Hi Ei Jin,
Bummer about the Highland Park 25.
Typically, Scotch has an ABV (alcohol by volume) of ~43-48% as they believe that is where it is most enjoyable. Cask strength offerings are unique because they are bottled in the 50-60% ABV range since they do not dilute it down. Due to the higher ABV, it will taste harsher - although one could conceivably dilute with water or ice before drinking. In thinking further about this, since your intended recipient has not given you much indication as to his preferences, I would suggest bypassing the Laphroaig.
In looking further for you on LCBO, I discovered that they have incorrectly classified two “Scotch Single Malts” as “Scotch Whisky Blends”! So, if you filter to “Scotch Whisky Blends”, you will find the Balvenie Tun 1509 #5. This is a limited edition release and can be considered a very special gift. I have 8 bottles from their original Tun 1401 series and they will be some of the last bottles I ever give up if I am whittling down my collection. Slightly lower on the price scale is the Macallan Rare Cask and can also be considered a quality gift. Again, both of these are indeed single malts - and both seem readily available.
Hope this helps!
S.