facts

Unfortunately Papa does have a point... there have been instances where a "more qualified" white male was NOT hired/promoted because there was a quota that had to be met of hiring/promoting a "minority". Yell, scream, and throw tantrums all you want but when that happens it is just as wrong as not hiring/promoting someone because they are a minority.
 
Quest4Less said:
Unfortunately Papa does have a point... there have been instances where a "more qualified" white male was NOT hired/promoted because there was a quota that had to be met of hiring/promoting a "minority". Yell, scream, and throw tantrums all you want but when that happens it is just as wrong as not hiring/promoting someone because they are a minority.

I'm reminded of Chris Rock's standup routine where he says to the audience, "There isn't a white guy in the room who would trade places with me, and I'm rich." Any idea that white men in America face any real degree of discrimination as opposed to what many others have gone through, and continue to go through, is ridiculous. The power structure in the US is still essentially a white man's domain.
 
solitaria said:
PS - In ALL probability franky66 got pulled over because he was driving while black otherwise he wouldn't be so angry about it. I am sure more black people get pulled over for the wrong reasons than for legitimate reasons or at the very least more innocent blacks get pulled over than innocent whites. You have to be in some serious denial to think otherwise.

I actually have to agree with this statement.
My Trinidadian friend from College is as Canadian as you can be. He plays hockey and eats hamburgers and has bbq's any chance he gets.
He also gets harrassed and eye balled everytime he's in a store. When he's with me or my Italian friend, it's a bit different. They look at him but with a grain of salt. It really is sad how he is treated. It's hard to change the perception or attitudes of people after centuries of racial oppression and stereotyping.
 
It is also interesting to note that just because you are white, it doesn't mean you won't get discriminated. What I mean is that, even if you are white but don't have an Anglo last name, your chances of being "accepted" is as low as a visible minority. I think that Canadian society as a whole still "values" Western European whites, especially those from the British Isles more then any other whites, subsequently, any other group of ethnicities.

I remember from school saying that Canadian immigration policy and society ranks the ethnicities like this (from most favourable to unfavourable):

1) Anglos (it's obvious why they are ranked most favourable - "White Canada")
2) Western Europeans ( common "Western Civ.", demoratic, etc. etc.)
3) Eastern Europeans ( they're white but ex-Commies, ex-Habsburgs, etc. etc.)
4) Balkans ( they're ex-Commies, ex-Habsburgs, etc. etc.)
5) Asians ( they look different, different culture, etc. etc.)
6) Blacks (they look different, different culture, etc. etc.)

Of course, immigration policy has changed but the attitude toward the different ethnicities of our Canadian ethnicities remain the same ... unfortunately.

Furthermore, if the company you work for isn't runned by Francophones, there are very few large corporations who are headed by a Francophone.
 
ruck said:
It's hard to change the perception or attitudes of people after centuries of racial oppression and stereotyping.

It's just as hard to convince people who've never experienced it, that it exists.
 
And your proof of this would be...

papasmerf said:
The fact I am white kept me from getting decent jobs that are set aside for others.

...that you had also interviewed every other candidate of color and thus knew you were more qualified, in addition to being seen as a better fit for the organization?

I am amazed at how many people assume that if someone of color was hired, it had to be simply because they were a member of a minority group.

At best I think it comes from a fundamental lack of understanding regarding how Affirmative Action programs work. The truth is though, I think it just makes for a more comfortable place to "hide" versus facing up to the fact that their skills (both "hard" and "soft"...heaven knows I've met enough candidates who thought that simply being smart and white was enough) were not a match for the role.

I recall years ago a guy who worked for me made a comment about how "we" (my and his employer) were hiring less qualified engineers. He based this on the fact that I had shared during a presentation that that company was making an effort to recruit and hire more minorities (of all colors, including "female") in order to diversify our ranks.

I explained to him that while we were RECRUITING candidates belonging to groups who were underrepresented in our work force (such as white females- anyone who knows about these things will explain to you that Affirmative Action in the US has benefited white females far more than any other demographic), this wasn't the same as HIRING THEM. I went on to inform him that while I recently had spent an entire day at the campus of my (and his, coincidentally) alma mater specifically looking to identify talented minority and female engineers, I didn't find any that day worthy of a second interview. We weren't "lowering our standards"...we were simply making more of an effort to find minorities (and women) who MET our standards.

It is in fact ILLEGAL to hire someone for the vast majority of jobs (99% plus) based on race. For those few jobs where this is something that can be done, virtually all of them involve the government sector, and are regarding "at arms length" relationships...meaning the person in question isn't really an employee, but instead a contractor of some sort (government contracts that are set aside for minority OWNED companies are fairly common, though becoming more rare - same for female owned companies - but there is no reason why a white male couldn't be an employee of said companies and actually perform the work).

Here is something that might surprise you...many companies would LOVE to hire based on race (and the assumed associated culture). You think advertising firms wouldn't LOVE to say "hire some Black and Latino creative people...we need to market to those audiences...right now we've got too many suburban breed white guys around here". They can't. Instead, what they have to do is work like hell to find recruits in places where said candidates are likely to be Black or Latino...and then send those candidates through the identical hiring process in hopes that they are qualified. It is illegal to use race to screen said candidate - and companies take great pains to avoid lawsuits based on this. All racial profiling information is kept completely separate from the candidate data, and is never shared with the hiring manager. Can the manager make some assumption based on what he / she sees? Sure...but that cuts both ways.

I recall a time when I was specifically looking to hire an experienced Latino engineer for a project we were undertaking in Mexico. It was a very important project and relationships would be important - this person needed to be able to fit into the cultural and be able to do business comfortably in Mexico in addition to having to live there for an extended period. I wanted a Latino, my (white) management wanted a Latino, and we all knew a Latino would have a higher likelihood for success. Couldn't hire one based on that though - it’s illegal. All we could do is making being fluent in Spanish a requirement. I met lots of guys - mostly white guys who spoke Spanish. I also met a few Latinos, but none who were a good fit. Searched as long as we could, then push came to shove. Hired a white guy who spoke Spanish and who had done business in Mexico before. Things worked out fine - but my point is that the search would have been simpler had I been able to limit it - had I been able to tell our HR department "find me a Latino guy with these qualifications". But you can't. It’s illegal.

In summary, it is highly unlikely you have ever been denied employment because you are white. Much more than likely, it was because you weren't the right fit for the job - perhaps beyond your technical quantitative skills.

In other words, you came off like an asshole, and they decided they didn't want you around. It happens....
 
Last edited:
MLAM said:
...that you had also interviewed every other candidate of color and thus knew you were more qualified, in addition to being seen as a better fit for the organization?



It is in fact ILLEGAL to hire someone for the vast majority of jobs (99% plus) based on race. For those few jobs where this is something that can be done, virtually all of them involve the government sector, and are regarding "at arms length" relationships...meaning the person in question isn't really an employee, but instead a contractor of some sort (government contracts that are set aside for minority OWNED companies are fairly common, though becomng more rare - same for female owned companies - but there is no reason why a white male couldn't be an employee of said companies and actually perform the work).


I recall a time when I was specifically looking to hire an experienced Latino engineer for a project we were undertaking in Mexico. It was a very important project and relationships would be important - this person needed to be able to fit into the cultural and be able to do business comfortably in Mexico in addition to having to live there for an extended period. I wanted a Latino, my (white) management wanted a Latino, we all knew a Latino would have a higher likelyhood for success. Couldn't hire one based on that though -its illegal. All we could do is making being fluent in Spanish a requirement. Met lots of guys - mostly white guys who spoke spanish. Met a few Latinos, but none who were a good fit. Searched as long as we could, then push came to shove. Hired a white guy who spoke spanish and who had done business in Mexico before. Things worked out fine - but my point is that the search would have been simplier had I been able to limit it - had I been able to tell our HR department "find me a Latino guy with these qualifications". But you can't. Its illegal.

In summary, it is highly unlikely you have ever been denied employment because you are white. Much more than likely, it was because you weren't the right fit for the job - perhaps beyond your technical quantatative skills.

In other words, you came off like an asshole, and they decided they didn't want you around. It happens....




No actualy the fact is applications were not being given to whites.

Your stating I came off like an asshole shows your narrow mindedness and how you justify things.

Youur assumptions show your racism and how foolish it is. I support hiring qualifed applicants, no matter the color, sex, race or religion. I never have and never will favor excluding anyone from applying.

BTW check out the minority requirements for the BUFFALO SCHOOL PROJECTS. Something like 46%, even if no qualified applicants are available.


Your recolection of wishing to hire a Latino surprises me. Why didn't you recruit in MEXICO?? There you had a solid chance of meeting your goal. Maybe it is because you wanted a Canadian and not a MEXICAN in the positon. Antother racist position.
 
Actually...

papasmerf said:
Your recolection of wishing to hire a Latino surprises me. Why didn't you recruit in MEXICO?? There you had a solid chance of meeting your goal. Maybe it is because you wanted a Canadian and not a MEXICAN in the positon. Antother racist position.

...for a few reasons. One, because that would have required a substantial legal process that would have more than likely both been filled with delay and perhaps corruption. Two, because while the project was temporary, the role was not - so the idea was to bring someone on board who would stay with the company, but be initially based in Mexico on the project, versus hiring someone local then having to convince them to permanently relocate to the United States (an expensive and legally challenging process, along with the associated cultural integration issues in reverse). Neither of these have to do with racism (BTW, the company, I, and the hiring polices I spoke of are all American...I am not completely clear how things work here in Canada - I think I mentioned that I haven't done any hiring here, but maybe I did not). It is simply much easier to send an American to Mexico for 6 months and bring him back than it is to do what is necessary to hire a Mexican in Mexico - then convince him or her to move to the United States. An experienced engineer in Mexico makes a good living and lives like a king - an experienced engineer in the US makes a good living and lives like...well, and experienced engineer. Why would a person come north if they had a great job there?

Insofar far as applications not being given to whites - well, you'd have a case for a lawsuit. That would be illegal. Wouldn't be the first time however an application has been refused to someone because of race...the difference being however that you seemed to imply that this was because of various policies (hence my reference to affirmative action).

In regards to the Buffalo School Projects - I'm not familiar. Any idea what roles these positions are for, or if they are indeed direct hires? I wouldn't surprised at all if it is for contracting...and as I stated previously, requirements that contracting firms be minority or female owned are not at all unusual for government engagements. If you have a link I'll look at it and eat crow if appropriate, but I just cannot fathom any direct hiring practice that explicitly states a certain percentage of those actually brought on board as employees must be of a certain race. Again, this is a very common assumption / stereotype regarding Affirmative Action, but also very not true.

Lastly, I was being somewhat tongue in cheek regarding the "asshole" comment. Just saying that often times people don't get a job they THINK they are qualified for simply because they don't interview well. Sort of like the "A" student that did nothing but study and who can't land a job out of college (and comes to the interview inappropriately dressed and equipped with an arrogant attitude), and resents the "B" student who join various clubs and activities in college, demonstrated social and leadership skills, and knew how to conduct themselves in an interview.
 
Last edited:
DateMasamune said:
I remember from school saying that Canadian immigration policy and society ranks the ethnicities like this (from most favourable to unfavourable):

1) Anglos (it's obvious why they are ranked most favourable - "White Canada")
2) Western Europeans ( common "Western Civ.", demoratic, etc. etc.)
3) Eastern Europeans ( they're white but ex-Commies, ex-Habsburgs, etc. etc.)
4) Balkans ( they're ex-Commies, ex-Habsburgs, etc. etc.)
5) Asians ( they look different, different culture, etc. etc.)
6) Blacks (they look different, different culture, etc. etc.)

Of course, immigration policy has changed but the attitude toward the different ethnicities of our Canadian ethnicities remain the same ... unfortunately.

That used to be correct in the 1950s to the 80s. A good example is the immigration of Dutch and German people after WWII. The enemy status of Germans was quickly removed to allow entry. It was much harder as an Asian back then.

These days the biggest criterion for immigration is filling a particular skill such as registered nurses, welders, carpenters, machinists, computer systems analysts etc. This list keeps changing based on need.
 
here we go again

One of the best ways to stop racism is to live by example. My parents were extremely poor in Trinidad, and it was a struggle to come up here and we lived in the Regent park area for about 10 years. When we came up here we hardly ate anything and we had to wear the same clothes for two days straight in order for my father to be able to attend college. Despite all that we have gone through my father is now a successful accountant . My father has decided to help the black people by teaching them taxes, personal finances...etc at local community centres. Going to high school some of my friends ( phillpino, white, and black), were involved in various criminal activities, some had a wealthy family (including the blacks) and some had a poor family. Yet despite all this I am attending university with a couple more years left (studying accounting). So no matter what environment you live in there are ways you can get out. The reason I write this is to show that I lived in proverty but my family was still able to get out.

There are always people who will be racist and no matter what we SAY or even do their minds will not be changed. We can talk until we are blue in the face but the fact remains that (especially through the help of the media) black youths are viewed as being criminals and we can't deny that a lot of black youths are committing crimes. Yes we are looked down a lot by society but it is not going to help by just telling people "This is because we are oppressed" because they will just keep shoving the facts in our faces. The best thing is to help our own people (and it is definitely not going to happen over night), because trust me there isn't any other race that is going to help us. We need to be role models for the black youths for all they have on television is BET, and 80 % is all about music and fashion during the day and evening. At my university I have not seen more than 5 Afro Americans professors, and two of them were just teaching Afro American literature courses. Therefore the black doctors, lawyers and accountants and any other profession (especially those who came out of ta poor community) need to go back to show these children at a very young age that they can make a difference. Some are going to say we tried that but it hardly works, but it does help a couple children to change and to me that is good enough we cannot change everybody in an instant. Don't get me wrong we can talk to people and tell them that not every black person is a druggie or a criminal, but remember actions speak louder than words. Always remember that no matter what we try and do to prove that we are not always criminals there is always going to be the ignorant persons that will never change their minds. Hence forget what people think and just make sure that you are making a difference and lead by examples.

We moved in a predominatly white neighbourhood and our neighbours were very reluctant in talking to us first, but as the years went by, we have become very close friends and recently the father told us that he didn't trust us blah blah but then he realized we are just like him trying to survive successfully (economically, spritually, mentally etc) in this world.

Side note: I know this is my first post and I have been registered for a long time. My excuse is that I started a relationship with someone around September and I was hoping it would worked but unfortunately it didn't :( so it has been a month since I have been single and since I am going to university I have hardly had the funds to participate in certain activities (massages, SC). But I have seen Paris at SRM, info will be up in a couple days. I have also seen Janda but everybody knows about her so there really is no point. For all those that are ticked off for me doing this (taking a long time to post despite being in a relationship) ah well go see Janda to get your mind off of it. Now that I am single I will be posting.
 
Meister said:
These days the biggest criterion for immigration is filling a particular skill such as registered nurses, welders, carpenters, machinists, computer systems analysts etc. This list keeps changing based on need.

Might as well add like cab driver, Wal-Mart greeter, security, hot dog vendor, spa/nails attendant, etc. etc. that the locals don't want to do leaving it a vacuum for immigrants.

One night, I was chatting with a hot dog vendor guy at around 2:00 AM in the morning after a night out and he told me his drem job was to be a security guard in one of those office towers. He's been a hot dog vendor for 7 years and he doesn't even own the stand. This is the other side of the story of hard working immigrants who can't get a decent job and are stuck. No, it's not the language barrier, this hot dog vendor guy spoke perfect English ...

Furthermore, the largest most discriminating body/institution is the god damn government, not Canadian society. It's with these stupid policies that don't but whites and visible minorities on a equal footing creating a friction among the groups for jobs. Racism in Canadian society has a common thread running through all the deviations and that is job secuity/livelihood. One group blames another and race comes up ...
 
DateMasamune said:
Might as well add like cab driver, Wal-Mart greeter, security, hot dog vendor, spa/nails attendant, etc. etc. that the locals don't want to do leaving it a vacuum for immigrants.

I don't think you are realizing some of the labour shortages we have here. We don't have shortages of Wal-Mart greeters (don't even get me started on Wal-Mart). But, we do have shortages of some specific professions such as nursing and building trades. (insert lawyer joke here)

So, I think the government is doing the right thing by attracting those skills. They are even trying to fast track doctor's licenses from immigrants so that Northern Ontario can have an adequate number of doctors.

Canada and its citizens are very tolerant and welcoming towards immigrants, more so than most other countries.
 
The average Walmart employee who is an immigrant is better educated than the average native born Canadian. ;)
 
Stop the Blame Game

I live in the USA which is more racist than Canada. I'm amazed at how tolerant the white man has been with minorities. If whitey wanted to, he could ship all minorities back to their home countries.

You're posting on TERB? Congratulations! A lot of people (including poor whites) can't afford to go anywhere near a computer.

Are you a hobbyist? Banging a never-ending parade of high class white women SPs? How much more could you want than for whitey to allow you to pork his women? A lot of guys (including white guys) can't afford to hobby.

So it seems to me you're doing pretty well.

Of course, there is white privilege. Of course, there is white racism. Of course, there are times when you may be mistreated in public. Life is not fair, and it's certainly not perfect. We all need to suck it up.

Just do whatever you got to do to make yourself more qualified than everyone else. Would you rather be in the third world starving?

BTW, I'm not white.
 
Is everyone in the third world starving?

Barbados is considered a third world country. You think the people there are starving in droves?

A great misconception is that people who are in the USA and Canada are here because they just escaped starvation and a horrible life back in their home country.
 
Even when affirmative action and quotas were common, a qualified white man would still find a decent job, get into a university, etc. Might not be their first choice but it's still better than many minorities were getting before that. The ideal behind those policies, even the stupid ones was simply to try to give OPPORTUNITY to succeed, not the RIGHT to succeed. You'd be amazed at how little opportunity many have.
 
Ya, that makes sooo much sense...:(

Asterix said:
I'm reminded of Chris Rock's standup routine where he says to the audience, "There isn't a white guy in the room who would trade places with me, and I'm rich." Any idea that white men in America face any real degree of discrimination as opposed to what many others have gone through, and continue to go through, is ridiculous. The power structure in the US is still essentially a white man's domain.

So just because there has been discrimination in the past against minorities that makes it okay for there to be discrimination against non-minorities now? Sorry but that doesn't work.... "two wrongs do not make a right". Discrimination in ANY form against ANYONE is wrong - period.

And for the record - I have been discriminated against. I was up for a promotion and they gave it to a female minority who joined the company after I did, had less education, and a lousy attendence and attitude. Why? Because she told them she would sue for discrimination if they didn't. Even if in the long run they proved otherwise the publicity would have driven off a lot of customers - so they caved. So yes Virginia - reverse discrimination DOES exist.