Privacy verses "Public Good"

SkyRider

Banned
Mar 31, 2009
17,546
2
0
There is an important point tangentially raised in a couple of current threads but I think it deserves its own thread.

Question: How much information is the public/employer/neighbour entitled to know about you?

Several residents in Strathroy interviewed by the news media said they should have been informed that a suspected terrorist was living in the neighbourhood. Agree, disagree?
 
In the case of a terrorist suspect, we the public should only be informed after the fact, so as to maintain the integrity of the investigation without compromising it. While there is the slim chance that an accident could occur if they are making a homemade explosive device, that isn't enough to warrant notifying residents of the goings on in their neighbourhood. Just like the police wouldn't notify anyone living near a house that is being used as a grow op or chem den for the manufacture or drugs. The right of the public shouldn't be a consideration in an investigation like this case, unless there is an imminent danger to the public, which there wasn't. For the police to find out the full extent of this persons involvement in terrorism, their target, the potential of working within a cell and what or who their contacts may be, the public must remain in the dark.
 
In the case of a terrorist suspect, we the public should only be informed after the fact, so as to maintain the integrity of the investigation without compromising it.
Not just with suspected terrorists but this issue arises from time to time. Examples:

A convicted pedo is released into the community.
Karla Homolka living next door.
A convicted murderer who might blow up his house along with a few others.

I remember a few years ago "Jane Doe" sue (and won) the police for not informing her and other women that there was a rapist on the loose in their area.
 
There is an important point tangentially raised in a couple of current threads but I think it deserves its own thread.

Question: How much information is the public/employer/neighbour entitled to know about you?

Several residents in Strathroy interviewed by the news media said they should have been informed that a suspected terrorist was living in the neighbourhood. Agree, disagree?


Nothing. How is that?


If he was just "suspected" then I hate to say it but nothing also.
 
Not just with suspected terrorists but this issue arises from time to time. Examples:

A convicted pedo is released into the community.
Karla Homolka living next door.
A convicted murderer who might blow up his house along with a few others.

I remember a few years ago "Jane Doe" sue (and won) the police for not informing her and other women that there was a rapist on the loose in their area.

Suspected is a lot different from Convicted. A convicted sex offender is a proven risk to the public, so it's reasonable to notify the neighbours. A suspected terrorist may not be much of a risk to the neighbors, they probably want to attack a more public target.
 
Not just with suspected terrorists but this issue arises from time to time. Examples:

A convicted pedo is released into the community.
Karla Homolka living next door.
A convicted murderer who might blow up his house along with a few others.

I remember a few years ago "Jane Doe" sue (and won) the police for not informing her and other women that there was a rapist on the loose in their area.


There is a big difference with your examples, as FF pointed out, these are examples of people who were convicted and therefore could be a possible threat to the community that they are living in.
The one example of a murderer who has been convicted of such and done his time is a tad different though. The circumstances surrounding his crime may not dictate that he is the type to blow his house up.
Pedophiles on the other hand, have a well known to re-offend. They aren't really the the one off type of offender, like a murderer.

I recall the Jane Doe case and it revolved around a single rapist, who committed his crimes by entering through open windows during a hot summer. He had committed numerous rapes before Jane Doe, in a certain area of the city and the police weighed the facts and chose not to inform the public, hoping to catch him before he was able to victimize again. They chose wrong in this case, as the threat to the area was imminent and they used the public as bait. That's why she won her case.

In the case of drug labs/grow ops and terrorism, there is a danger to the public, drug labs and grow ops can blow up and if the terror suspect is building a homemade explosive, that too can go seriously wrong. In this case, a suspected terrorist, there is more to be gained in keeping him under surveillance, gaining valuable intel on his/her means of terror (bomb, guns) if they are working in a group, a cell if you will and the extent of that group and its ties to terrorism and also what the target is. In this case, it's better to take down the whole cell, know its links and what they see as a good target. Also to track where they got their weapons, if illegal and any products used for building an explosive device, if one was made.

In the case of a drug lab or grow op, the police weigh the threat of explosion to the community and take this seriously. Once they know the link to who is behind this, they usually take it down immediately upon finding this sort of intel out, because the threat is real in this case.