Public or Private BCL

Should the BCL be private or public???

  • private

    Votes: 28 58.3%
  • public

    Votes: 16 33.3%
  • don't care

    Votes: 4 8.3%

  • Total voters
    48
Back Burner said:
Then I hear that if a client smells or is a no show he will be put on this private list. Doesn't this lesson the importance of the BCL? Why does this need to be private? Doesn't this turn something that is for the ladies protection into nothing but a private gossip area?
It is not for you or me to decide! But I don't see anything inherently wrong or trivializing in the concept of reporting clients who are bad for non-violent reasons, or who are no-shows (perhaps because they are anti-prostitution zealots who consider themselves heroes for booking fake calls). It's entirely reasonable that there be gradations of badness. Presumably some detail of why the client is bad is available along with the identifying information.

I'm all in favour of anything that reduces the stress on the girls.
Back Burner said:
My second problem is; who polices it.
If it's not someone whom the girls trust, it won't get used. And to make it trustworthy, that person must verify identities. There are many on this (and other!) boards, I'm sure, who would adopt an entirely different posting style if their name and work-number was posted in their profile, or even if this information was simply known to the mods.

Back Burner said:
As long as they women feel safe, do what’s best
Now, there's something I can agree with!
 
First, I never said that a client who smels bad gets entered, but explain to me why we can not have list for people such as this guy

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=63449

What is wrong with that????

Also, no one polices anything. That is not what these boards, the list, advertising directories are about. None of us police or try to police the industry, we all just provide information.

HH
 
midLifeCrisis said:
It is not for you or me to decide! But I don't see anything inherently wrong or trivializing in the concept of reporting clients who are bad for non-violent reasons

I guess we disagree on this point. If we do agree that it's safety first then how can you not think that a "smelly client" is not trivial in comparison to a SP having her life threaten? Where do you think the line should be drawn then? This time it's "he smells", next time it's "he's hairy".

Again I have no problem with the women having this private BCL but I do think if SP's are going to use the argument that it's for their safety, then why does a "smelly client" (Sorry to harp on this, and no I don't smell) have to be in the BCL?

Just a question.
 
HappyHookers said:
First, I never said that a client who smels bad gets entered, but explain to me why we can not have list for people such as this guy

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=63449

What is wrong with that????

Also, no one polices anything. That is not what these boards, the list, advertising directories are about. None of us police or try to police the industry, we all just provide information.

HH


Sorry "HH" I was late seeing your post. I never said that you said this,(the smelly guy thing) but other ladies have. And I`m talking about having that info private.

Again, what happens when this information that was provided turns out not to be true? What happens to the SP, and the post & how would you rectify it?


Just curious.
 
Seeing as I haven't personally had to deal with this yet, I can not given you a completely solid answer. All I can say is that:

1} I would make a public and private apology to the person listed
2} The lady in question would at least on my board, be public posted about and would be expected to make an apology as well {at least by me and I wouldn't stop nagging until she did}
3} If allowed, it would be publicly posted about on the various other boards.
4} Make any other type of restitution needed by the person wrongfully entered.

I can only do my best in the verification process, but it is not an exact science.

As for the private information, ya I have it. But would you rather the information be posted publicly with full names and address like on SPOC???? At least this way only the people who have applied to the BCL and have been thoroughly checked out, ads crossed check, every referral checked, so we know who is looking at the information. How many people can access the SPOC BCL?????

Now I think you asked a great question in what would I do if someone was wrongly entered. I wonder what the SPOC and BBE would do in the same situation?

As for the smelly client, I think people are misunderstanding this again. I personally would not enter a person because lady said the guy was smelly. However, on our board a lady may make a post about it. The forums are completely separate from the BCL though, so please understand that. Now would I allow personal information to be posted about this "smelly client"??? No, of course not.

As for your private men's room question, I do not have a problem with a properly run men's room. I do not think that a female owner should have access, even if it is her own board. I know a few PMR that are successful and are managed by responsible hobbyist {meaning if I listed their names, you would all say "Oh cool, they are good guys"} I know PMR that used for the sole purpose of destroying an SP's career. I think that is wrong, but what can I really do about it????

HH

HH
 
Back Burner said:
Again I have no problem with the women having this private BCL but I do think if SP's are going to use the argument that it's for their safety, then why does a "smelly client" (Sorry to harp on this, and no I don't smell) have to be in the BCL?
Is this just a nomenclature issue? Would your concerns be met if it were to be called a "Client Review Board" rather than a "Bad Client List"?
 
midLifeCrisis said:
Is this just a nomenclature issue? Would your concerns be met if it were to be called a "Client Review Board" rather than a "Bad Client List"?


I think that would just make it worse. It seems once again that as far as others are concerned, escorts should have none of few little in the way of rights. We don't have the right to a NRP, we don't have the right to a private BCL, we don't have the right to a private posting forum, amoung others.


HH
 
HappyHookers said:
I think that would just make it worse. It seems once again that as far as others are concerned, escorts should have none of few little in the way of rights. We don't have the right to a NRP, we don't have the right to a private BCL, we don't have the right to a private posting forum, amoung others.


HH

Unless you have received a lot of pm's " as far as others are concerned " seems to refer to one or two posters. I can't imagine there are two many who believe sp's should have restricted rights.
 
train said:
Unless you have received a lot of pm's " as far as others are concerned " seems to refer to one or two posters. I can't imagine there are two many who believe sp's should have restricted rights.

Having been in this business as long as I have and having gained experience through the sharing of others who have been around for many more years then me, you would be surprised to hear what the ladies feel about having restricted rights.

Sweetie I can tell you feel them from all areas of our lives.

From the boards, we have no right to protect ourselves from slander and lies. We have no right to have our names withheld in PMs etc especially with all the STD threads lately. These women are to named, and publicly according to quite a few around here. Who cares that no proof of an actual STD exists, who cares that these men could have contracted something from someone else. As soon as any hobbyist feels like he has gotten something, it is always "that damn hooker" gave it to me. Where are our rights there?

The simple fact that I have to post a poll like this, and yet people still feel {which they are entitled to} that the list should be public, and mostly only because they want to know out of curiosity. Who's best interests are being looked out for there????

It has been brought up a lot lately and previously as well, about women with No Review Policies. "We are the paying customer, the customer is always right, we have a right to review them, they don't like get out of the business" I mean Hello??? We are human too, we have feels, thoughts, opinions etc.

On MERB, a poll "Should SPs shut up? " Do you know how many women had to fight to be able to have all of women able to post on review boards now. It was a completely No-No before. If you were an SP, you were not allow on the board. Period.

There are always threads about what rates we should charge, what services we should offer with people making comments that entail avoiding anyone who doesn't fit the realm they feel is right.

From wives, girlfriends and mainstream society women. Most of them believing that we should have no rights because we help "their" husbands, fathers, brothers, boyfriends to cheat. We are dirty whores.

From police, from government, shall I continue????

Every where we go, someone has something to say about what we can and can not do, what we should do, what we should look like, what we should charge, the type people we are. It is a non-stop battle.

Having PM's from people means nothing. I am talking about the everyday life of an escort and the reactions, feels and opinions of those we come across. To a lot of them, we are less then human, and we should have little to no rights at all.
 
Bravo

hh well said very good post no offence to the guys not all of them are like this

ps i was labled a bitch on another board only because i chose to stand up for my self. it seems on that board i was only there to serve and be a door mat. sorry but i did that with my ex husband and all i want now is a lil respect not much to ask but hard for some people to give. :(