Question for Scotch Drinkers

My sweet friend Ceiling Cat, I ordered the 25yo direct from the distillery after a bottle of their 16yo got finished at Easter dinner.

OClaahn.gif
 
q9UbG9f.png




In the UK , they drink more cognac than the French because it is so cheap. Scotch is not as expensive as in Canada but they stay with the lower end scotch and export the 12 year old and + stock. Personally I stay with the 12 and 18 year old scotch that is around $100 a bottle. Certainly you do get an exclusive product in a 21 or 25 year old but IMHO the enjoyment quotient does not increase in proportion to the price. In the past I have been gifted very expensive bottles of scotch that I did not enjoy. I had a bottle of JW Blue that I did not enjoy at all, and the Chivas Royal Salute was a deluxe version of Chivas Regal 12 but I would not pay a premium for the higher end product.

In my experience any scotch 12 year old and under is available at any LCBO, 18 year old scotches are not sure to be on the shelf and anything over 18 years old ( 21 and 25 ) years old must be ordered. Ardbeg 25YO ( $655. )is not even available at the LCBO or SAQ ( Quebec )

Thank you Ceiling Cat
 
Just to give you an idea of what UK prices are for scotch, almost all are at least 33% cheaper. In the UK they consider Chivas Regal and Ballentines to be equals and are priced at about $32.75 for a .750 ml bottle. Ballentines here in Ontario and Quebec is about $25 / .750 ml bottle. A bottle of Dalwhinnie would go for about $59 CDN. in the UK vs. $93.50 here. You can also get the Tesco brand scotch ( sort of a President's Choice Brand ) for $18 CDN. for a .750 ml. bottle.
 
In Scotland, what is popular among the average working class guy in terms of scotch whisky? I wonder what is their take on these expensive single malts that are exported and sold abroad?

I don't know, only time I was drinking with locals in Edinborough they were drinking a fairly peaty scotch I didn't know. Though the amount of it drunk might have something to do with my sketchy recollection. The gang I was with tended towards the Islay.
 
I would go for a single malt of the Highland variety. Any 12 or 15 year old won't break the bank and are in the $100 territory. Of you're looking at 18 year old's, they are going to cost much more, but they are worth the money if Scotch is your or your clients thing. Islay's are a more acquired taste with how peaty they are and would be a waste on those who don't really have a taste for Scotch.

If you want to go with Canadian Whisky, try Wiser's 18 year old.
 
They stopped importing Glen Cardhu for awhile.

I started life as a farmaioli, wasting food was considered a crime. I was given a bottle of Lagavulin and I tried it with a bowl of stewed tripe. It's been nothing but Islay ever since.

UmmmmMmm Goooood Eatin!

33cc2a0b45b101f379d190bade71e337.jpg
 
They stopped importing Glen Cardhu for awhile.

I started life as a farmaioli, wasting food was considered a crime. I was given a bottle of Lagavulin and I tried it with a bowl of stewed tripe. It's been nothing but Islay ever since.

UmmmmMmm Goooood Eatin!

33cc2a0b45b101f379d190bade71e337.jpg

What is a farmaioli?
 
Another dish that pairs exceptionally well with single malt: Liver alla Veneta. Delicious, just remember to soak the liver overnight in milk. If you don't get the blood out, it's inedible.

Gooood eatin.

fegato-alla-veneta.jpg
 
farmaioli = country hick.

So you came from a background of a illiterate farm boy from the back road farms of Italy to drinking 25 year old Ardbeg scotch. How is the protection racket these days?
 
First: If you are talking a single malts then that is whisky (no "e"). The blends (Scotch), rye, bourbon and Irish are all different and deserving of attention in various degrees but whisky is in a league of its own.
Second: The pleasure is in the journey, not the destination. LCBO offers a wide and ever changing variety of single malts and its hard to find a bad one. Do the research and enjoy the journey.

I am about to open and decant a bottle of Canada's own, Glen Breton which is from Cape Breton Island. Later today I will pour a few ounces into an Edinburgh Crystal glass (Thistle Pattern), add a splash of water and recall many happy family moment over the years as we sit down to Thanksgiving dinner. Slainte!

Is there any Glenn Breton available in Ontario. My neighborhood LCBO does not seem to stock it any more.
 
As others have said, heavily peated whiskys are a love em or hate em drink. Furthermore, after a glass or two, you smell like you've been eating charcoal - not awesome for intimate times and very detectable for those your clients may see later, long after the alcohol breath dissipates. So I'd go for a less peaty scotch whisky, or something different. As for scotch, I think cragganmore is an amazing bang for buck, an excellent whisky whose taste will be really wnjoyed by aficionados and newbies alike. and I've tried most of the isle of Jura ones and find them decent, very pleasant to drink (tho not "transcendent").
Also as others have said, I'd offer some non scotch whisky too. I can also vouch for Crown Royal Northern Harvest. Only a few bucks more than an every day rye, but so pleasant to drink. It's my goto whisky since it was released. I can drink a tumbler of the stuff neat, it's so smooth and tasty. Bourbon is increasingly popular and the larger liquor stores stock an amazing variety. Lately my pref is Knob Creek Single Barrel reserve. But careful, it's 120 proof (1.5x more alcohol than standard hard liquor) and your clients if they have a couple may leave with a significant unexpected buzz, especially after a generous pour, undiluted.
 
Something different - I'm a big fan of The Glenlivet Nadurra Oloroso. It's a 'cask strength' scotch whiskey - 60.7% abv, and you water it to taste. I usually pour approx 2/3 to 3/4 portion of whiskey and top up with H2O. It has a butterscotchy taste but with additional complexities and a full mouthfeel. Now I'm going to have to kill you all! It's rather difficult to find - last time, I bought two. Save some for me.
 
Now I'm going to have to kill you all! It's rather difficult to find - last time, I bought two. Save some for me.

It is not hard to find at all. Just look on the LCBO locator. $90.25 @ the LCBO or $83.50 SAQ ( Quebec )

My suggestion :
Glenmorangie Original Single Malt Scotch Whisky $72.10 LCBO / $67.00 SAQ ( Quebec )
 
Glenlivet 18 is very decent, light, great for sipping and leaves no nasty after taste. I love it with a quality steak or even some good cheese and crackers. It's nimble because it smells good and has a sweetish, fruity taste. Best thing, it's widely available and inexpensive.
 
Glenlivet 18 is very decent, light, great for sipping and leaves no nasty after taste. I love it with a quality steak or even some good cheese and crackers. It's nimble because it smells good and has a sweetish, fruity taste. Best thing, it's widely available and inexpensive.

If you like Glenlivet 18 then you are sure to like Aberlour 12 Years Highland Scotch at a lower price point.