QM-1 test firing

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113

It fires at 58 minutes
 
This is the solid rocket supplemental booster.

Now how this does anything to solve the problem of cold weather launches and burn through like on the Space Shuttle, doesn't reach out to grab me.
 
Well, you claim to be a lawyer, so what would you know about rockets.
 
I've always wondered how hard it is to affix such test engines to the ground, with all that thrust generated. The rocket itself doesn't buckle.

Did you notice how the surrounding ground was steaming hot, even though it wasn't touching the emitted flame and gases? Must be some incredible radiant heat generated.
 
th


The question remains how is NASA's Space Launch System (solid rockets strapped onto a liquid fueled rocket - as shown above) going to avoid the cold weather launch problems so catastrophically shown in the launch of the Space Shuttle "Challenger."

Perhaps they eliminated "O" rings, but that raises issues of its own, and both the video and the illustration show a segmented solid rocket.
 
The question remains how is NASA's Space Launch System (solid rockets strapped onto a liquid fueled rocket - as shown above) going to avoid the cold weather launch problems so catastrophically shown in the launch of the Space Shuttle "Challenger."
Ummm, by not launching during cold weather? I wonder if NASA has a suggestion box?


Perhaps they eliminated "O" rings, but that raises issues of its own, and both the video and the illustration show a segmented solid rocket.
Pray-tell, what issues does eliminating the O-rings raise? Man, they teach you allot of stuff in lawyer school eh? Like bullshit baffles brains.
Cool! so you are a rocket expert on top of all your many other expertise. Perhaps you can tell be why Iron Man doesn't get flattened in his suit during all those high-G maneuvers? I've always wondered.


Most of us rely on Google. Did you know:
- The O-ring problem was addressed through a redesign of the joint, O-ring material and the putty material in the SR design after the Challenger failure and before the shuttle program restarted. <-- Wow, them there Nasa scientists fixed the problem!
- Here's a document describing the fix (starting bottom of page 8). http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20120001536.pdf
- I'm guessing .... but I'm no Aardvark ..... that the QM-1 designers would have carefully considered the o-ring design in their new booster and would have applied the NASA lessons learned from Challenger.

Sarcasm aside, the Challenger failure was as much about human error as it was about engineering design. NASA failed to follow their own processes and procedures and listen to their experts during the launch phase. Engineering designs can be fixed. Human politics and egos, much tougher to fix. Especially if know-it-all lawyers are involved.
 
Ummm, by not launching during cold weather? I wonder if NASA has a suggestion box?



Pray-tell, what issues does eliminating the O-rings raise? Man, they teach you allot of stuff in lawyer school eh? Like bullshit baffles brains.
Cool! so you are a rocket expert on top of all your many other expertise. Perhaps you can tell be why Iron Man doesn't get flattened in his suit during all those high-G maneuvers? I've always wondered.


Most of us rely on Google. Did you know:
- The O-ring problem was addressed through a redesign of the joint, O-ring material and the putty material in the SR design after the Challenger failure and before the shuttle program restarted. <-- Wow, them there Nasa scientists fixed the problem!
- Here's a document describing the fix (starting bottom of page 8). http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20120001536.pdf
- I'm guessing .... but I'm no Aardvark ..... that the QM-1 designers would have carefully considered the o-ring design in their new booster and would have applied the NASA lessons learned from Challenger.

Sarcasm aside, the Challenger failure was as much about human error as it was about engineering design. NASA failed to follow their own processes and procedures and listen to their experts during the launch phase. Engineering designs can be fixed. Human politics and egos, much tougher to fix. Especially if know-it-all lawyers are involved.

Don't be hard on Aardvark (or lawyers - the Challenger disaster happened because of a disconnect between executives and engineers). He may simply be thinking out loud.

Did you see that fantastic docu-drama starring William Hurt as Feynman about the Challenger disaster?
 
Don't be hard on Aardvark (or lawyers - the Challenger disaster happened because of a disconnect between executives and engineers). He may simply be thinking out loud.

Would a skilled lawyer, especially someone as brilliant and experienced as Ardy, make a fundamental mistake by "thinking out loud"?

Ardy stated: "Now how this does anything to solve the problem of cold weather launches and burn through like on the Space Shuttle, doesn't reach out to grab me."
The video provided by danmand obviously was not intended to address that question, it was simply showing the test and providing some background info. But like many of Ardy's posts, there is always an underlying theme of someone else's failure or lack of expertise.
Honestly, I don't like know-it-all pompous asses (remember Blue Laser, Blackrock or T-boy?) and he's is one of TERB's biggest. It bothers me how he talks down to people and how quickly he tries to discredit expert opinion because "they don't write for a prestigious paper or don't have multiple post graduate degrees". Therefore I challenge him when he gets particularly bad. He'll either ignore the challenge or slime away, but I think more people are starting to notice.

Did you see that fantastic docu-drama starring William Hurt as Feynman about the Challenger disaster?
I did, but it was as more of a Hollywood drama than a fact-oriented documentary. I've read some of the on-line summary reports about Challenger and the documentary missed many of the key issues. The Nova episode was pretty good: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/space/space-shuttle-disaster.html

Trust us we're NASA of course we've eliminated the problem.
SRBs have been around for years. NASA, the military and private enterprise have 100s and 100s of successful launches. Space flight is a hugely complex and there will be failures. I'd have more hope for NASA than a lawyer if I heard "trust me".
 
Ardy stated: "Now how this does anything to solve the problem of cold weather launches and burn through like on the Space Shuttle, doesn't reach out to grab me."
The video provided by danmand obviously was not intended to address that question, it was simply showing the test and providing some background info.
Now you could have written in what way Alliant Techsystems has addressed the problem. I might have asked some further questions said thank you for the information and that would have been that.


SRBs have been around for years. NASA, the military and private enterprise have 100s and 100s of successful launches.
Indeed they have, however, most Solid Rockets are not strapped onto manned liquid fueled boosters. This proposed system and the Space Shuttle are the only two which come to my mind (which to spell it out doesn't mean that there aren't others, merely that those are the two which immediately come to my mind), then of course the unmanned Delta series of rockets (M,N, 0 through 8 including the heavies).
 
......... But like many of Ardy's posts, there is always an underlying theme of someone else's failure or lack of expertise.

An example of my point: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...on-Suspended&p=5194734&viewfull=1#post5194734
"A decent producer doesn't have someone out filming all day and then tell them that all the hotel can produce for dinner is a plate of cold cuts!"

Were you there Aardy? Do you know for a FACT this was due to the producers incompetence?

Further info: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/motoring...-Gear-producer-because-he-wanted-a-steak.html
According to this article:
- the kitchen was closed and the chef had gone home.
- Clarkson had been drinking before the scuffle
- Clarkson had delayed the helicopter departure back to the hotel by 2 hours because he was drinking in a pub. It was during the delay the hotel people closed up the kitchen and offered the cold plates.

Although this information is not conclusive either, I'm tired of people like self claimed mega-experts like Aardy jumping to conclusions without having all facts. As a self claimed lawyer, you would think he knows better!
 
An example of my point: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...on-Suspended&p=5194734&viewfull=1#post5194734
"A decent producer doesn't have someone out filming all day and then tell them that all the hotel can produce for dinner is a plate of cold cuts!"

Were you there Aardy? Do you know for a FACT this was due to the producers incompetence?
The producer is the producer, Jeremy Clarkson is the star. It is rather common knowledge that many stars are prima donnas. The producer among many other things is supposed to be keeping the wheels greased. You don't attempt to pack your star off to bed with a supper of cold cuts, you do what eventually happened they cooked Mr. Clarkson a steak.

Could everyone involved have exercised better judgement you bet they could have, and should have.
 
Now you could have written in what way Alliant Techsystems has address the problem. ........

, .......merely that those are the two which immediately come to my mind), then of course the unmanned Delta series of rockets (M,N, 0 through 8 including the heavies).

What's your point? The military have been using SRBs successfully since the 60s (submarines and ICBMs). The shuttle program has been using SRBs from inception (1981). In recent history, more liquid fueled rockets have blown up than solid fuel rockets according to wiki (I claim no expertise).

There are many technical reasons why NASA would NOT use SRBs or multi-stage SRBs exclusively for their types of missions. So again, what's your point?

LOL, I love your not-subtle display of Delta rocket expertise! BTW, looks to me some of your post was stolen/paraphrased from wiki.

Anyway. Please have the last word. I made my point.
 
My "point" is again the question how this does this address the problem of cold weather launches, such as was so disastrous for the Space Shuttle program. To me at least if to no one else it seems curious that NASA would again use the same sort of design.

:deadhorse: