Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: To Speedo
onthebottom said:
So you wouldn't consider the invasion of Austria or Czech. to be the beginning of WWII? Bit Anglo centric of you isn't it. My point was, that the lesson of WWII (in the European theater) was that everyone was late.
I think you will see, after Iraq, another isolationist movement in the US. Not as drastic as after WWI, the world is a much smaller place now and the threats are different, but I think Americans are trying to figure out why they have tens or hundreds of thousands of troops in Europe and Asia defending Europeans and Asians.
OTB
"Anglo centric". My but you are grasping at straws.
Austria went willingly and the Czech's were political pawns, hope that in giving Hitler his "one time show of power" would stop his bad behaviour, much like why they got the Olympics. A bad decision by Neville Chamberlain, (who is lucky that Churchill so overwhelms British politics of that era or Chamberlain would be renoun for being the idiot he was), in assuming that he could trust Hitler when he said, "Neville, trust me I won't cum in your mouth."
To answer your question though. The World War did not start with the Czech invasion because at that point the only countries involved were Germany and Czechoslovakia with Stalin turning his back. At that point it was still a 'local issue'. Once England, France, Germany, Russia, Italy etc. get into the game then it is not just a war but a category World War.
Your point about 'late' is marginally valid in that the world did not do much to control the situation, (certainly Hitler was egged on by the fact that the US indicated they would remain neutral hard to say what he would have done had the US said "Nuh uh uh! No invading or we'll re-tool Detroit and wipe the floor with you Dolphy). However when we speak of late it is more to the point of "now that we are clearly fighting a world war maybe you want to come lend a hand?"
I personally find the "US experience of WW1" as any sort of cause a laughable rationalization. The US was hardly involved directly in WW1 for a year in total and even then it was based more on fear that France and England were going to get all the goodies after the Kaiser was defeated than coming out to assist. But then again as I said before there is a misconception that WW2 and WW1 are related and excepting some of the punitive war reparations that contributed to Germany being in economic turmoil for the next 15 years there is little to compare the administration and motivation behind WW1 and WW2. Regardless the ‘isolationism’ was a policy pre-WW1 in the US and certainly not a response to their involvement in the so called ‘Great War’.
Could the US go back to an isolationist policy as you suggest? Possibly. It is interesting the way you phrase it though as if the US has been ever responding to requests to put troops in the Philippines, Japan, Germany etc. whereas in fact the troops were basically just left behind from previous actions only without the moniker ‘occupier’. Who else in the world, excepting Russia back in its prime, has its own military bases in other countries these days? I think it is a little self serving to suggest that the US is out there benevolently protecting the interests of these countries.
Besides if the US foreign action were really about doing the right thing North Korea is the current hot spot. Jong Ill has perpetrated atrocities upon his people at least as worse and on a far greater scale than Hussein could have imagined. North Korea remains a far greater risk both to the region, the world community and the US economically than Iraq ever could be and unlike Iraq that had no WMD and little else North Korea certainly has weapons of ‘massive’ destruction if not some forms of WMD. Of course that would mean taking on a capable enemy and Bush is quite aware that North Korea is no Iraq.
However all of that is moot. You have hit on the big issue with respect to isolation and that is regardless of whether there was justification or not to be in Iraq will the US public have the stomach for anymore forays into the world given that the Iraq war sequel has not been nearly as much fun as the first one and that the world has not embraced the effort. It matters little whether their perception is myopic and self centred or not, it is their perception and right now I can only imagine the harsh taste of bile that rises up in the average American’s mouth when he considers Iraq and whether or not it is worth the effort.
Maybe it would be good for both the world and for the US to step back and realize that;
A: the world does not need the US to behave like the enforcer big brother.
B: there are times it is nice to be able to call up your big brother to lend a hand.
However I am just not certain that given the current multi-national economic system that it is truly possible for the US to simply withdraw.
T.