Quebec keeps Canada sane

Didn't someone post once on Terb that the SP scene in Quebec City was next to nonexistent?
Due to various factors it's been about three years since I've hobbied in Ville de Québec. At that time although the number of agencies was quite small and you do have to be able to speak at least some French, there was at least a small SP scene.

However, I will be the first to say that it is abolutely nothing like Montreal or Toronto, then again Ville de Québec is a fraction of their size.
 
I dont know which Quebecois you guys are talking to, but if you want a conversation instant killer with anyone in that province under 35, then bring up the subject of independence/sovereignty etc.. The top is so boring to them right now, the vast majority are interested in their jobs, mortgages, kids etc just like anyone else in this country.

True, but it's always just simmering under the surface.

I work a guy who runs his own company in Isle Perrot. I think the world of this guy. He is NOT a PQ'ist, in fact, he loves Trudeau. But the whole Ad-scam thing had him really really riled up. (He has since calmed down) It was AMAZING to me to hear him talk about how it disgusted him what the liberals did and say that he (almost) thought fuck you we should separate.

You're right about the younger generation, but mainly in Montreal in the west part of Quebec. They are much more cosmopolitan.
 
True, but it's always just simmering under the surface. . . .

You're right about the younger generation, but mainly in Montreal in the west part of Quebec. They are much more cosmopolitan.
I do not claim to be an expert, but I'd agree with you from about Sorel west is entirely different from there east.

Of course the demographic shift over the past thirty years in the Eastern Townships is absolutely stagering.
 
You're welcome. ;)

We also inject some good food in this country (and no I'm not talking about poutine), great cheeses, some much needed sense of style, and good looking women.

I agree! I love French Canadian women. They are the best. Very kind, affectionate, sexy, and approachable.
 
It's less that there's too little classroom time, and it's more that it's way too fixated on name and date trivia, with too little context. Most Canadians have a horrible handle on human history, the history of Western Civilization, followed by British / French / (particularly) Native history, followed by the history of British North America and Canada.

Of course this is case. The public schools are ill-equipped to provide in-depth specialized knowledge in arcane fields of human knowledge. Most Canadians know nothing about the theory of relativity besides the trivia such as recognizing E=mc2 and knowing that Einstein was a pretty smart guy. Most Canadians don't understand the basic concepts of contract law. Most Canadians don't understand logarithms. Most Canadians don't understand that "cancer" is not a single disease and that therefore it is meaningless to talk about the search for "a cure for cancer". Most Canadians know little about philosophy. Most Canadians do not understand the basic tenets of the world's major religions. Most Canadians do not understand how central banks operate. Most Canadians don't understand the physics of soundwaves and musical harmony.

The schools cannot teach everything. Reading, writing, arithmetic as well as a superficial introduction to a broad range of subjects, with the hope of (a) providing students with basic living skills for the 21st century (b) instilling the desire to learn more.

Knowledge in all of these areas is highly fragmented, disjointed, and 'trivia centric'. This is a very serious problem with some nasty implications.

Why is it a serious problem?
 
Instead of thinking about what Canada owes to Quebec, think about what Quebec owes to Canada.

If Quebec had not been part of Canada and instead had been an independant colony of France it would've ended up like all of Frances other colonies. It would've been a poor, corrupt, repressive basket case of a country. If it were independent of Canada, it would've been another Haiti on our borders.

Think about that.
 
Instead of thinking about what Canada owes to Quebec, think about what Quebec owes to Canada.

If Quebec had not been part of Canada and instead had been an independant colony of France it would've ended up like all of Frances other colonies. It would've been a poor, corrupt, repressive basket case of a country. If it were independent of Canada, it would've been another Haiti on our borders.

Think about that.

No, it would have been sold by the French to the Americans just like Louisianna was sold way back when and the inhabitents would have been forced to give up their French culture and language just like the French in Louisianna were forced to.
 
Instead of thinking about what Canada owes to Quebec, think about what Quebec owes to Canada.

If Quebec had not been part of Canada and instead had been an independant colony of France it would've ended up like all of Frances other colonies. It would've been a poor, corrupt, repressive basket case of a country. If it were independent of Canada, it would've been another Haiti on our borders.

Think about that.

yeah thats right exactly because Quebec and Haiti have the exact same historical and socio-economic factors that would have clearly turned it into another Haiti :D

good God man you are such a simpleton
 
No, it would have been sold by the French to the Americans just like Louisianna was sold way back when and the inhabitents would have been forced to give up their French culture and language just like the French in Louisianna were forced to.

Maybe not so quickly, though. Was recently reading about Cajun history.

Louisiana Purchase was in 1803. In 1921, Louisiana required that all schools be in English. So, it seems that the Cajuns had over a 100 years to retain their culture or slowly assimilate.

There just weren't enough Cajuns in Louisiana to make significant political impact. Quebec is a different story.
 
Maybe not so quickly, though. Was recently reading about Cajun history.

Louisiana Purchase was in 1803. In 1921, Louisiana required that all schools be in English. So, it seems that the Cajuns had over a 100 years to retain their culture or slowly assimilate.

There just weren't enough Cajuns in Louisiana to make significant political impact. Quebec is a different story.
I don't believe it would be quite that simple. If you are going to use that sort of analogy with the same time line

By the mid-1800's Montreal and environs and Quebec City and environs also Trois Riviere would all be exclusively Anglophone areas, by now only rural areas in perhaps the Gaspe or on the North Shore would be Francophone and it would be quite definately an "at home" or "in our town" language.
 
Maybe not so quickly, though. Was recently reading about Cajun history.

Louisiana Purchase was in 1803. In 1921, Louisiana required that all schools be in English. So, it seems that the Cajuns had over a 100 years to retain their culture or slowly assimilate.

There just weren't enough Cajuns in Louisiana to make significant political impact. Quebec is a different story.

I wouldn't say that.

How many French Canadians were there in Quebec in 1803?

The French Culture survived in Quebec because of the Catholic Church. The British let the Catholic Church continue in Quebec as it had been. The Church remained in in control of Education in the province (and in some ways still does) up until the Quiet Revolution. The British also let French Canadians retain their Civil Code of Laws as opposed to adopting the British Common Law.

When the Americans took over Lousiana, they made no such concessions and today the French Language and culture of the Acadians and French in Lousiana has been reduced to a footnote on a post card in a souvenir shop on Burbon Street.

I have no doubt that a cash hungry France would have sold Quebec to their good buddies the Americans. You can bet the farm on that.

It's all hypothetical anyway, because the fact of the matter was that Britain wanted Quebec and France did not. After the 7 Years War, the French had the right to protect Quebec in the Treaty of Paris in 1763, however, they (the French) chose to protect Guadaloupe. They wanted Guadaloupe because Guadaloupe had sugar and Quebec had beaver pelts and rocks and they considered sugar a more valuable commodity than beaver pelts and rocks in New France, so the French traded Quebec to the British for Guadaloupe. In return, the British agreed to allow the Catholic church to continue and to preserve the Civil Code.

Quebec actually flourished more under British control, because the British allowed local industry in Quebec to be established. Under French rule, there was no indiginous industry allowed in Quebec. If you needed linen, or iron, or any manufactured good, you could only purchase it from France. It took forever, and it was very expensive. In short, the Quebecers were held hostage to the French. Under the British, local industry was set up and even encouraged. The British logic was that the local economy would flourish and they of course would only stand to bennefit (they would tax it).

The British were right.

Everything economically in Quebec stemmed from the British way of doing business, not the French. On top of that, the British protected Quebec and Upper Canada from the American to the south.

I find it ironic that so many Quebecers despise the British when it was the British system and government that allowed them to survive and in fact flourish even and did more for them than the French ever did.

The famous French Pilosophe Voltaire typified the French attitude towards Quebec, and he called it "a few acres of snow" and was glad when the British took it over. To this day, the French French look down their noses at Quebecers.

My good buddy who I refered to in a previous post saying that there was "no culture" in the rest of Canada once told me a story of how when he was a young man, he travelled to Europe for the first time and according to him, the French "treated me like shit" and ironically, the British treated him quite nicely.
 
Of course this is case. The public schools are ill-equipped to provide in-depth specialized knowledge in arcane fields of human knowledge.

It's a long running problem with all North American schools... And there's noting 'arcane' and 'specialized' about history (and geography) unless you turn it into context free name and date soup. Knowing the day WWII started and that it was caused because of something called "the Treaty of Versailles', and subsequently forgetting it 2 days later, is useless compared to actually having something of an integrated sense of who, what, where, when, and why... One is trivia and trivial, and the other should be rather vital. (if you look at the depth of ignorance in some of the political debate in the US in the last decade you can see that in spades.)

Frankly, I think you are dead wrong, it's not that the schools can't teach math and science, it's that they fixate on mechanics (formula driven math) that can be better done by machines, rather than understanding why 'the broad strokes of a thing' are important and integrating that into a persons broader knowledge base. Turning kids into short term memorization machines that have some capacity to plug numbers into formals is what's wrong with education. It produces, at best, hyper specialized adults who lack enough of an well integrated general knowledge base to be anything other than 'ignorant' in most other endeavours.
 
[The French demanded the return of Guadalupe in the Treaty of Paris of 1763]because Guadaloupe had sugar and Quebec had beaver pelts and rocks and they considered sugar a more valuable commodity than beaver pelts and rocks in New France.
No fooling the income to France from Guadaloupe was what 50 or 150 times that of Nouvelle France?

Many more than Voltaire considered Nouvelle France to be but quelques arpents de neige.
 
From what i've heard from friends I would say yes.

Alberta is where the Reform Party and the magazine the Alberta Report originated, which reflects on Alberta's proud redneck mentality. Calgary was the only Canadian city where Bush Jr. was applauded on his post-presidential speaking engagements. The Alberta rednecks became smug and did not want to share their wealth with the rest of Canada, and as energy is the sole driver of their economy, they are a one trick pony. But witness the recent misfortunes in the oil patch, if they continue, the provincial surplus may be wiped out, they might become a "have not province", and they could be backed to kicking cow shit with their every present cowboy boots. Quebec outclasses Alberta is almost every way.
 
Agreed with most of what you wrote above (and what followed), except maybe for pt. 5.

My experience growing up in a small town in the middle of buttfuck nowhere in the North of Quebec suggest that there is a significant difference in the attitude towards sex than what I've experienced in Toronto or Ottawa. Obviously, I don't know what is going on behind close door, and while my own "field" sample of both population may be significantly higher than the majority, it is still a limited and anecdotal sample. But if we're talking about attitude, I'd say that people in Québec are generally significantly less prude than people in the ROC.

I don't think that it translates into a more positive and accepting attitude toward gays however, or toward other "non-conforming" sexualities (such as paid-for-sex or BDSM).


This reminds me of a poll I read about in Chatelaine's magazine. See here: http://en.chatelaine.com/english/binary/pdf/issue/2008/02/20071119_145933_2200.pdf Of course, it's a magazine poll, but the differences between Quebec women and Anglo women is noteworthy. I've always thought that why French girls are so much more fun in bed, because they don't have so many hangups about sex. Anglos fill the heads of their women with so much more repressive stupidity... The difference between reported orgasms between Anglos and French is noteworthy...
 
Lower Canada is a geographic term.

Simply, Quebec is lower in elevation above Sea Level than Ontario. (You know, the St. Lawrence River flows in one direction - down hill (funny thing about water) towards the Ocean)

It is not that Quebecers are some sort of lower class citizen.


Interesting! That actually makes historical sense too. I've always wondered why Quebec was called lower Canada. You have a very plausible answer there. Now, could you back that up with citation so that when I explain it that way in future, I can point to something other than "some guy on the Internet said..." Please note, I'm not trying to be an ass. I really am interested!

Thanks!
 
It's a long running problem with all North American schools... And there's noting 'arcane' and 'specialized' about history (and geography) unless you turn it into context free name and date soup. Knowing the day WWII started and that it was caused because of something called "the Treaty of Versailles', and subsequently forgetting it 2 days later, is useless compared to actually having something of an integrated sense of who, what, where, when, and why... One is trivia and trivial, and the other should be rather vital. (if you look at the depth of ignorance in some of the political debate in the US in the last decade you can see that in spades.)

Frankly, I think you are dead wrong, it's not that the schools can't teach math and science, it's that they fixate on mechanics (formula driven math) that can be better done by machines, rather than understanding why 'the broad strokes of a thing' are important and integrating that into a persons broader knowledge base. Turning kids into short term memorization machines that have some capacity to plug numbers into formals is what's wrong with education. It produces, at best, hyper specialized adults who lack enough of an well integrated general knowledge base to be anything other than 'ignorant' in most other endeavours.

You raise some excellent points. However, I think you mistake the purpose of the "education system" as being "producing educated citizens" or something like that. I think that the purpose is to produce "productive workers" and "good consumers." Thinking educated people aren't necessarily the best at either of these things. Also, it takes a long time to produce a well rounded education with lots and lots of extra curricular reading. Most people have neither the time, energy, economic means or other necessary components to become this.

I think I can claim to have a "well rounded education" with two degrees (Sciences and Arts) and a specialized professional degree. Hardly anyone I know (including my peers) spent that much time at school just learning about stuff in general and then having a decent theoretical framework on which to hang all the stuff they learned about. I've studied everything from planetary science, classical Greece and Rome, French history, plant genetics to modern political economy and other minutiae. That took a long time and had a huge opportunity cost.

The vast majority of people simply want to get all the pre-requisites out of the way and move into their professional studies and simply get on with making money. This is what most people (including those who really run the show) want. It's called being a "productive citizen" (emphasis on productive rather than citizen). That said, considering the result (society wide), the system works reasonably well. Just don't expect to find someone with whom to talk about Socratic ideas on every corner. ;)
 
At it's lowest point - Toronto is 76 metres above sea level. At it's highest, around Keele and Steeles, 209 metres above Sea Level.

http://www.toronto.ca/toronto_facts/geography.htm


Montreal is 57 metres above sea level

http://www.worldclimate.com/cgi-bin/data.pl?ref=N45W073+4102+7162709G1

As you get to the mouth of the St. Lawrence, guess what - you're at Sea Level.

Thanks for those facts. What I wanted was the historical reference linking the above facts (which I never doubted) to the actual naming of Upper and Lower Canada (i.e. in seventeen eighty something, Joe Blow on behalf of his majesty King Turd of British pile named that which is now known as Quebec "Lower Canada" because its closer to sea level and they had to walk uphill all the way to what was to become Hogtown"

Do you have that reference by chance? Thanks!