QM-1 test firing

The producer is the producer, Jeremy Clarkson is the star. It is rather common knowledge that many stars are prima donnas. The producer among many other things is supposed to be keeping the wheels greased. You don't attempt to pack your star off to bed with a supper of cold cuts, you do what eventually happened they cooked Mr. Clarkson a steak.

Could everyone involved have exercised better judgement you bet they could have, and should have.

I get your point, although in my view the "prima donna" defense is a weak one, but I accept that's the way it is.

My point is there is only so much that the producer could have reasonably done to compensate for the circumstances. Jeremy Clarkson choose to go to a pub after they completed filming. According to comments provided by James May, Clarkson said he only wanted a couple drinks, so the producer arranged for dinner to be served later. Turns out Clarkson stayed in the pub for 2 hours. By that time the restaurant was closed and the chef went home. The producer claims he tried calling other places while Clarkson was drinking, but he had limited access to information (he was on-site) and had no-luck. The dust-up occurred fairly soon after they flew back to the hotel, thus the producer had no time yet to find alternatives.

Bottom line, Clarkson was the root cause of the delay and the Producer went to more than reasonable efforts to perform his job. BBC management as well as Hammond and May appear to agree that Clarkson was being a "knob".

Perhaps we need to demand more professionalism from "stars". I personally really enjoy Jeremy on Top Gear, but the show could survive his leaving. Charlie Sheen is an extreme example, but Two and a Half Men survived (barely) after his leaving and Sheen's new show sucked. Charlie personally did quite well $$.
 
My "point" is again the question how this does this address the problem of cold weather launches, such as was so disastrous for the Space Shuttle program. To me at least if to no one else it seems curious that NASA would again use the same sort of design.

:deadhorse:

AGAIN: THEY DIDN'T USE THE SAME DESIGN FOR THE O-RINGS. The joint was redesigned. The rings and putty use different materials. There are observation ports designed to allow for inspection.

The basic design has worked for 100s and 100s of launches.

Are you just being difficult now?
 
The joint was redesigned. The rings and putty use different materials. There are observation ports designed to allow for inspection.

The basic design has worked for 100s and 100s of launches.
Thank you.

It still seems peculiar to me and I presume driven by cost factors when one considers that the Saturn V was entirely liquid fueled as is the Proton M.
 
AGAIN: THEY DIDN'T USE THE SAME DESIGN FOR THE O-RINGS. The joint was redesigned. The rings and putty use different materials. There are observation ports designed to allow for inspection.

The basic design has worked for 100s and 100s of launches.

Are you just being difficult now?

Lawyers are experts in arguing, not so much rocket science.
 
It still seems peculiar to me and I presume driven by cost factors when one considers that the Saturn V was entirely liquid fueled as is the Proton M.

I'm not an expert, but like many people here I have a big interest in the technology. I may get some of this wrong:

Solid fuel rockets:
- Produce more thrust per pound of fuel.
- Once started a SFR must burn to completion, it cannot be turned off
- Are simpler, less expensive and because they have less parts and moving parts are much more reliable
- While sitting unused, they are safe and stable. Chances of a explosion, leak or other major failure is very low.

Liquid fuel rockets
- thrust exits the engine at higher speed (more powerful), but less efficient per pound of fuel
- Can be turned on and off and throttled <-- use this feature during the shuttle flights when the shuttle rotates onto it's back and then throttles up. Can be used for maneuvering in space
- Complex to design and build, lots of moving parts means lower reliability compared to SRB (but they are still very reliable), expensive to build.
- Fuel handling on the ground is expensive and dangerous.
- While sitting on the launch pad and fueled, the risk of a failure is meaningful.

In the case of the shuttle, knowing that the SRBs create ~80% of the take-off thrust, I've often wondered why they didn't just build bigger SRBs and provision a smaller liquid fuel tank. Alternatively why not 4 SRBs and the second pair start just before the first pair run out of fuel. My reasoning: at take-off time, most of the thrust is required to overcome the weight of the fuel itself, so if the SRBs produce more thrust, are lighter and are more reliable (ignoring the Challenger failure), why the need or the massive fuel tank? . Sure you still need liquid engines for maneuvering in space, but I've never been able to find an explanation for this. LOL, I'm sure NASA knows what they are doing, but I'm curious.