Public or Private BCL

Should the BCL be private or public???

  • private

    Votes: 28 58.3%
  • public

    Votes: 16 33.3%
  • don't care

    Votes: 4 8.3%

  • Total voters
    48
While I do understand to a point the reasoning behind a public list, I do feel that most people who are encouraging the list to be public are men, and rightly so, they want to know who is on the list, if they are indeed on the list etc. But really that is not what this list is about, and to hopefully clear up some things, the list is not about an pissed off SP making a claim either.

Now I will not try to say that I have professional training in interviewing people when they make a claim, but I have spoken to many detectives from Metro, Peel and some other regions who work in the sex crimes, street crimes and morals divisions and have been given some real insight on how to question a victim. This is important as I need to be 100% sure that the information provided is accurate. Again, I am not an expert, but I wonder and honestly challenge those who have a public list, if they put forth the same effort and have the same relationship with the various police departments.

I also have to reiterate the importance of client discretion. I realize that many say, if he is listed and is dangerous he should be posted about publicly, and my answer is no. He shouldn't. It is not right to go posting his personal information on a public forum. Also, in most cases with these and other type boards, the phone number is 416-555-****, and the name is posted as John *****, how helpful is that really. Why is some of the information not just handed out??? Because the law prohibits is. None of theses sites have the funding to deal with a major law suit, none of the men have had criminal charges laid, the claim is therefore alleged and most women who access the BCL understand this.

Please understand that we have also been successful in our research efforts to have men who were previously blacklisted on other BCLs for some violent and dangerous behaviors, to have proven that what was entered was not true. The client may have been an ass, a little rough and rude, a little demanding, even emotionally abusive, but he did not physically hurt anyone.

Now a SP can not just make a claim that client is a Bad client because he wrote a negative review of her, called her fat and ugly, or anything of the sort. That is not what this list is about, and again this list is broken up into categories. For example, there is a section for known clients who are in the habit of removing the condom during the main event. Shockingly enough there are quite a few who do this. This is dangerous, therefore they are listed. There is a category for know scam artists, and rip offs. Men who pay with an envelope full of bill size news paper cut outs. There is a Dangerous offenders categories for men who have raped, violent robbed, and/or beat women. A section for men who bring cameras into MP’s or SP sessions. Can you honestly say that these people should not be listed????

Believe it or not, 90% of the online escorts and agencies that use this list are only using it for safety. They get a phone number or email address, they cross check against list, and if something comes up, they decide if they want to take the call. That is all it is about. There is no hidden agenda, there is no SP retaliation going on, and to believe so is to basically say that you don’t trust the women using this system. You are saying you do not trust the administrators to do their job. If that is the case, where is the proof or even the possible proof that we are not doing our job probably? And where is the proof that those who host a public list are doing there jobs??? How can you say that all the entries in the public list are accurate and truthful??? The SPOC list, mostly made up lately of SW claims, can not the same things be said about them. The SW got mad when they saw a regular of theirs going to the girl down the street, so they blacklisted him. How much investigation is done by the SPOC??? How much is done by BBE??? There are a few entries there that people would question if it was fact or fiction or even a little of both. I am not saying that either of these places are guilty of this, but the question is there regardless. If you can question the motives and the investigation practices of a private list, you should question the same of public list.

HH
 
Svend said:
Bad hygiene?
A no-show will make the bad client list?
He'll be on par with someone who beats or rapes an escort?

Bad hygiene HELL YEAH, but not bad so much as undesireable, if there is not 2 seperate lists then bad it is.

No-shows should also make it, how would we ever find out that Joe Blow does it every week-end to a different girl if his name weren't there.


Finally, of course a client with mouth rot is not on par with one who rapes or beats a girl...at least not to those with a brain...You see some of us can actually read and can see the difference between a guy that rapes and a guy that doesn't show up. :rolleyes:
 
Okay, having different categories and levels of bad behaviour is good.

I can read. :rolleyes:
 
The Shake said:
Allowing personal information in public forums, except in the most extreme circumstances, is an outrageously bad idea. Think about some of the people on these boards - the nuts and whack jobs and Cardinal Fang - do you really think that they should have access to private information based on a simple accusation? Is that wise or safe for anyone?

HEAR HEAR!
 
I say make it public. There's nothing but anonymity on these boards and frankly, I'd like to know if some guy I'm yucking it up with on here is an a-hole abuser. You may ask: what difference does it make if you know? Well, I think that abusers think they have power over women because women don't talk and that they're too afriad to turn them in or make a complaint to the police. What an abuser couldn't stand was a woman who stood up to him and a community of men who also stand against him. Anyway, that's my two cents for what its worth.
 
I think you are misunderstanding the list here. There maybe 5% of the people who are listed are actually on these boards. So what difference would it make for the other 95% of the clients who are listed. It would make a difference to them. They won't get any backlash, unless of course a member here or another board decides to take matters into their own hands. I personally would feel very responsible if my information that I listed in a public list was the tool used to harm another person.

HH
 
The Shake said:
Ah, no.

If someone in the general public is charged with a crime, it may be reported on the news. Of course, a charge only occurs after an investigation by the police. While there are obvious exceptions if the case and/or the accused are extremely high profile (the recent accusations against Bill Cosby come to find), very few media outlets would ever report even the most basic personal info (such as a name) without a formal charge having been laid.

It's silly to try to compare unsubstantiated allegations made on a review/discussion board to the media reporting on police investigations.

That said, many sex workers feel isolated from the legal system (for obvious reasons) and are not comfortable dealing with the police. Bad client lists give them an opportunity to share knowledge and protect themselves. Although there is always a chance of inaccurate or even malicious information being provided on such lists, keeping access restricted to the core group of people that need it seems to be a reasonable trade-off. In a worst case scenario, a falsely accused John might find it more difficult to book a date. While unfair, it's hardly the end of the world. The consequences of having your personal information posted in a public forum, however, could be far more serious.

As for Paige's asinine comment that "some sex workers can't be bothered with passwords", my only response would be "too fucking bad". We have passwords for our bank cards, our voice mail, our e-mail, E-bay, tax software, etc., ad naseum. If you are so fucking lazy that you "can't be bothered" to have a password to access information that can protect well, quite frankly, you're probably too fucking lazy (or stupid) to find and read the information in the first place.
Allowing personal information in public forums, except in the most extreme circumstances, is an outrageously bad idea. Think about some of the people on these boards - the nuts and whack jobs and Cardinal Fang - do you really think that they should have access to private information based on a simple accusation? Is that wise or safe for anyone?
omg i think i luv you ;)
 
Ok guys, I love the little cat and mouse games just like the next person, but for the purpose of this thread and the importance of it, can we please stay on topic. Just this once?????

HH
 
Autoguy and YYC: the Fangster and Goober are having a pissing contest in another thread. Personally I think they are secret lovers and this pissing contest is nothing but a smoke screen. I'm going to send thier names onto Myron Thompson.
 
What bothers me about this entire thing is that I see two issues.
We've went from one extreme to another. I have no problem with SP's feeling they need a private BCL is for their own safety and protection. That is the argument isn't it?

Then I hear that if a client smells or is a no show he will be put on this private list. Doesn't this lesson the importance of the BCL? Why does this need to be private? Doesn't this turn something that is for the ladies protection into nothing but a private gossip area? I think this is why the comparison is made to a private men’s room.

My second problem is; who polices it. I've seen first hand where individuals post first then get the facts later. Only to find that they were totally wrong. (KK & the flower) I understand that mistakes will happen and that some things will fall between the cracks (because they will) as long as there is a consistent and quick procedure to correcting these types of errors.

As long as they women feel safe, do what’s best