Polite Canadian gets Pepper Sprayed

Hangman said:
You're absolutely right. A law-abiding citizen should not get assaulted. However, this guy was not obeying the law, was he. Failing to follow the directions of a police officer or in this case, Homeland Security, IS ILLEGAL.

Or would you rather that people can just ignore the police and do whatever they please?

Interesting difference in how you all view this guy...who may or not be a lawbreaker...versus how you all leap to the defense of the retard who got clocked at 250kph and you scream about how he is innocent, the speed racing law is wrong, there is nothing wrong with speeding when you know what you are doing, blah blah blah.

Just for the record I think that the customs guy and this guy are both wrong. The Canucklehead could have asked more politely for some politeness. The customs guy does not have to be a jerk in how he treats each new 'customer'.

To paraphrase Trudeau and what he said about back bench MPs the same applies to customs people....100 yards away from their booth and out of uniform these guys are nobody. And I think that they know that so they are just bigger assholes when on duty.
 
vsailor said:
I'm not afraid of them in the slightest!!!!! ( you don't know me, so don't surmise you do)...I say "yes sir" because I want to get to my destination with the least amount of hassle!!! and a little courtesy goes a long, long way compared to rudeness (try it sometime you might be surprised!!!)...just as when I get pulled over doing 140 in a 100 zone I say "yes sir" to the cop...you wanna argue with them tough guy go ahead, I'll continue to say "yes sir" whenever crossing the US (or any border)!!!


I don't argue with them either. thats because they are little tyrants.

when I said you are afraid- I don't quaking like tboy when he see a bike, I mean you don't act natural. you become afraid they might stop, harass, or something worse for a some trivial shit- like they don't like the look you give them. to me thats bullshit and is wrong.
 
If you want to be treated like a mature, respected adult, then how about acting like one?

It always amazes me how complete a-holes are the first ones to say they were 'disrespected' or not treated 'fairly'.

Ever hear of the golden rule - 'do unto others as you would have them do unto you...'
 
Respect goes both ways.

I've always found it odd that police, border guards, security, military etc., have always found a disproportionate number of arrogant, disrespectful and outright hostile individuals to fill their ranks. It seems like these jobs are magnets for emotionally and socially stunted adults.

Maybe these areas need to do a better job of screening potential employees? And they certainly need to do a much better job of policing their own.


This goes for the thread on the idiot cop that beat up (I mean, "tried to restrain") a 15-year old girl as well.
 
red said:
yes. thats right. there is no doubt the individual was an idiot but he did not deserve to be pepper sprayed.
At the border when you are instructed to turn off your vehicle - you do. You don't argue about how the Agent didn't say "please." It may be nice if they say please, but try getting a Judge to agree that you were abused because the agent said "turn the engine off" rather than "please turn the engine of your car off."
 
red said:
the person wasn't arrested or charged so I guess they didn't do anything illegal.
Whoa, where did you get that from? He was detained - remember that USCBP has extensive administrative law powers that they don't have to take you off to U.S. District Court to enforce, it is rather up to you to appeal the administrative decision.
 
Could he have phrased it more politely? Sure, but he wasn't making a request, he was issuing an order so why make it sound like a request by putting a please in there?

Should the driver have been pepper-sprayed? Probably not, but w/o knowing the "tone" of the "say please" it's hard to tell.

(and no I didn't defend the 250kph driver either.... I don't care how good a driver you are, how good your car is and what public road you are using, there is no excuse for driving like that)
 
Aardvark154 said:
Whoa, where did you get that from? He was detained - remember that USCBP has extensive administrative law powers that they don't have to take you off to U.S. District Court to enforce, it is rather up to you to appeal the administrative decision.
was he charged with a criminal offence?
 
red said:
was he charged with a criminal offence?
He doesn't have to be.

You are a USCBP Agent, I refuse to turn off the engine of my car, you ask again, I refuse, you pepper spray me.

You have a couple of different options: You could charge me with Criminal Violations of U.S. Code. But how much easier for you to instead charge me with Administrative Violations of the Immigration and Nationality Act. I can end up being bared from attempting to enter the U.S. for at least five years and depending upon the offense longer. Further if I lose in any Immigration or Administrative hearing, the ball is now in my court to appeal through the U.S. District Court. And better yet for USCBP the courts have given very great deference to governmental action at the border.

In plain English, I’m going to have to prove that your actions were absolutely unconscionable, not merely questionable, before I have much likelihood of prevailing.

On top of the above this all happened Monday March 2. You do your report it does through the channels up to the U.S. Attorney's Office - they can seek Criminal Charges against me even though you the USCBP Agent never arrested or summonsed me. Hence the fact that there are no criminal charges three days later means nothing.
 
ok sir you win , can you PLEASE turn you FCKG car off
 
I find the USCBP agents at Pearson more friendly than the ones at the Buffalo/Peace Bridge land crossing. Whenver I fly they are polite, crack the odd joke and smile. At the Peace Bridge they seem grumpy, have no sense of humour, etc. Not sure why this is.
 
red said:
I don't think that asking the officer to say please (yes- I agree it was stupid) warrants a physical response.

But that isn't strictly what happened. It sounds like he was ordered multiple times to comply and refused to. From the story the officer told him that if he did not comply that the result would be he would be pepper sprayed. Even after being told he would be pepper sprayed he STILL refused to comply, and lo and behold, he got pepper sprayed.

Given that the officer gave him fair warning of what was going to happen it's less clear to me that it was excessive. He wasn't surprised that he got pepper sprayed, he knew damn well it was coming and he knew what he needed to do to avoid it.
 
I don't expect any please and thankyou's at the border ever. If I get it I'm shocked and would I demand it, never. the guy was looking for trouble and he found it. No sympathy here.
 
I'm never afraid of crossing into the USA - or coming home for that matter. Number one reason - I have nothing to hide / no reason to fear. Number two - I am always polite and bust out the 'yes sir / thank you sir' not out of fear but because it is the way I was raised.

Funny how if you show proper respect and manners then the VAST majority of the time you get treated the same.

One does not DEMAND respect - one EARNS it.