Prostitution Ruling

Nemesis_2007

Member
Dec 16, 2007
70
0
6
Hey does anyone know when the prostitution ruling will conclude? When is the appeal going to be heard and a decision be made?
 
It's not exactly a simple matter, is it? If they rule the current laws ARE constitutional, they're going to have to come up with a damn good argument to counter the original judge's statements. If they rule the current laws AREN'T constitutional, even a moron would realize that's going to seriously shake things up. For one thing, the Harper government sure as hell isn't going to stand for that. What new legislation could they pass that would restrict prostitution as much as or more than it is today and still pass muster in the courts? Can they restrict prostitution to certain venues? What kind of licensing and registration aspects should prostitution have? How can these be implemented to protect prostitutes and other interested parties? How can they help prevent instances of underage prostitution? What kind of help is available for prostitutes who are threatened or abused? Or for prostitutes that are being pimped? Can prostitutes be required to only work at a registered agency? Should STD checks be mandatory? How will the government deal with the inevitable public backlash?

They have their work cut out for them.
 
It's not exactly a simple matter, is it? If they rule the current laws ARE constitutional, they're going to have to come up with a damn good argument to counter the original judge's statements. If they rule the current laws AREN'T constitutional, even a moron would realize that's going to seriously shake things up. For one thing, the Harper government sure as hell isn't going to stand for that. What new legislation could they pass that would restrict prostitution as much as or more than it is today and still pass muster in the courts? Can they restrict prostitution to certain venues? What kind of licensing and registration aspects should prostitution have? How can these be implemented to protect prostitutes and other interested parties? How can they help prevent instances of underage prostitution? What kind of help is available for prostitutes who are threatened or abused? Or for prostitutes that are being pimped? Can prostitutes be required to only work at a registered agency? Should STD checks be mandatory? How will the government deal with the inevitable public backlash?

They have their work cut out for them.

Delays of six months between hearing and decision are not unusual at the C of A level.
 
Delays of six months between hearing and decision are not unusual at the C of A level.

You mean it's not like American Idol where judges can rattle off a decision in 30 seconds or less?
 
Thanks guys for your info. The reason why i asked because i own a company that provides licensed bodyguards and want to expand into the escort industry but obviously cant do so with the current laws in place.
 
Last edited:
Oh one more question, which court is involved? Supreme?

I don't know a lot about the courts, but I believe we're at the first level of appeal. If they rule in favour of the first decision, we still have the Supreme Court, right?
 
I think everyone knows where Harper stands on this issue. Should be very interesting.

Actually, nobody really knows where Harper stands on this issue, other than him preferring not to touch it at all. We're not even sure if Harper knows where Harper stands on the issue, but we're quite sure he doesn't want to fight an election over it.

I can't say too much publicly, but many of the fears of his "secret agenda" are somewhat misplaced. When ignoring what he's said (usually to placate his base) and focusing on what he's done (when actually implementing legislation) he hasn't become the born-again social conservative we were all so afraid of. Lots of time to change his tune, of course, but I have it on very good authority that he has no desire to swing to the right on most social issues.

Regardless of what happens at the OCA and SCC, one thing that we won't see is a knee-jerk reaction from Parliament, with any sort of hasty implementation of Swedish Approach (I refuse to legitimize it by calling it a "model" for anything), which is less palatable to the Harper Government than most of us would think. Additionally, the SCC will be smart enough to include a stay in their judgement, to allow Parliament time to review the issue before tabling any new legislation. Then, when that's all said and done, it'll fall to the municipalities to create regulatory guidelines; I freely admit that I'm actually a lot more concerned about Ford and Mammoliti, than I am about Harper or even Joy Smith.

You'll have to take my word for it, but things are moving along behind the scenes, and we don't expect the decision until early 2012 at the earliest. After all, Himel herself took a full year to write the decision, and there's every indication the OCA will be just as thorough as she was.
 
Last edited:
Actually, nobody really knows where Harper stands on this issue, other than him preferring not to touch it at all.

I can't say too much publicly, but many of the fears of his "secret agenda" are somewhat misplaced. When ignoring what he's said (usually to placate his base) and focusing on what he's done (when actually implementing legislation) he hasn't become the born-again social conservative we were all so afraid of. Lots of time to change his tune, of course, but I have it on very good authority that he has no desire to swing to the right on most social issues.

Regardless of what happens at the OCA and SCC, one thing that we won't see is a knee-jerk reaction from Parliament, with any sort of hasty implementation of Swedish Approach (I refuse to legitimize it by calling it a "model" for anything) is less palatable to the Harper Government than most of us would think. Additionally, the SCC will be smart enough to include a stay in their judgement, to allow Parliament time to review the issue before tabling any new legislation. Then, when that's all said and done, it'll fall to the municipalities to create regulatory guidelines; I freely admit that I'm actually a lot more concerned about Ford and Mammoliti, than I am about Harper or even Joy Smith.

You'll have to take my word for it, but things are moving along behind the scenes, and we don't expect the decision until early 2012 at the earliest. After all, Himel herself took a full year to write the decision, and there's every indication the OCA will be just as thorough as she was.

Harper has lasted this long and now has a majority because he restrained his right wing social agenda whilst throwing the occasional bone to the church ladies. Now that he has total power, I think he will still remain aloof and reasonable, but may allow backbenchers or Senators to introduce reactionary legislation . Like the clown who suggested changing the beaver to a polar bear, or the covert campaign against the CBC which is now underway. Could be a long 4 years.
 
It's not exactly a simple matter, is it? If they rule the current laws ARE constitutional, they're going to have to come up with a damn good argument to counter the original judge's statements. If they rule the current laws AREN'T constitutional, even a moron would realize that's going to seriously shake things up. For one thing, the Harper government sure as hell isn't going to stand for that. What new legislation could they pass that would restrict prostitution as much as or more than it is today and still pass muster in the courts? Can they restrict prostitution to certain venues? What kind of licensing and registration aspects should prostitution have? How can these be implemented to protect prostitutes and other interested parties? How can they help prevent instances of underage prostitution? What kind of help is available for prostitutes who are threatened or abused? Or for prostitutes that are being pimped? Can prostitutes be required to only work at a registered agency? Should STD checks be mandatory? How will the government deal with the inevitable public backlash?

They have their work cut out for them.

This is what makes government involvement in any industry a pain in the ass. Everyone has "the good" of the members of the industry and the community in mind and them make shit so complicated that noone can really benefit from the industry.
 
Harper has lasted this long and now has a majority because he restrained his right wing social agenda whilst throwing the occasional bone to the church ladies

On abortion and several other issues he has more or less pledged not to introduce legislation in those areas, and I believe since he said he won't, that he won't.

However he has made no pledge on this issue and so my fear is that this would be an easy bone to throw to the church ladies. I doubt the pro-prostitution proud is going to go out and protest at his events, it would probably just blow over.
 
However he has made no pledge on this issue and so my fear is that this would be an easy bone to throw to the church ladies. I doubt the pro-prostitution proud is going to go out and protest at his events, it would probably just blow over.

Will he outlaw gay prostitution as well? Or, only the heteros?
 
On abortion and several other issues he has more or less pledged not to introduce legislation in those areas, and I believe since he said he won't, that he won't.

What he said is that his govt will not support any legistlation to restrict abortion. The door that he left open was for his church MPs to table a private members bill that would be subject to an open vote...i.e. anyone be they Lib, NDP or Fart Catching Reformer can vote as they see fit....there would not be a "Govt" mandated "vote this way edict" from Harper to his fart catchers. That way he is off the hook as HE and HIS govt did not introduce the legistlation but HE and HIS govt can vote any which way they want in a free vote. Do not delude yourself into thinking that the Harper Reformers do not want to own every female's uterus and dictate what it can or cannot do.

In the meantime the religious right and reformers are quietly assuming local hospital boards which do have the power to decide whether or not legal abortions are done within their four walls. "Oh Dr Fiji you want hospital rights as an OBGYN? No problem as long as you do not perform abortions." Now when 99% of your patients are with you to HAVE babies are you going to pass on that revenue stream solely to provide the occasional abortion?

Quietly across the country females of all ages cannot get abortions within their own area or city. None on PEI, Very difficult in the baptist bible belt of NB.

We here in Toronto have a very skewed view of how things work in the hinterland. I realize that most of you here don't care as it doesn't affect you but what you should care enough about is stopping the mainly white male Reformers of the country who continue to exercise control over what a lady can or cannot do with her body.

They are going to continue to make inroads and blow away 30 years of progress for females.
 
Actually, nobody really knows where Harper stands on this issue, other than him preferring not to touch it at all. We're not even sure if Harper knows where Harper stands on the issue, but we're quite sure he doesn't want to fight an election over it.

You'll have to take my word for it, but things are moving along behind the scenes, and we don't expect the decision until early 2012 at the earliest. After all, Himel herself took a full year to write the decision, and there's every indication the OCA will be just as thorough as she was.

I'll take your word for it. But it's not like Harper has been silent on the issue and everything he's said so far points to opposition. Might just be political grandstanding, who knows?