Question Re. Ebay vs Craigslist for Selling

Kilgore Trout

Active member
Oct 18, 2008
2,489
0
36
I have an Ebay account that I've used about 30 times over past 7 years to buy misc items.
But, I've never sold anything there and I have some miscellaneous computer and garage equipment that I want to get rid of because I don't need them anymore and they take up space.

My main question is what is the commission at Ebay for selling things? I can't figure it out. All Ebay's selling information is vague and evasive and ambiguous about what you pay for selling and I can't find straight answers on their website.

Example, if you sell something for $500. is the commission the same as for a $25. item. What if you sell something and they return it a week later do you get the selling fee back because I'll let people return an item within a week if they figure it's not what they need.

I think I read there is no commission if your item doesn't sell in alloted time. Is that right?

Also, if you have used both Craigslist and Ebay for selling items in Toronto what was your experience? I know all ads are free on Craigslist; so, is the money you pay Ebay worth it for listings? Ie do you get a larger response and bigger selling price for Ebay listings compared to Craigslist?

Thanks for any info.
 
No commission if not sold, but there is a "listing fee" paid regardless. Although this month they have a special "no listing fees for AUCTION STYLE items." Plan on bout 12% including Paypal's piece of the action if item sells.

I start at Ebay. Click on "advanced search." Put the item you want to sell in the description. Then check "completed listings." Then search. That will list ALL items like yours that have or have not sold and at what price. That will give you an idea of what it may be worth. I would start by listing it on Craigslist and if it doesn't sell then go to Ebay.

Ebay CAN definitely be worth it. Long story short, I was selling Santa's on Ebay for $250. They sold in hours (about 15 of them) on Ebay. NO ONE even inquired about on them from my Craigslist ad.

I am moving so I have been selling large items with great success on Craigslist. 99% of the people have been awesome and paid pretty much what I wanted. And no commission payment was very nice.

Anyway, start with the Ebay completed item search to see what your item may be worth. Then list at CL first and then Ebay. Of course things you can't ship easily are definite CL items. Got to always be on the lookout for scammers and deadbeats on Ebay. Another good reason to start at CL.

I live in the Figer Lakes area of NY so I have Rochester and Syracuse to list on. Good luck.
 
Okay, thanks for your info, it's what I needed to know.
I didn't know you could count on commissions coming out to about 12% after Paypal and Ebay take their cut. Ebay must be making a lot of money because they have a virtual monopoly and they also own Paypal.
 
That % includes other fees like some of the photo options you may want is close. I paid about $3-400 for the $3750 Santa's I sold, but believe Ebay was well worth the cost for the exposure I got. The Santa's weighed about 40 lbs a piece.

Another quick story. I sold a 20 year old Sears Chipper/Shredder catch bag (looks like a laundry bag) I found in a drawer in my garage for $25 on Ebay after no responses on CL.

The "search completed items" on Ebay is a great tool to find out what stuff is worth. Even if I'm not plan on selling an item it's nice to see what buyers are paying for something I have. I have a friend who SUCKS at selling things on Ebay/CL because he doesn't look at WHAT PEOPLE HAVE PAID for the same item. He is always overpriced because he sets the price at what HE THINKS IT'S WORTH.

Good luck.
 
I have a friend who SUCKS at selling things on Ebay/CL because he doesn't look at WHAT PEOPLE HAVE PAID for the same item. He is always overpriced because he sets the price at what HE THINKS IT'S WORTH.

Everytime I see one of those "Flip this House, etc" TV shows I laugh. Your point is so right, no matter WHAT you are selling. Price point will make the difference.
 
i prefer kijiji.ca and craigslist to sell things , i have sold over 20 items on there with out a problem , you save on shipping and hassle in the most part .
 
I think the main issue is whether your product has a better opportunity of being sold locally vs globally, eg value, size, weight, appeal. Old garage stuff really is a local play.
 
pcOmo, thanks for the reminder about kijiji. I totally forgot about that option; but thanks for reminding me.
----
Re Ebay pricing:
I always wondered why some people had low prices for some things coupled with very high shipping charges.
Eg. one person would sell something for 129.99 from California with shipping charges of 79.99 while another in California would charge 209.99 for the same item; but, with free shipping to Toronto. Obviously the first guy is looking to keep his ebay commission low by loading a lot of the price into the shipping cost which I guess Ebay doesn't take a commission on.

As for myself, I plan on making everything local pick up only. I don't want to ship anything to anybody even if I get less money for it.
So, I'm thinking I'll start with Kijiji and Craigslist.
I'll only do shipping on something if there is no local demand for it.

Thanks for all the input everyone.
 
I'd go with Kijiji, I've sold several things there successfully. Even a lefty mandolin to a fellow in Victoria in 2 weeks. I thought it would sit forever. However Kijiji even though it is owned by Ebay isn't very big in the US and you can only list your item in one city. Craigslist is a lot bigger but you get bombarded with phishing emails " I'll buy your item, please send your banking info and address" or MLM schemes.