Plante or Hasek?

unassuming

Well-known member
Feb 11, 2017
14,232
5,456
113
2 different style goalies.

Jacques Plante: perhaps the best stand up goalie of all, played the angles. He was perhaps the first net minder to stop puck behind net for his defence and the first to leave the crease to head man the puck.

Dominik Hasek: flop style , spent most of time lying on the ice hoping the puck would hit any body part


I can't choose
 
I wonder which genius pulled the trade that sent Hasek to Buffalo for
Stephane Beauregard? Now I know Befour was good but we're not comparing him To Plante now are we?

I can't decide either......Dead heat!
 
Jacques Plante: perhaps the best stand up goalie of all, played the angles. He was perhaps the first net minder to stop puck behind net for his defence and the first to leave the crease to head man the puck.

First goalie to wear the mask in games. Jacques Plante hands down.
 
First goalie to wear the mask in games. Jacques Plante hands down.

Jacques Plante was not the 1st goaltender to wear a mask in an NHL game.
 
Jacques Plante was not the 1st goaltender to wear a mask in an NHL game.

Who was then? Always thought it was him. Wikipedia says it was Plante, although some dude wore a football type facemask for a game or 2 in 1930s cuz he had a broken nose...when that healed he dropped it. Anyhow, such different eras, curved sticks and composite sticks and bigger faster players, etc. Hasek though took a pathetic offensive team to the Stanley cup in 1999. He carried those buffalo teams. Plante played for some offensive juggernauts in Montreal and a good team in St Louis...
 
Who was then? Always thought it was him.

"Jacques Plante
It was not until 1959 that a goaltender wore a mask full-time. On November 1, 1959, in the first period of a game between the Montreal Canadiens and New York Rangers of the National Hockey League (NHL) at Madison Square Garden, Canadiens goaltender Jacques Plante was struck in the face by a shot from Andy Bathgate."

"Plante subsequently designed his own and other goaltenders' masks.[38] He was not the first NHL goaltender known to wear a face mask. Montreal Maroons' Clint Benedict wore a crude leather version in 1930 to protect a broken nose, but Plante introduced the mask as everyday equipment, and it is now mandatory equipment for goaltenders.[39]"
 
Jacques Plante.

He revolutionalized the position. He was more technically sound and a student of the game. He influenced many, many goalies. Both won MVPs.
 
Jacques Plante.

He revolutionalized the position. He was more technically sound and a student of the game. He influenced many, many goalies. Both won MVPs.

Plante was also one of the first goalies to leave the crease to challenge the shooter, a revolutionary move at that time. Also, one of the first to go behind his net to cut off and stop shots from opposing defencemen. To drive the officials crazy, he used to raise his arm to indicate icing violations.
 
Plante was also one of the first goalies to leave the crease to challenge the shooter, a revolutionary move at that time. Also, one of the first to go behind his net to cut off and stop shots from opposing defencemen. To drive the officials crazy, he used to raise his arm to indicate icing violations.
Yup. All ways that he revolutionalized the position aside from the mask. The most impactful goalie ever.