Wow you guys are all so wise. None the less I find it odd that you forget to use basic tools to allow for inflation and you seem to forget that stocks split and comparing a $20 value for one share to $100 for one share does not make any sense at all unless you factor in the stock splits (if any) that have accrued value as well.
Did any of you notice that every 10 to 12 years the rules change? During the 80s bonds rose and gold fell. During the 90s stocks rose and gold fell. and during the 2000s gold was up sharply and stocks volatile and bonds flat. In the 2010s... we will see
There is no one good investment.
In 2013 we have to realise that gold and silver are simply a commodity. Gold is a not to distant cousin of pork bellies and soy. The only difference is some people are still assuming it has some intrinsic value. As long as enough people think it has a miraculous special value it will sell at a premium. When enough people think it is not there salvation the value will drop.
Fear feeds the belief that gold / silver have some magic value. So as long as people think having a piece of metal in their sock drawer keeps them safe the bubble will continue

.
Want great investments? Short term "survival" stuff, or more exactly the companies providing them are in a boom cycle. Bacon ( yummy and it protects you from assorted other religions). Food in general. The crops in several countries are in dismal shape. I might even be willing to repeat the assumption that the average Canadian family will be spending almost 1/2 its disposable income on food within the next 2 years. Energy is a good bet. The energy policy in Canada and the tar-sands pretty much guarantee there will be a huge profit in the energy sector.
Gold? Silver? They can make you money, and the bubble will burst and if you are still in that market, ouch. Why not just go for platinum? At the existing price it is a great deal
Will you make money in the long run? If you can stick long enough, of course. Same as going to Vegas and making money there. Just go to the casino, and bet "red". Every time you loose just double your bet. If you keep doing it long enough, eventually you will win ! All you need to do is stick long enough.
I guess it is all about risk tolerance. And knowing what you are doing and not believing this decade's trend will last for ever.