Pond Death

lol -really? - Well I submit to you that it can't regulate conduct punitively or by waving a magic wand and ignorantly passing laws.

If that were the case there would be fewer and fewer people both in jail and going through the legal system. This is clearly not the case. The message is not being received or understood.

I trust you have informed Our Harper Government of the utter futility of its recent stiffening of legal penalties for crime and plans for superjails to warehouse the offenders.

Reason having failed, I guess the response to the Freedom For Pond Owners lobby, must the same as theirs to similar Soft on Crime Bleeding Hearts: "Too fucking bad! It's the law".

But no matter whether, "The message is not being received or understood", no one who passes laws is gonna stop trying. At least not until we can figure out how to drown the potentially negligent pond owners and parents before puberty.

But that seems kinda harsh.
 
Actually that is exactly where Rockslinger's logic leads. He argues death by misadventure cannot be eliminated so don't bother trying.
What Rockslinger said is that "death by misadventure" will never be completely eliminated (e.g there are 500 drowning deaths a year), but just how far do we go to safeguard "death by misadventure". Should adults be forced to wear bike helmets?
 
What Rockslinger said is that "death by misadventure" will never be completely eliminated (e.g there are 500 drowning deaths a year), but just how far do we go to safeguard "death by misadventure". Should adults be forced to wear bike helmets?

I think there is a massive qualitative difference between laws designed to protect children and those designed to protect adults.

Considering the social cost of brain injuries (fatalities are cheap) I don't have an objection to a law requiring adults to wear bike helmets when riding. It is pretty darned close to the seat belt law to my mind. I have not looked at the numbers, but if a law that imposes a minimal burden (like bike helmets) will reduce injuries a substantial amount...I would not likely be opposed to it.

In return, do you object to the laws that require minors to wear bike helmets based on your misadventure theory?
 
In return, do you object to the laws that require minors to wear bike helmets based on your misadventure theory?
No, I do not object to the kid bike helmet law but of you forget to put the helmet on your kid and he kills himself crashing into a tree should you be charged with gross negligence causing death?
 
No, I do not object to the kid bike helmet law but of you forget to put the helmet on your kid and he kills himself crashing into a tree should you be charged with gross negligence causing death?

It really depends on the circumstances.

As I indicated above (more than once I think), I think that is an overcharge done very early. I expect it will result in a plea to something less, or an acquittal, depending on the facts of the case. Right now we know very little in the way of facts.
 
For those interested, the fine in Toronto for a kid not wearing a helmet while riding a bike is $65 plus $5 court cost plus $10 into a victims relief fund. I assume the kid's parents are responsible for paying the fine. Hate to see a 10 year old kid going to court to pay a fine. If the kid crashes into a city own tree, then there is additional liability for damaging the tree.