please explain it to me

Titalian

No Regrets
Nov 27, 2012
8,488
9
0
Everywhere
can i ask you, with all my respect? you really think that's going to work?

sure, you can say you are giving piano lessons and you're a freelance piano instructor..and you dont have to provide proof that you're a freelance professional piano instructor...

but..

the police aren't stupid. and they can see through this ruse/bullsh*t play.

and they might decide to arrest and press charges anyways.

its like a killer being caught in the house with the body on the floor and he's saying he didnt do it, he just walked in on the crime scene cause he was just looking for a bathroom to use, in the house.

in the end, the police and court of law are going to put you on trial. whether or not your guilty, they're gonna drag you through the mud and put you through an exhausting ordeal of process in court. call you guilty and make you prove your innocence. you think the police give a sh*t about you or what happens to you?

regardless if in this country you're innocent until proven guilty.
On another note, I truly believe most LE don't really give a shit, about this idiodic bill. This has most certainly been voiced by Mtl LE.
 

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,947
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
PayPal is another source of money transfer, Which is literally undetectable. I use it all the time for ebay purchases.
How is your paypal transaction history "undetectable"????

Cash seems FAR less detectable to me.

You aren't under the illusion that your bank records are somehow secret from the police, are you?
 

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,947
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
and like I said ............. let's not forget in Canada you don't have to PROVE your innocence, they have to provide proof of your GUILT.
They will have a lot less trouble proving your guilt than you think. People here seem to think judges and juries can be stymied by word games. They aren't.
 

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,947
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
On another note, I truly believe most LE don't really give a shit, about this idiodic bill. This has most certainly been voiced by Mtl LE.
Well that is the ultimate question. If they decide to go after prostitution none of the tricks mentioned here will save you. If they decide not to enforce it at all then no tricks will be needed.

What happens remains to be seen but they certainly would not have any trouble convicting someone claiming that paypal isn't cash or that the money was for the condom.
 

Terminator2000

Well-known member
Jun 16, 2007
3,466
144
63
On another note, I truly believe most LE don't really give a shit, about this idiodic bill. This has most certainly been voiced by Mtl LE.
LE dont really give a shit about this idiodic bill. and dont forget also, they dont really give a shit about you. or if you go through the justice system's grinder....
 

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,947
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
the resources to investigate the financial history of every consenting adult in the biz would cost a bomb
Not really, and they wouldn't do that. They can get your financial records for less than the cost of a cup of coffee once they have a warrant, they do it all day long on child support cases which covers many more people than the adult industry.

The cost of the lawyer assigned to prosecute you is far higher than the cost of pulling banking or PayPal records. If the cost of the prosecutor doesn't stop them the cost of executing an electronic warrant sure as hell won't.

They would never get a warrant to go on an industry wide fishing expedition looking for violations. They would easily get a warrant when they already had found a client with a suspected escort and were trying to prove that particular case. The warrant would also cover your emails, text messages, etc.

Having established that a woman is an escort they would have no problem getting a warrant to find out who has been paying her through banking, PayPal, etc., as they have probable cause to suspect the transactions are crimes by the senders.
 

Titalian

No Regrets
Nov 27, 2012
8,488
9
0
Everywhere
Not really, and they wouldn't do that. They can get your financial records for less than the cost of a cup of coffee once they have a warrant, they do it all day long on child support cases which covers many more people than the adult industry.

The cost of the lawyer assigned to prosecute you is far higher than the cost of pulling banking or PayPal records. If the cost of the prosecutor doesn't stop them the cost of executing an electronic warrant sure as hell won't.

They would never get a warrant to go on an industry wide fishing expedition looking for violations. They would easily get a warrant when they already had found a client with a suspected escort and were trying to prove that particular case. The warrant would also cover your emails, text messages, etc.

Having established that a woman is an escort they would have no problem getting a warrant to find out who has been paying her through banking, PayPal, etc., as they have probable cause to suspect the transactions are crimes by the senders.
You know what Fugi, somehow we'll figure it out. This particular Trade is not going away very soon.
 

SkyRider

Banned
Mar 31, 2009
17,546
2
0
under C36 the girl is free to go

this allows her to target pimps and bad johns as she has committed no crime and can go to the cops for protection
It is my understanding that Bill C-36 will also target good Johns, even if the escort does not file a complaint. So, both good and bad Johns will be treated as criminals (collective punishment).

Question: Does Bill C-36 contain a mandatory "whistleblower" provision? For example, if you suspect that Larry down the street is paying for sexual services, do you have a legal obligation to report him to the police?
 

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,947
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
You know what Fugi, somehow we'll figure it out. This particular Trade is not going away very soon.
Absolutely. But we need to figure it out with our eyes open to the actual power C36 gives to the police. Your point that we do not know how heavy handed the enforcement will be is a good one (and likely answered differently in Toronto vs York Region vs Edmonton) the idea that it is somehow easy to avoid prosecution with a few winks and nudges, "the money was for the condkm", etc., is naive in the extreme, as is the notion that the police cannot track electronic money transfers.
 

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,947
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
Agreed. These electronic payment schemes seem a bit too convoluted to me, leaving a permanent electronic trail where cash would leave none.
And significantly the electronic trail allows police to prove the transaction after the fact, whereas with cash they would have to bust in and find it on the night table.

So by using PayPal or direct deposit you are making it easier for the police to prove guilt in the event that they find your name in an email conversation or an appointment book.

On a cash basis you could raise a reasonable doubt as to whether you went through with it or backed out, but with electronic proof of payment proving indisputably that you did pay for the service it is a bit more grim.

One thing people are not grokking is that the current laws all require you to be caught red handed, actually "found in" the in call by the police, not found to have previously been in.

But as I understand it under the new law since the transaction itself is now criminal after the fact evidence can convict you if they can prove the payment was for a sexual service.
 

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,947
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
your post screams "I haven't got a clue how a provider deals with her finances, communication or client list !!" lol ;)

you also, obviously, have no idea what an intelligent provider or business owner might change in order to comply with the changes to the law. :)
If any of that involves email, text messages, bank or PayPal transactions then the police will have it.

Note that under our current laws these things are all irrelevant to an investigation because the transaction itself is not currently illegal. Under c36 those things all become material evidence of a crime.

So I don't think the way providers CURRENTLY manage their communications or their appointments or their finances is very relevant. C36 will change how providers should do that, with a much heavier emphasis on anonymized methods.
 

Titalian

No Regrets
Nov 27, 2012
8,488
9
0
Everywhere
Absolutely. But we need to figure it out with our eyes open to the actual power C36 gives to the police. Your point that we do not know how heavy handed the enforcement will be is a good one (and likely answered differently in Toronto vs York Region vs Edmonton) the idea that it is somehow easy to avoid prosecution with a few winks and nudges, "the money was for the condkm", etc., is naive in the extreme, as is the notion that the police cannot track electronic money transfers.
As for me, I'll be counting on some of my well reviewed regulars, who have obviously prepared themselves, for this event. And I also believe that LE's main focus will still
be on trafficing and pimps.
 

D-Fens

Well-known member
Aug 12, 2006
1,195
91
48
As frustrating as it may be that clients aren't keeping abreast of c36, it's downright stupefying that some of the owners of major spas and agencies are still oblivious to the train coming down the tracks.
Most agencies and spa owners know about C-36 and have consulted with lawyers. There was a big meeting during the summer where all the major agencies got together with legal council.

Funny thing is they don't seem all that worried.
 

D-Fens

Well-known member
Aug 12, 2006
1,195
91
48
how is that done???


everyone moved to India???
You clearly haven't been paying attention...

The TERB server has been out of Canada for months... even when C-36 is law TERB will still be here.

It is illegal in Ireland to advertise sexual services, so advertisers just moved their servers off shore where Irish law does not apply.

Irish Anti-sex work lobbies have been trying for years to shut these sites down and have gotton nowhere. The same thing will happen here.
 
Ashley Madison
Toronto Escorts