Please help, need advice on Whisky.

It's a matter of palatte.

The Spayside single malts are more refined and easier to drink. The single malts of Western Scotland are peaty and take some getting used to. Johnny Walker is now Japanese owned, I don't drink it but I do enjoy JW's single malt Glen Cardhu. A bottle of 12yo will run you $82.00.

These days I only drink the nectar of Islay. You can get a Port Charlotte 10yo for $70.00, or an Ardbeg An Oa 10 yo for $62.00. Then there's Irish Whiskey, but my exploration of those is only just beginning.
 
Some, who are not a farmaioli like yours truly, may find this disguising. IMHO there's no better accompaniment to single malt.

 
It's a matter of palatte.

The Spayside single malts are more refined and easier to drink. The single malts of Western Scotland are peaty and take some getting used to. Johnny Walker is now Japanese owned, I don't drink it but I do enjoy JW's single malt Glen Cardhu. A bottle of 12yo will run you $82.00.

These days I only drink the nectar of Islay. You can get a Port Charlotte 10yo for $70.00, or an Ardbeg An Oa 10 yo for $62.00. Then there's Irish Whiskey, but my exploration of those is only just beginning.

There isn't yet a peaty Canadian, but there is Bearface, which is a really tasty and smooth newer Canadian whisky.
At $39 or so its worth checking out.
 
Macallan rare cask is a great choice.
You can't go wrong with any Macallan. But check the lcbo website to see which location has available stock as most specially with the higher priced choices only have very limited quantity in the store, and considering is Christmas time they run out of stock.
If the stock is 3 or less call the store and make sure they have availability.
 
Hi Ei Jin,

Bummer about the Highland Park 25.

Typically, Scotch has an ABV (alcohol by volume) of ~43-48% as they believe that is where it is most enjoyable. Cask strength offerings are unique because they are bottled in the 50-60% ABV range since they do not dilute it down. Due to the higher ABV, it will taste harsher - although one could conceivably dilute with water or ice before drinking. In thinking further about this, since your intended recipient has not given you much indication as to his preferences, I would suggest bypassing the Laphroaig.

In looking further for you on LCBO, I discovered that they have incorrectly classified two “Scotch Single Malts” as “Scotch Whisky Blends”! So, if you filter to “Scotch Whisky Blends”, you will find the Balvenie Tun 1509 #5. This is a limited edition release and can be considered a very special gift. I have 8 bottles from their original Tun 1401 series and they will be some of the last bottles I ever give up if I am whittling down my collection. Slightly lower on the price scale is the Macallan Rare Cask and can also be considered a quality gift. Again, both of these are indeed single malts - and both seem readily available.

Hope this helps!
S.

Awwwww you are the sweetest. Thank you so much for taking the time to search the lcbo website for me. I have ordered it already and should have it on Monday or Tuesday. I am so impressed with your knowledge in whisky. It seems you are making very good investments in your precious collection. Thank you again and I hope you have a lovely weekend.
 
Macallan rare cask is a great choice.
You can't go wrong with any Macallan. But check the lcbo website to see which location has available stock as most specially with the higher priced choices only have very limited quantity in the store, and considering is Christmas time they run out of stock.
If the stock is 3 or less call the store and make sure they have availability.

Thank you very much for the tip.
 
It's a matter of palatte.

The Spayside single malts are more refined and easier to drink. The single malts of Western Scotland are peaty and take some getting used to.

This in a nutshell; what does the gift recipient prefer? The Glenlivet 21 is from Speyside so it won't be a good choice for a person that enjoys a peatier scotch from Islay. I'd wager a guess that the person you're buying for likes the Islay scotches, given his preferrence for bourbon as you stated.

Also if you are able to acquire one, I would recommend a Japanese blended whiskey like an older Hibiki 21 (if you can source one out).