Question

buttercup

Active member
Feb 28, 2005
2,564
11
38
The following extract is about how inevitable it is that some young kids go off the rails.

It was written well before sociologists and the like studied the subject.

Note how the author gets his points across very clearly, and personally to the reader. (The author is not writing about himself, but about his observations.)

Who wrote it?


Let the reader try to picture the following:
There is a lodging in a cellar and this lodging consists of two damp rooms. In these rooms a workman and his family live--seven people in all. Let us assume that one of the children is a boy of three years. That is the age at which children first become conscious of the impressions which they receive. In the case of highly gifted people traces of the impressions received in those early years last in the memory up to an advanced age. Now the narrowness and congestion of those living quarters do not conduce to pleasant inter-relations.
Thus quarrels and fits of mutual anger arise. These people can hardly be said to live with one another, but rather down on top of one another. The small misunderstandings which disappear of themselves in a home where there is enough space for people to go apart from one another for a while, here become the source of chronic disputes.
As far as the children are concerned the situation is tolerable from this point of view. In such conditions they are constantly quarrelling with one another, but the quarrels are quickly and entirely forgotten. But when the parents fall out with one another these daily bickerings often descend to rudeness such as cannot be adequately imagined.
The results of such experiences must become apparent later on in the children. One must have practical experience of such a milieu so as to be able to picture the state of affairs that arises from these mutual recriminations when the father physically assaults the mother and maltreats her in a fit of drunken rage. At the age of six the child can no longer ignore those sordid details which even an adult would find revolting. Infected with moral poison, bodily undernourished, and the poor little head filled with vermin, the young 'citizen' goes to the primary school. With difficulty he barely learns to read and write.
There is no possibility of learning any lessons at home. Quite the contrary. The father and mother themselves talk before the children in the most disparaging way about the teacher and the school and they are much more inclined to insult the teachers than to put their offspring across the knee and knock sound reason into him. What the little fellow hears at home does not tend to increase respect for his human surroundings. Here nothing good is said of human nature as a whole and every institution, from the school to the government, is reviled. Whether religion and morals are concerned or the State and the social order, it is all the same; they are all scoffed at.
When the young lad leaves school, at the age of fourteen, it would be difficult to say what are the most striking features of his character, incredible ignorance in so far as real knowledge is concerned or cynical impudence combined with an attitude towards morality which is really startling at so young an age.
What station in life can such a person fill, to whom nothing is sacred, who has never experienced anything noble but, on the contrary, has been intimately acquainted with the lowest kind of human existence?
This child of three has got into the habit of reviling all authority by the time he is fifteen. He has been acquainted only with moral filth and vileness, everything being excluded that might stimulate his thought towards higher things. And now this young specimen of humanity enters the school of life.
He leads the same kind of life which was exemplified for him by his father during his childhood. He loiters about and comes home at all hours. He now even black-guards that broken-hearted being who gave him birth. He curses God and the world and finally ends up in a House of Correction for young people. There he gets the final polish.
 
Hitler but this is not before the subject was studied.

Yes, Hitler. I thought it would be difficult!!

He wrote Mein Kampf in 1923, in prison. The subject really had not been studied, as we now think of that subject, at that time.

Hitler really was a most excellent communicator. He had his faults, of course . . .
 
So even Hitler could see what evil would result from leaving parents to have kids in poverty trying to raise them with the inadequate means they have. What makes so many in our generation so blind to the obvious?
 
So even Hitler could see what evil would result from leaving parents to have kids in poverty trying to raise them with the inadequate means they have. What makes so many in our generation so blind to the obvious?

I don't like your "even". You're implying surprise that H might have been capable of sympathetic insights and feelings, him being evil and all.

Please don't think I support his racial views, and the rest of his corruption. But I don't think we do ourselves any favours by refusing to recognize just how truly brilliant H was. He was deeply understanding of the human condition, especially of working class people. He was a breathtakingly good speaker, who connected with every person in his audience. Perhaps the greatest orator the world has ever known. Considerably better than Churchill, who was very good indeed. His recognition of sociological causes and effects was, in 1923, original and world-leading.

Perhaps today, of all days, we should give thanks that his kind are few and far between.
 
There has always been a fine line between genius, and insanity. It's pretty easy to see this guy crossed the line by fair bit.