Question on dealing with pathological liars

Mcluhan

New member
Does anyone have a friend or family member that is a pathological liar?

I have three family members, (it's a large family and these are cousins) , they are in the same nuclear family, who are pathological liars. I normally just ignore them but recently a situation developed which has me a little put off.

One MD's definition from a web site:
People who lie constantly are often called pathological liars. That's not an official clinical diagnosis, which means it's not listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, or DSM-IV. But chronic lying in adults is often a manifestation of antisocial personality disorder (also known as sociopathy). Sociopaths are often deceitful and manipulative in order to gain personal profit or pleasure.

In the case of these people it is a constant irritation. They would rather lie than tell the truth.

If you have people like this in your circle, how do you deal with them? Curious.
 
Mcluhan said:
If you have people like this in your circle, how do you deal with them? Curious.

Just lie back. :D
 
I caught a couple of new episodes of SNL and there is a new character on it that is just like that (lying). Things like: You should all come to MY party, Oprah is coming, Phil, Bill Clinton.....etc etc etc.

Call em on it EVERYTIME. Especially when you're amongst a crowd.

If you have a good memory, recall what they said on x and x date and say: that isn't what you said last week?

BTW: how old are these cousins?
 
Mac

this is hysterical you complain about your family liars and one of the hit the next post :p
 
Mcluhan said:
Does anyone have a friend or family member that is a pathological liar?

I have three family members, (it's a large family and these are cousins) , they are in the same nuclear family, who are pathological liars. I normally just ignore them but recently a situation developed which has me a little put off.

One MD's definition from a web site:
People who lie constantly are often called pathological liars. That's not an official clinical diagnosis, which means it's not listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, or DSM-IV. But chronic lying in adults is often a manifestation of antisocial personality disorder (also known as sociopathy). Sociopaths are often deceitful and manipulative in order to gain personal profit or pleasure.

In the case of these people it is a constant irritation. They would rather lie than tell the truth.

If you have people like this in your circle, how do you deal with them? Curious.
I knew someone in university who was a pathological liar. Even the stupidest stuff. He was called out on it and I have to say it was a very awkward moment and things just weren't the same after. I truly don't know how you deal with it effectively and with minimal consequences.
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KgsgIEQEc_Y

"Everything Harry tells you is a lie -- remember that! Everything Harry tells you is a lie!"
"Now listen to me carefully, Norman laddie; I - am - lying!"
"You lie, but if everything you say is a lie then you must be telling the truth, but you cannot be telling the truth because everything you say is a lie... you lie, you tell the truth, you– Illogical! Illogical! Please explain! You are human! Only humans can explain their behavior! Please explain!"
(mockingly) "I am not programmed to respond in that area..."

- Kirk and Mudd, delivering the final coup d'grace to Norman

http://memory-alpha.org/en/wiki/I,_Mudd
 
K Douglas said:
I knew someone in university who was a pathological liar. Even the stupidest stuff. He was called out on it and I have to say it was a very awkward moment and things just weren't the same after. I truly don't know how you deal with it effectively and with minimal consequences.

People lie because of a need for acceptance. Calling them out embarrasses them. There is no benefit for them. A liar needs to be approached one on one. Provide them with a level of comfort. If you choose to publicly call them on it you will be challenging them to tell a better lie.
 
Mcluhan said:
If you have people like this in your circle, how do you deal with them? Curious.
My 19 year old was falling into this pattern. I caught him a lie, where there was no benefit to him for lying and got him to admit he had a problem. Then I set him up with a clinical psychologist to delve into why he was doing it. He went for 10 or 12 sessions and it seems to have made a dramatic improvement.

Of course it would be different dealing with someone with whom you have a different/less close kind of relationship.
 
the key is to be non-confrontational

Calling someone out publicly is just rude and ineffective. The best thing to do is to talk to them privately and remind them that there is no need to lie. Remind them that you love them and accept them for who they are, not for who they are pretending to be. Do this in a disarming way, not a confrontational way, so that they don't feel judged, but comforted. Let them know that they aren't going to lose your friendship over this, but that the constant lies will cause you to spend less time with them if they continue.

xoxo Violet
 
Sorry, I don't agree V but it depends on what they are lying about. Are they lying just to impress you? Are they lying to make them seem somehow superior to you? (that they got better grades, make more money, have better friends blah blah blah).

In this case calling them on it only proves just how inane their lies really are.

Now if a highschooler lied to his or her uncle about their failing grades (instead of saying they are failing to say, "they're ok") is totally different. Or a kid lying because he did something wrong. But to lie just for the sake of lying SHOULD be called out. Otherwise what is there to be learned other than the fact that lying is ok?

Some lessons have to be learned and some of those lessons are hard. Being embarrassed in public will show that lying isn't the right thing to do hence if you don't want to be embarrassed, don't lie.

Here's a good example: A guy I worked for had a son. When his son reached about 4 yrs old he got it into his head that it was so much fun to jump off the third step. Well, Mom and Dad would see him getting ready to launch and rush over to catch him. They'd scold him and say he shouldn't do that he might get hurt to no avail. So one day they were sitting in the livingroom and his wife sees the kid getting ready to do it again, when she jumped up to go catch him he grabbed her by the arm and stopped her so the kid landed on the floor and bruised his noggin. Needless to say the kid didn't stair dive anymore.
 
shack said:
My 19 year old was falling into this pattern. I caught him a lie, where there was no benefit to him for lying and got him to admit he had a problem. Then I set him up with a clinical psychologist to delve into why he was doing it. He went for 10 or 12 sessions and it seems to have made a dramatic improvement.

Of course it would be different dealing with someone with whom you have a different/less close kind of relationship.

It occurs to me you did a very wise thing there Shack, hat's off to your approach, that was really good thinking. (and thanks for sharing that).

In this case, this group is ranging in age, 40+ and up. And truly, I guess I don't plan to do anything about the situation, because I am not in a close orbit with the group. My tendency is just to turn a deaf ear and let it play out as usual. The lies tend to be mostly in the form of self-aggrandizement, but one in particular makes up whole life episodes which go beyond embellishment. I do find it strange that there are three in one family and I guess I posted this question partly to see if anyone else had come across this situation of a 'pack of liars.' It seems odd to me.
 
Mac posted this
he is a member of mthe club
 
I had quite a bunch of lying people in my family, particularly my mother...
Somehow I agree with violet's approach, but firstly you need to determine the objective of the liar. To me there is no lying for lying.

Lying can be from a manipulative pattern (let's say to bring benefit to the liar) or a self defense mechanism.

The second pattern is difficult because the person is avoiding the truth to confort him; and hence need a therapy to gain self esteem. This therapy is long and needless to say that the person needs to realize that he needs it before doing it. That may be an approach, letting the person know and realize how low he thinks of himself (but not in a negative way of saying it).

The first pathology has two possibilities: either the manipulator does not realize he's doing it (or the harm he does to other people), or he does know what he is doing.
Obviously when he knows what he is doing, it is very difficult to change them. Usually, in the books, they say that these people need to be avoided at all costs as they most probably cannot change (hard psychosis, difficult to treat) - and staying next to them will only harm you, even if you want to do good. It was the case for my mother so I know what they mean. If you confront these people in public, they will try to have their revenge and most of the time will dodge your comments. It is hard to corner them as you need tangible proofs of their lie to show the audience how deep the lie or the manipulation is. Even if you succeed, this person will not be likely to cure (though it happens) and will most probably try to find another place to do it again, and another circle of people.
If you try to talk to this person, then he will know that you know and will act accordingly. This is known as a type 3 manipulator.

A more positive one is the type 2 manipulator. He does not know how his lies and manipulation affects the others, and it's high likely that he will stop - and change - if shown, peacefully, how his words can be harmful to others or give a bad image of him (though he thought it could be better for his ego).


Just keep in mind that everybody has his own way to reach happiness, no matter how odd it looks to you or me.

A diplomatic approach is always paying, and it will allow you to know how this person really feels about what he does. If he knows, hence a type 3, run away or be prepared to see your relationship change. If he doesn't know, then you will gain everything to tell him/her as this person will feel better and maybe he will trust you deeply.

I admit that it is very difficult to make the approach. In my case, it was my mother so I was kind of obliged to do it; and I also had other friends I wanted to see again and who were ruining the gatherings so there again I had to do it for one or two of them.

It's a cost, so weigh the benefits and the consequences. But if it works, you made a good dead and that's always a reward.
 
40 + ??? Holy fuck, I thought you were talking teenagers or 20 somethings...

With what you just posted Mc, it sounds to me like it is oneupmanship gone crazy.

This reminds me of a guy we worked with who we called "onebetter". No matter who won what, bought what, knew someone or had something, he always had "one better".

I can't remember what exactly it was that I called him on in front (I seem to recall it was about him owning something, car, boat, plane, house or similar)of the whole department but I remember saying to him "either bring us proof, or stay the fuck away from us...I've had it with your Bullshit". He didn't bring proof and as far as I can recall, he never ate lunch, break or socialized with us ever again. We dealt with him businesswise but that's it.
 
tboy said:
40 + ??? Holy fuck, I thought you were talking teenagers or 20 somethings...

With what you just posted Mc, it sounds to me like it is oneupmanship gone crazy.

This reminds me of a guy we worked with who we called "onebetter". No matter who won what, bought what, knew someone or had something, he always had "one better".

I can't remember what exactly it was that I called him on in front (I seem to recall it was about him owning something, car, boat, plane, house or similar)of the whole department but I remember saying to him "either bring us proof, or stay the fuck away from us...I've had it with your Bullshit". He didn't bring proof and as far as I can recall, he never ate lunch, break or socialized with us ever again. We dealt with him businesswise but that's it.

That actually hits a nail on the head. Comical. Dumb me, i didn't put 2+2 together there. This is very symptomatic of the group.
 
better to avoid the hostility, resentment

tboy said:
Sorry, I don't agree V but it depends on what they are lying about. Are they lying just to impress you? Are they lying to make them seem somehow superior to you? (that they got better grades, make more money, have better friends blah blah blah).

In this case calling them on it only proves just how inane their lies really are.

Now if a highschooler lied to his or her uncle about their failing grades (instead of saying they are failing to say, "they're ok") is totally different. Or a kid lying because he did something wrong. But to lie just for the sake of lying SHOULD be called out. Otherwise what is there to be learned other than the fact that lying is ok?

I understand what you are trying to convey, but there is a way to approach the person and handle the situation without the hostility. Simply pointing out the lie is not helpful, as most pathological liars have built so many lies upon lies that they start to believe their bullshit. I know, because I used to have that same problem. When you call them out on it, it only causes them to get defensive and unpropitious, and can even encourage more lies to cover up their faulty stories.

Some lessons have to be learned and some of those lessons are hard. Being embarrassed in public will show that lying isn't the right thing to do hence if you don't want to be embarrassed, don't lie.

Calling someone out publicly is extremely uncouth. Not only does it incite resentment and hostility, it demonstrates your character as judgmental and bullying.

Here's a good example: A guy I worked for had a son. When his son reached about 4 yrs old he got it into his head that it was so much fun to jump off the third step. Well, Mom and Dad would see him getting ready to launch and rush over to catch him. They'd scold him and say he shouldn't do that he might get hurt to no avail. So one day they were sitting in the livingroom and his wife sees the kid getting ready to do it again, when she jumped up to go catch him he grabbed her by the arm and stopped her so the kid landed on the floor and bruised his noggin. Needless to say the kid didn't stair dive anymore.

We aren't talking about children here, however. Pathological liars and children doing stupid things are very different situations.

I do understand what you are saying, but it just seems like a very brutish and immature way to deal with an adult situation. If these are your friends and you do care about them, why not encourage them to be honest with you as opposed to making them feel badly about themselves. Let them know that their lies are not benefiting them in any way, and how much you would rather spend time with them telling the truth. It's much better to give incentive for good behavior rather than punishment for the opposite - at least when dealing with adults.

~Violet~
 
V: while you may call it brutish and uncouth, I call it direct. I normally don't pussyfoot around problems and meet them head on and would treat (and have treated) this situation in the same way.

As for it being different than children doing stupid things, is it really? It is an adult doing a stupid thing. Simply telling them it is stupid that you know they are lying is not very impactful is it? SImply telling them that you don't want them around if they lie won't do a damn thing to change them. But if you create a scene where they realize that their lying has direct consequences then they might stop and think the next time they start spewing their verbal diarrea.

As for them being my friends, sorry, I wouldn't have someone like this in my life. If they were a family member I would call them on it, and if they didn't change I wouldn't interact with them or be around them ever again.

As for your incentive/punishment theory, sorry, that doesn't work either. Look at our jails? They are full of people who have incentives to stay on the straight and narrow and just don't.

Anyhow, you deal with these people your way, and I'll deal with them mine.

Peace Out sista!
 
tboy said:
V: while you may call it brutish and uncouth, I call it direct. I normally don't pussyfoot around problems and meet them head on and would treat (and have treated) this situation in the same way.

As for it being different than children doing stupid things, is it really? It is an adult doing a stupid thing. Simply telling them it is stupid that you know they are lying is not very impactful is it? SImply telling them that you don't want them around if they lie won't do a damn thing to change them. But if you create a scene where they realize that their lying has direct consequences then they might stop and think the next time they start spewing their verbal diarrea.

As for them being my friends, sorry, I wouldn't have someone like this in my life. If they were a family member I would call them on it, and if they didn't change I wouldn't interact with them or be around them ever again.

As for your incentive/punishment theory, sorry, that doesn't work either. Look at our jails? They are full of people who have incentives to stay on the straight and narrow and just don't.

Anyhow, you deal with these people your way, and I'll deal with them mine.

Peace Out sista!

Personally, although I didn't want to take sides in this debate, (its seems it is now a debate) HOWEVER your comments and oswano's terrific comments (imagine having the courage to deal with a mother on this basis) seems to jive with my way of handling this situation. I did actually confront the one individual 'once' some time ago, only because he was both in my personal space, and in my face. He immediately turned hostile, and threatened me violently. I couldn't believe how quickly it happened. It was then I realized I was dealing with a psychotic and dangerous person. And since I am neither a therapist or an immediate family member, I decided the best policy was to stay clear (far away). I raise this point because, sometimes minding your own business is by far the best route to take and the idea of helping someone might trigger a hostile back fire..
 
Mcluhan said:
Personally, although I didn't want to take sides in this debate, (its seems it is now a debate) HOWEVER your comments and oswano's terrific comments (imagine having the courage to deal with a mother on this basis) seems to jive with my way of handling this situation. I did actually confront the one individual 'once' some time ago, only because he was both in my personal space, and in my face. He immediately turned hostile, and threatened me violently. I couldn't believe how quickly it happened. It was then I realized I was dealing with a psychotic and dangerous person. And since I am neither a therapist or an immediate family member, I decided the best policy was to stay clear (far away). I raise this point because, sometimes minding your own business is by far the best route to take and the idea of helping someone might trigger a hostile back fire..

M: Your confrontation doesn't surprise me one bit. The types that lie to make themselves look good (see onebetter) are really insecure fuckwads and those are the types more prone to physical rather than mental confrontations. I hate to say it this way but your backing down only confirmed to him that his actions were the right ones (in his mind). Just think what would have happened had you confronted him in private one on one? He probably wouldn't have threatened you, you probably would have attacked you.

When I say call somoene on their lies I don't mean say "you're a fucking shithead liar" in front of everyone. For eg: Mr Braggart says he just bought a new Gallardo I'd say "hey that's great, show me a picture of it with you in the driver's seat in your driveway".....Of course he will say he doesn't have one then say "ok, I'll be over at your place nice and early to check it out, I love those cars..." of course he'd make some excuse why you couldn't Then I'd say "I can't wait to see it, let me know when it's good for you.." and leave it at that. That way he knows, and you know he's full of shit and everyone around them has an idea that he might be.....but it gives him an out....
 
Mcluhan said:
He immediately turned hostile, and threatened me violently. I couldn't believe how quickly it happened. It was then I realized I was dealing with a psychotic and dangerous person. And since I am neither a therapist or an immediate family member, I decided the best policy was to stay clear (far away).

You are definitely right on that one.
Now if his reaction was not triggered by any hostility on your end, then he is definitely telling you to mind your own business and to stop ruining the little world he managed to build so far.

If that's the way he thinks, acting as a dominant in a vertical relationship will not help. If you show yourself as stronger, he'll back off but he will still continue to do his schemes in the background and you will bear the consequences afterwards.
I know it is something people don't want to hear about in America, but backing off in this situation was the best answer and the wisest decision. And I am not saying that because of the French genes...

It often takes a lot to answer with your wisdom instead of your ego; and if it's for your good then you'll need the first one more than the second...