Question on dealing with pathological liars

osanowo said:
You are definitely right on that one.
Now if his reaction was not triggered by any hostility on your end,

No it was not. He came into my home, his behavior was loud, obnoxious, (nothing unusual there) and telling me wild story that was obviously impossible and not anywhere near factual (with out going into details, trust me on the factual element). Normally I ignore this behavior, (have done so for years) but this time I challenged his story, saying something trivial like, 'Common buddy those blah blah blah, where not blah blah blah .. ( a direct challenge to his facts). Whoops. Big mistake. Next, I was looking at a raised fist, caulked and pointing in my face. So I simply ordered him out of the home. (he went) This happened in the space of about 2 minutes. It was incredible how the behavior transitioned from casual conversation to a violent confrontation. This is a unique experience with a relative by the way, I am not the belligerent type. But I do stand my ground. When someone threatens you in your own home, you have little choice about what to do next. The run-up scene was something you would only see on say a CSI flashback, where they are investigating a homicide. I don't laugh at the credulity of those scenes any more, because now I understand how quickly a discussion can turn violent over the most trivial of matters. In fact now that I look back on the short fuse aspect, I am wondering if the guy is on meth. There is a possibility I guess. It would match the short-fuse element.

then he is definitely telling you to mind your own business and to stop ruining the little world he managed to build so far.


Yes, I think you have spelled it out. It makes sense to me. The challenge was then not to the story but well beyond, to his whole house-of-cards persona, and he probably harbours some deep anger bottled-up that was unleashed. Maybe he has been seriously challenged by someone else recently that he now hates (no idea who, police, ex-girlfriend, male friend, who knows) hence there is a simmering anger. I must have triggered it and became its lighting rod. Probably unexpectedly for both of us.

If that's the way he thinks, acting as a dominant in a vertical relationship will not help. If you show yourself as stronger, he'll back off but he will still continue to do his schemes in the background and you will bear the consequences afterwards.

Well, it happens that I am you might say, senior to this fellow in age and other ways. And yes, that's one way to put it, as you say i was acting as the dominant in a vertical relationship when I threw him out of the home ,otherwise he would not have gone with the command. (nice language that, BTW, sounds like you have really done your home work)
I know it is something people don't want to hear about in America, but backing off in this situation was the best answer and the wisest decision. And I am not saying that because of the French genes...

It often takes a lot to answer with your wisdom instead of your ego; and if it's for your good then you'll need the first one more than the second...

Well, I played junior hockey, and grew up in a neighborhood before people carried guns were you fought your way out of disagreements regularly. I'm no stranger to scrapping at all. But in this case, it wasn't the time nor the place, so I kept my cool (although the adrenaline was pumping for sure). Its never good in a family to strike a member. And thanks for pointing it out, but I truly have no sense of ego about this whatsoever. I really just want to avoid confrontation. Its not my cup of tea and I have nothing to prove.

I really appreciate your comments. They have been very helpful to understand things.
 
Sorry, I just have to add a little levity to the thread:

When you say "Its never good in a family to strike a member." I had to laugh because what happens if you do is you end up on Jerry Springer lol
 
Mcluhan said:
Its never good in a family to strike a member...

lol

tboy said:
you end up on Jerry Springer

lol yeah or at the police station, unfortunately...


Mcluhan said:
I really appreciate your comments. They have been very helpful to understand things.

My pleasure!
I came to realize how understanding the theories of manipulation can help to disable the triggers and release you from the strings of it.
When you don't have enough empathy (do we ever have enough...) some things are hard to understand in people's reactions; and sometimes you carry the weight of it without noticing. Let's say the situation you talked about ended up in you feeling guilty for a situation that was, from what you say, directly linked to his wrong being... and most people would tell you that he's a jerk or other would tell you to go and ease the tensions, apologize.
But for what good? You'd feel the burden of something you did not commit and did not understand!

Realizing that leads you to understand how manipulation comes from deeds of particularly selfish persons, closed up - and there is more and more of these guys.
I am glad it has helped you, and I'd recommend any book dealing with manipulation... it's been the smallest books I have read (50 pages) and by far the most powerful.

Freedom never seems farther than when you learn to know the truth.
 
There's not much you can do about something serious like that. It would probably take a lot of effort and counselling to get someone like that to change a core part of their personality.

Privately calling them out is better than publicly.

In the one experience I had with it the guy obviously had self esteem issues which went a lot further than just having the need to hear a handful of people telling him that we liked him without the lies.

Sadly in the end we lost touch with him and the last we heard he was up on fraud charges and prison time.

I think a lot of people don't learn about the consequences of lying until it's too late.