First of all I wouldn't use anything that isn't recommended for use on the penis. You are better off to go to the sex store and get a desensitization cream. Don't go cheap or you will just get a numb unpleasant feeling.
Things that have worked for me in this situation are - have the client put on the cream BEFORE he comes to see you. If he is comfortable with a condom on from the beginning and a cock ring that can help to. But the key is to have him put them on, not you. I know it is nice to have the intimacy of you doing it but with the removal of that intimacy you might actually get these things in place.
Then, I usually start the session out very slow. Pay attention the the thighs, creating a sensation in the area but not touching the penis itself. Give a back rub. And like Kyra said, let him watch you pleasure yourself or finger you or play with a toy in you. Most of these men could care less that they came but moreso that they didn't have a chance to get you off first. So switch the focus to you first untill he is excited enough that he doesn't care if he cums quick . . . . THEN you can touch him. The longer you guys do this and his confidence goes up, the longer he will be able to hold off.
It takes time and talking about it together. Let him know that it doesn't matter when he cums and that you like playing with his cock even if he's cum and isn't hard again. These things take time, which shouldn't be a problem because he is likely a repeater. Ask him where he likes to cum. And then at least if it happens quick you can direct it in a way that turns him on and don't let the intimacy stop just because he came.
At least that is what works for me. But you are a smart girl Shauna. I am sure you have already tried 95% of that. Just thought I would respond in full for anyone else who may be having the same issue.