Question for Scotch Drinkers

SS, I find that Auchentoshen's 12 Year Old or The Balvenie Doublewood 12 are reasonably priced single malts that are smooth drinking but not peaty. However, if you do prefer a bit of peat, try the Highland Park 10 or 12 Year Old.
 
I’m a bourbon guy so can’t help, fun reading though.

It was meant to be.

um I did take the liberty to call scotch from islay a "type". Not sure how it allows you to come to your conclusions but fuck you too.

https://healthpsychologyconsultancy.wordpress.com/2013/08/21/the-argumentative-personality/
I find the "ignore" method works best!
 
SS, I find that Auchentoshen's 12 Year Old or The Balvenie Doublewood 12 are reasonably priced single malts that are smooth drinking but not peaty. However, if you do prefer a bit of peat, try the Highland Park 10 or 12 Year Old.

As stated, my preference is Dalwhinnie. I'm trying to offer my guests a bit of variety without breaking the bank. Thank you for the suggestions GG2013.
 
Yeah. Blue is also a great scotch. Can't remember if it's a single malt or blended though.

Blend. And not worth it by far IMO.

But that said, whiskeys (and bourbons - ugh) are a personal preference. If you want a decanter of stuff you like, try a bunch and pick one. If part of the reason is to impress, plenty of well known options.


Personally I prefer smoother in the summer, peaty in the winter. And I'm always happy to try something new.
 
Good taste Sophia. What you put in that crystal however, depends on your price point, and frankly, how much you like the people you’ll be sharing a dram with.

I go to WhiskeyFest every year, have personally run through many varieties at home and have friends with walls dedicated to whiskies. This is a very personal preference. Based on your preference for the Dalwhinnie style I’d say the Balvenie is a fair recommendation. The 12 Doublewood is likely on a par with your 15, the 21 year old Balvenie is probably what I would recommend as something to put in the crystal, but it may break the bank. There’s also a very limited release of the Dalwhinnie Distillers Edition at Yonge and Summerhill at the moment. I believe it has a second maturation in Olorosso sherry priced just a little bit higher than the 15.

This link may help, it’s put together whiskies with similar taste profiles.

http://www.scotchmaltwhisky.co.uk/similar-malts.htm

The Laphroig is great if you like peat, but it’s a kick in the man bag if you’re not really really really into it. Like a serious kick. I know people who like peat... and they cross their legs. If you want peaty go with Lagavullin, much more appropriate for both peaty and non peaty drinkers. The 16 year old isn’t much higher than your current favourite and would also give you the variety to offer your guests. Similarly, the Talisker Storm is pretty awesome for the price.

If you’re not sure go to one of the big LCBOs. Yonge and Summerhill / Queens Quay / Eglinton and Laird / other suggestions guys? and sample the whiskies from the wall of whiskies available. Often 20+ choices. Ask the consultant what’s peaty and see if you like it. However! I’ve seen really bad advice from consultants. Trust your palate... or go with me to the next WhiskeyFest ... ;)

Good luck. Let us know what you get in the end.
 
If you’re not sure go to one of the big LCBOs. Yonge and Summerhill / Queens Quay / Eglinton and Laird / other suggestions guys? and sample the whiskies from the wall of whiskies available. Often 20+ choices.

Great thread and lots of good choices. I would second this reco to go to the tasting bar at LCBO and try for a reasonable fee $1-4.

Single malts are such a personal preference, if the goal is to stock a whiskey that would appeal to the broadest cross section of men at a reasonable price, then you may want to go with a blend like Chivas Regal or Johnny Walker Black.

Tho I wouldn't mind a Macallan 15 ;)
 
First: If you are talking a single malts then that is whisky (no "e"). The blends (Scotch), rye, bourbon and Irish are all different and deserving of attention in various degrees but whisky is in a league of its own.
Second: The pleasure is in the journey, not the destination. LCBO offers a wide and ever changing variety of single malts and its hard to find a bad one. Do the research and enjoy the journey.

I am about to open and decant a bottle of Canada's own, Glen Breton which is from Cape Breton Island. Later today I will pour a few ounces into an Edinburgh Crystal glass (Thistle Pattern), add a splash of water and recall many happy family moment over the years as we sit down to Thanksgiving dinner. Slainte!
 
This reminds me that I've been meaning to pick up some Bushmills Black Bush. My good friend Dodd introduced me to Bushmills in my early 20's.

I'm beginning to develop a taste for Irish Whisky, they have a good body although generally sweeter than single malt.

Threw a BBQ party for The Leafs home opener, Laphroaig Cask Strength was served for the dudes and Fazza (Italian white wine) for the ladies. I also have a 25y Ardbeg in my liquor cabinet but I'm saving that for a special occasion.
 
In Scotland, what is popular among the average working class guy in terms of scotch whisky? I wonder what is their take on these expensive single malts that are exported and sold abroad?
 
Glenlivet 18 is in my opinion a great one and can be very appealing to people who are normally bourbon or rye drinkers. It's quite a bit more expensive than their 15 year though, but damn is it ever good. If you are considering ryes by the way, give Lot 40 a try.
 
Be careful OP as soon you may need a Bar/Smartserve License and be responsible for the actions of drunk Terbites leaving your establishment.
How do you tell if the obvious intoxication of your clients after a session was because of your service or your scotch?;)
 
Bacon vodka.......just say in.....
 
I'm beginning to develop a taste for Irish Whisky, they have a good body although generally sweeter than single malt.

Threw a BBQ party for The Leafs home opener, Laphroaig Cask Strength was served for the dudes and Fazza (Italian white wine) for the ladies. I also have a 25y Ardbeg in my liquor cabinet but I'm saving that for a special occasion.

q9UbG9f.png


In Scotland, what is popular among the average working class guy in terms of scotch whisky? I wonder what is their take on these expensive single malts that are exported and sold abroad?

In the UK , they drink more cognac than the French because it is so cheap. Scotch is not as expensive as in Canada but they stay with the lower end scotch and export the 12 year old and + stock. Personally I stay with the 12 and 18 year old scotch that is around $100 a bottle. Certainly you do get an exclusive product in a 21 or 25 year old but IMHO the enjoyment quotient does not increase in proportion to the price. In the past I have been gifted very expensive bottles of scotch that I did not enjoy. I had a bottle of JW Blue that I did not enjoy at all, and the Chivas Royal Salute was a deluxe version of Chivas Regal 12 but I would not pay a premium for the higher end product.

In my experience any scotch 12 year old and under is available at any LCBO, 18 year old scotches are not sure to be on the shelf and anything over 18 years old ( 21 and 25 ) years old must be ordered. Ardbeg 25YO ( $655. )is not even available at the LCBO or SAQ ( Quebec )
 
it's not a "type", it's a place;....

To be precise, it is a type/style created (and limited) to a place. It sure as hell isn't a brand which was his original point.

Can't everyone just chill and have a sip of their favourite?
 
My advise ... why just settle for one when variety is the spice of life. You have a lot of choices so make a list and buy some bottles over time, keep one of two opened for guests and let the others age for that special occasion.

VBB
 
In my experience any scotch 12 year old and under is available at any LCBO, 18 year old scotches are not sure to be on the shelf and anything over 18 years old ( 21 and 25 ) years old must be ordered. Ardbeg 25YO ( $655. )is not even available at the LCBO or SAQ ( Quebec )[/COLOR][/SIZE][/FONT]

My sweet friend Ceiling Cat, I ordered the 25yo direct from the distillery after a bottle of their 16yo got finished at Easter dinner. Nice to see you finally escaped from Unemployed Man's basement. Welcome back.

http://ardbeg.com/
 
it's not a "type", it's a place; the scotches made on islay have different flavours and processes. if you bothered to read the information you were disseminating you would know.

too many people these days trying to be know-it-alls, not enough people who actually know shit.
on an average evening I sip enough laphroaig to wash all that sand out of your vagina
 
Ladies and Genltemen:

My favourite scotch is Dalwhinnie 15 so I always have some in stock. I bought a beautiful chrystal decanter with matching double old fashioned glasses for on top of my buffet/bar and am looking for suggestions for a fine scotch to fill it with for guests. A reg suggested Balvenie but if a particular brand shines above the rest I'll go with that one. Any and all suggestion for single malt are appreciated.

Thank you to all Scotch lovers!

Something from the Speyside would probably appeal to a wider audience with their fruitier notes and less intense peatiness as opposed to their Islay counterparts. Depending on your budget, I would thrown in a recommendation as well for the Glenlivet 18 yr old or their 15yr old French Oak Reserve if you're being more budget conscious. You can't go wrong with something from Macallan as well; if you can get your hands on a Hibiki though (it's blended not single malt granted), even better. :)

IMO the JW Blue Label is definitely not worth the premium price they ask for it.