Quebec keeps Canada sane

On the Catholic church comments, that's overdone, there has always been a huge gulf between the official policy and what actually goes on, in every catholic country. Maybe something to do with being able to go to confession. I do believe that Quebec has *always* been more sexually tolerant than English Canada, even in the hey day of the church.

I did specifically leave out immigrants in my list. Quebec may be progressive minded but it is not tolerant of immigrant culture. This is, I think, similar to any European country--it' s a problem with being a "nation state".

How long have you lived there?
 
train you win the best answer award



let us not forget hockey

Also they are anti war as seen in the lack of enlistment in both wars

They have also been historically oppressed when Quebec was

called Lower Canada whch explains the above

Lower Canada is a geographic term.

Simply, Quebec is lower in elevation above Sea Level than Ontario. (You know, the St. Lawrence River flows in one direction - down hill (funny thing about water) towards the Ocean)

It is not that Quebecers are some sort of lower class citizen.
 
I've spent ALLOT of time in Quebec, and here are my observations:

1. Quebec is a great place and I really love it there.

2. I was worried that people would treat me like shit because I am an Anglo. Nothing could be further from the truth. I've only encountered ethnic dislike once in all my years in Quebec - in Laval of all fucking places. I try to speak French and people are cool with me. (Though they really do speak louder when I don't understand them.)

3. Quebec is more open sexually than the ROC, but not that much. There is very little difference between Montreal and Toronto (in so far as attitudes towards sex.)

4. Small town Quebecers can be (but not always) fairly liberal and open minded to sex.

5. Gays are not well received outside of Montreal and Quebec City. Witness Daniel Boisclaire - former leader of the PQ.

6. Quebec culture is very real - the architecture, the church, the food, the arts, however, they can be elitist and snobish. A Quebecer I used to work with with said (and firmly believed) that there was no real "culture" in the rest of Canada.

7. All Quebec popular music is painfully bad and sounds the same to me. Like a cross between Michael Bolton and Joe Cocker sung in French by brutal aging hippies. I tried to like it, but I can't. It's farking terrible stuff.

8. Quebecers are hard working and very industrious (at least the ones I work with.) The myth of the lazy Quebecer is a myth in my eyes.

9. There is a HUGE rivalry between Quebec City and Montreal. Quebec City people consider themselves superior to Montrealers becasue they are "La Pure Laine" (the true French) in Quebec and Monrealers are mutts, neither Franco or Anglo or someplace in between. Montrealers just get a kick out of it.

10. Montrealers truly believe that Montreal is a better place that Toronto. Montreal is a great City, but Toronto truly is a far more diverse and I would say better place to live. (Maybe I'm biased.)

11. Quebecers who have lived in Toronto are often amused to admit that after living here for a few years that they really grew to like Toronto and it still freaks them out on some level.

12. Some Quebecers when they hear me speak French love my English accent (which surprises me). They also want to practice their English with me.

13. I love TQS on late nights on Fridays. Full on porn.

14. The church is ironically the reason that the French language has been so well preserved in Quebec. By being isolationist, and insisting on retaining their French language the church preserved the French culture in Quebec.

15. Quebecers are not Acadians and they don't care much about them despite Acadians also being Francophones.

16. When you talk politics with Quebecers, they can get rather defensive very quickly - especially about the British. If you want to freak them out, ask them where they think Quebec would be today if Britain had not taken over from France. They will always tell you that things would be better. Then ask them if they think that France would have sold Quebec to the Americans like France sold the French in Lousianna to the Americans. At first they won't get it, but once they see the connection, that France sooner or later would have sold Quebec to the Americans, they truly don't know what to say. Truth be told that if the British had not won the Seven Years War and taken over Quebec, Quebec would have been sold off to the American like Louisianna and they would surely be speaking American English. That always gets a few scratched heads in Quebec.

17. Look around Quebec City and you will see the cross pollination of the British and the Frech cultures in the Architecture.
 
I've spent ALLOT of time in Quebec, and here are my observations:

1. Quebec is a great place and I really love it there.

2. I was worried that people would treat me like shit because I am an Anglo. Nothing could be further from the truth. I've only encountered ethnic dislike once in all my years in Quebec - in Laval of all fucking places. I try to speak French and people are cool with me. (Though they really do speak louder when I don't understand them.)

3. Quebec is more open sexually than the ROC, but not that much. There is very little difference between Montreal and Toronto (in so far as attitudes towards sex.)

4. Small town Quebecers can be (but not always) fairly liberal and open minded to sex.

5. Gays are not well received outside of Montreal and Quebec City. Witness Daniel Boisclaire - former leader of the PQ.

6. Quebec culture is very real - the architecture, the church, the food, the arts, however, they can be elitist and snobish. A Quebecer I used to work with with said (and firmly believed) that there was no real "culture" in the rest of Canada.

7. All Quebec popular music is painfully bad and sounds the same to me. Like a cross between Michael Bolton and Joe Cocker sung in French. I tried to like it, but I can't. I farking is terrible stuff.

8. Quebecers are hard working and very industrious (at least the ones I work with.) The myth of the lazy Quebecer is a myth in my eyes.

9. There is a HUGE rivalry between Quebec City and Montreal. Quebec City people consider themselves superior to Montrealers becasue they are "La Pure Laine" (the true French) in Quebec and Monrealers are mutts, neither Franco or Anglo or someplace in between. Montrealers just get a kick out of it.

10. Montrealers truly believe that Montreal is a better place that Toronto. Montreal is a great City, but Toronto truly is a far more diverse and I would say better place to live. (Maybe I'm biased.)

11. Quebecers who have lived in Toronto are often amused to admit that after living here for a few years that they really grew to like Toronto and it still freaks them out on some level.

12. Some Quebecers when they hear me speak French love my English accent (which surprises me). They also want to practice their English with me.

13. I love TQS on late nights on Fridays. Full on porn.

14. The church is ironically the reason that the French language has been so well preserved in Quebec. By being isolationist, and insisting on retaining their French language the church preserved the French culture in Quebec.

15. Quebecers are not Acadians and they don't care much about them despite Acadians also being Francophones.

16. When you talk politics with Quebecers, they can get rather defensive very quickly - especially about the British. If you want to freak them out, ask them where they think Quebec would be today if Britain had not taken over from France. They will always tell you that things would be better. Then ask them if they think that France would have sold Quebec to the Americans like France sold the French in Lousianna to the Americans. At first they won't get it, but once they see the connection, that France sooner or later would have sold Quebec to the Americans, they truly don't know what to say. Truth be told that if the British had not won the Seven Years War and taken over Quebec, Quebec would have been sold off to the American like Louisianna and they would surely be speaking American English. That always gets a few scratched heads in Quebec.

17. Look around Quebec City and you will see the cross pollination of the British and the Frech cultures in the Architecture.

I agree with everything you say. I grew up in Montreal, married a French Canadian girl and go there and south of Montreal on business once or twice a month. People who haven't spent time there may not appreciate the diversity in beliefs and culture between Montreal and the rest of the province. Huge difference between cities such as Chicoutimi, Sept Isles, Trois Riviere, much less the smaller towns and Montreal.

The one thing that no one has mentioned is the fierce pride most Quebecers now have and how emotional they tend to get on certain subjects. Mainly language and politics.
 
I believe it's Quebec's cultural influence that has made Canada what it is:

-- More tolerant towards sex than Americans or Brits
-- A country with a strong art/culture appreciation
-- A belief in capitalism tempered by communal interests
-- Anti-gun, pro-gay, progressive outlook
-- Love/hate attitude towards large, centralized institutions

Outside of Quebec and central/urban Ontario the rest of the country is made up of hicks from the sticks who would, if they could, turn Canada into a backwards, repressive, moralistic, intolerant, and cruel society.

I think the only reason Ontario has strong progressive attitudes is its historic nearness to Quebec, and over time, Ontario has absorbed some of Quebec's ideas as it absorbed some of its people.

Discuss amongst yourselves.

I agree with part...but disagree that Ontario is the bastion of progressive attitudes. Ontario, outside of Toronto, is more intolerant and racist/prejudiced than any other part of Canada I have been in, and I have lived longer in other parts than in Ontario.
 
I agree with part...but disagree that Ontario is the bastion of progressive attitudes. Ontario, outside of Toronto, is more intolerant and racist/prejudiced than any other part of Canada I have been in, and I have lived longer in other parts than in Ontario.

You haven't spent much time in Alberta have you.
 
I agree with part...but disagree that Ontario is the bastion of progressive attitudes.

Well that's what I was trying to get at by saying "central Ontario" because there really are only a few places in Ontario that are progressive. Maybe "central Ontario" is too broad an area for what I was trying to describe. It is more than the GTA, and less than all of Southern Ontario.
 
What I was really trying to get across in this thread, and I guess not very well, is this notion that what makes Canada different is actually Quebec.

We like to say we are more European than the Americans, because we preserved more of our British heritage.

Bullshit.

We are "more European" than the Americans because we have Quebec, and although there has been the "two solitudes" or whatever you want to call it, in reality, we have absorbed a significant amount of Quebec culture in Canada, especially in the urban areas of Ontario.

We have been influenced by Quebec politicians, but at an even more fundamental level, there have been people who have migrated between the provinces, and brought their ideas with them.

"More European" is not quite the right phrase though, we are more Quebec than the Americans, which seems European in some ways, but is actually quite different since Quebec culture split off from European French culture and developed independently.
 
Agreed

You're welcome. ;)

We also inject some good food in this country (and no I'm not talking about poutine), great cheeses, some much needed sense of style, and good looking women.

And that is true. The women in QU know how to carry themselves. I love the 'leg' action when ever I visit my BELLE provence. Even at -30 the ladies wear dresses and skirts, and they have the cams to admire.
 
I don't know about your statement concerning ww 11, but Canada had a draft in WW 1, and said draft was instituted at the request of his majesty's government because too many of the flower of England were dying in that senseless slaughter.
Where does one even start, and why should I even bother? I suppose France was not having an equally high death toll.

This also goes to how Canadian History is taught.
 
We should all build a shrine to Rene Levesque ( the father of the separatist movement).

He caused all the head offices to move from Montreal to Toronto.

____________________________________________________________

The reason why Quebec ( Montreal ) has better food is competition. There are less people there and more restaurants. The repeat clients are nessesary to stay in business.

The reason why Quebec ( Montreal ) has better SPs is competition. There are less people there and more SPs. The repeat clients are nessesary to stay in business.

The reason the women look better there is competition. There are less guys there and more women, so they have to look better to get a guy.
 
Well that's what I was trying to get at by saying "central Ontario" because there really are only a few places in Ontario that are progressive. Maybe "central Ontario" is too broad an area for what I was trying to describe. It is more than the GTA, and less than all of Southern Ontario.
Perhaps the Greater Golden Horseshoe?

Otherwise know as the part of the country that sees itself as being "Canada", and which most of the rest of Canada loves to hate.
 
I've spent ALLOT of time in Quebec, and here are my observations:

1. Quebec is a great place and I really love it there.

2. I was worried that people would treat me like shit because I am an Anglo. Nothing could be further from the truth. I've only encountered ethnic dislike once in all my years in Quebec - in Laval of all fucking places. I try to speak French and people are cool with me. (Though they really do speak louder when I don't understand them.)
These are really good comments JTK.

I agree on one and two, but things are much better now then they were 20+ years ago, then it was your French is fractured - up yours.

3. Quebec is more open sexually than the ROC, but not that much. There is very little difference between Montreal and Toronto (in so far as attitudes towards sex.)

4. Small town Quebecers can be (but not always) fairly liberal and open minded to sex.

5. Gays are not well received outside of Montreal and Quebec City. Witness Daniel Boisclaire - former leader of the PQ.
yes to three and I believe five, but four I'm not so sure about
6. Quebec culture is very real - the architecture, the church, the food, the arts, however, they can be elitist and snobish. A Quebecer I used to work with with said (and firmly believed) that there was no real "culture" in the rest of Canada.
Absolutely so.

7. All Quebec popular music is painfully bad and sounds the same to me. Like a cross between Michael Bolton and Joe Cocker sung in French by brutal aging hippies. I tried to like it, but I can't. It's farking terrible stuff.
It isn't that bad, that doesn't mean I love it, but I don't hate it
8. Quebecers are hard working and very industrious (at least the ones I work with.) The myth of the lazy Quebecer is a myth in my eyes.
I'd entirely agree that it is no more true than it is about any other group
9. There is a HUGE rivalry between Quebec City and Montreal. Quebec City people consider themselves superior to Montrealers becasue they are "La Pure Laine" (the true French) in Quebec and Monrealers are mutts, neither Franco or Anglo or someplace in between. Montrealers just get a kick out of it.
Absolutely!
10. Montrealers truly believe that Montreal is a better place that Toronto. Montreal is a great City, but Toronto truly is a far more diverse and I would say better place to live. (Maybe I'm biased.)
I love Montreal, and I hate to say prefer it to Toronto. However if you forced me to live in one or the other, then I'd have to pick Toronto.

CUTTING OUT 11-13, Although I will say that 12 is true primarly in the two major cities, in the country it is French or French.

14. The church is ironically the reason that the French language has been so well preserved in Quebec. By being isolationist, and insisting on retaining their French language the church preserved the French culture in Quebec.

15. Quebecers are not Acadians and they don't care much about them despite Acadians also being Francophones.

16. When you talk politics with Quebecers, they can get rather defensive very quickly - especially about the British. If you want to freak them out, ask them where they think Quebec would be today if Britain had not taken over from France. They will always tell you that things would be better. Then ask them if they think that France would have sold Quebec to the Americans like France sold the French in Lousianna to the Americans. At first they won't get it, but once they see the connection, that France sooner or later would have sold Quebec to the Americans, they truly don't know what to say. Truth be told that if the British had not won the Seven Years War and taken over Quebec, Quebec would have been sold off to the American like Louisianna and they would surely be speaking American English. That always gets a few scratched heads in Quebec.
I entirely agree with the above. Gen will probably put me on her "do not call list" :-) but unfortunately a fair amount of Québec history as popularly believed is more national myth, than it is history.

For instance the whole decapitation theory holds little water historically, but is firmly believed by most in Québec

Great post Captain!
 
It's rare that this happens but I entirely agree with fuji on this . Quebecois girls also have the most delicious accents.
 
I dont know which Quebecois you guys are talking to, but if you want a conversation instant killer with anyone in that province under 35, then bring up the subject of independence/sovereignty etc.. The top is so boring to them right now, the vast majority are interested in their jobs, mortgages, kids etc just like anyone else in this country.

As for the Quebec City-Montreal rivalry, the best quote I heard in French translates to Quebec City is a classy older lady, while Montreal is a prostitute :D
 
I entirely agree with the above. Gen will probably put me on her "do not call list" :-) but unfortunately a fair amount of Québec history as popularly believed is more national myth, than it is history.

For instance the whole decapitation theory holds little water historically, but is firmly believed by most in Québec
And my experience in universities classrooms in Ontario tells me that unfortunately, schools in Ontario do at least an equally horible job at teaching history to kids.
 
Didn't someone post once on Terb that the SP scene in Quebec City was next to nonexistent?

Beautiful city, but without SPs I wouldn't want to live there.

This is an interesting thread - learned a lot, thanks.
 
And my experience in universities classrooms in Ontario tells me that unfortunately, schools in Ontario do at least an equally horible job at teaching history to kids.

It's less that there's too little classroom time, and it's more that it's way too fixated on name and date trivia, with too little context. Most Canadians have a horrible handle on human history, the history of Western Civilization, followed by British / French / (particularly) Native history, followed by the history of British North America and Canada. Knowledge in all of these areas is highly fragmented, disjointed, and 'trivia centric'. This is a very serious problem with some nasty implications.
 
And my experience in universities classrooms in Ontario tells me that unfortunately, schools in Ontario do at least an equally horible job at teaching history to kids.
Genèvieve I will be the last person to disagree with you.

Unfortunately the same applies to the U.S. and to the U.K. as well. :(