Philippians Join the LCN

anyone who designates these nations as cowardly has got to be joking, the Spanish for example was a nation where over 90% of the population were against their country's involvement, yet the government decides to go ahead and send troops. Attacks take place in Madrid and the same government tries emphatically to bl to blame the wrong guys and lie to its people and as a payback the people in a true democratic fashion let the government have it and tossed them out, now at least Spain has a government elected by the majority unlike a certain country whose leader wasnt elected by the majority hmmmm no prize for this one boys and girls if you can guess who :)
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: To Speedo

Talerion said:
England declared war a few days after Germany invaded Poland so sometime early in September 1939. Canada had obtained full independence in these types of matters following WW1 lead and declared war on Germany also in early September 1939 but a few days after GB.

The US declared war on Japan the day following the attack on Pearl Harbour December 8, 1941, and then on Germany three days later following Germany's declaration of war on the US and not in unison with their action against Japan as is commonly mistaken.

So to answer your question the war started September 1939 and the US, despite the pleading of England and the rest of Europe, showed up a little two years after the fact.

World War 2 is a bit easier since it was a 'world' scenario rather quickly. WW1 started off locally with the assasination of Archduke Ferdinand by a Serb, (man those guys are always causing problems), resulting in various single declarations of war in a domino effect until German declares war on France which because of a treaty between GB and France, GB declares war on Germany. Canada declared war on Germany hours following GB.

Thus by August 1914 the players are decided.

As in WW2 the US decides to sit back and watch, (well I suppose in fact WW2 was much like WW1 in this matter), and takes a stance of neutrality. April 1917 the US declares war on Germany. November 1918 WW1 end.

I suppose in fairness WW1 was a little more ambiguous in that it isn't quite as easy to point out the obvious evil that was present. Kaiser Wilhelm may not have been a nice guy but he was no Adolph. Also the US made efforts during WW1 to provide war material to the allies via Canada even though such actions would be considered contrary to their stance of neutrality.


So to answer your two questions, (the second being more subtle in the hopes of saying that while not as late as the US entering the war, Canada did so under obligation);

1. The US showed up quite late in WW1, nearly at the end in point of fact, and a full two years late in WW2. In both cases showing up after the war had been acknowledged as turned. Again as I indicated before this is not to suggest that the US involvement did not greatly hurry the end in either case and also in the case of WW2 given the German heavy water experiments it is possible that the first nucleur bomb may have had a swastica stamped on it.

2. While Canada indeed was obliged to follow suit with Britain in WW1, (although there was no question of this happening anyway following their efforts in the Boer War), this obligation ended at the end of WW1 and as such their entrance into WW2 was completely voluntary.


Does that answer your question?


T.

So you wouldn't consider the invasion of Austria or Czech. to be the beginning of WWII? Bit Anglo centric of you isn't it. My point was, that the lesson of WWII (in the European theater) was that everyone was late. The UK and France waited much to long to thwart German aggression and the world paid the price. With the horrors of WWI fresh in their minds both European powers were willing to do almost anything to avoid another war with Germany - this weakness of course worsened the eventual war. America, after it's WWI experience isolated itself not wanting to loose more American lives for Europe’s problems. Both were very bad decisions.

I think you will see, after Iraq, another isolationist movement in the US. Not as drastic as after WWI, the world is a much smaller place now and the threats are different, but I think Americans are trying to figure out why they have tens or hundreds of thousands of troops in Europe and Asia defending Europeans and Asians.

OTB
 
oldjones said:
They never actually left after seizing the colony from Spain back in 1898 did they? In spite of the Filipinos' war of independence, the US didn't give the colony its freedom until after WWII, I believe. Just a few more than 51 keeping the place "safe" ever since.

We did do a major withdrawal after the PI government tried to extort a huge sum out of the Navy for Subic, don't remember how long ago that was, being old it's all starting to blur together.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
We did do a major withdrawal after the PI government tried to extort a huge sum out of the Navy for Subic, don't remember how long ago that was, being old it's all starting to blur together.

OTB
As I understand it, the Phillipine Senate just rejected the lease terms offered. Eviction I think it's called.

Now about those squatters at Guantanamo…. Another place the US has held onto since grabbing it (on the pretext of terrorism, no less) in 1898.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: To Speedo

onthebottom said:
So you wouldn't consider the invasion of Austria or Czech. to be the beginning of WWII? Bit Anglo centric of you isn't it. My point was, that the lesson of WWII (in the European theater) was that everyone was late.
…edit…OTB
I must have missed the shooting involved in those invasions you're suggesting the 'non-Anglo-centric' date the start of the war from. Actually I wasn't even born, but the undoubtedly Anglo-centric histories I've read, and documentaries I've seen don't seem to mention it either. Just rigged plebescites, and cheering partisan crowds welcoming the Germans. Isn't shooting kind of a sine qua non of a war these days?

By all means excuse the US by pointing out that they weren't alone—at least until 1939— in underestimating the danger Germany posed, but the "bit Anglo-centric of you" comment was just snide.

Takes one to know one, as we said in my school days, so I know. BTW, when do US-centric histories say WW2 started?
 
oldjones said:
As I understand it, the Phillipine Senate just rejected the lease terms offered. Eviction I think it's called.

Now about those squatters at Guantanamo…. Another place the US has held onto since grabbing it (on the pretext of terrorism, no less) in 1898.

I think that's called a lease?

OTB
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: To Speedo

oldjones said:
I must have missed the shooting involved in those invasions you're suggesting the 'non-Anglo-centric' date the start of the war from. Actually I wasn't even born, but the undoubtedly Anglo-centric histories I've read, and documentaries I've seen don't seem to mention it either. Just rigged plebescites, and cheering partisan crowds welcoming the Germans. Isn't shooting kind of a sine qua non of a war these days?

By all means excuse the US by pointing out that they weren't alone—at least until 1939— in underestimating the danger Germany posed, but the "bit Anglo-centric of you" comment was just snide.

Takes one to know one, as we said in my school days, so I know. BTW, when do US-centric histories say WW2 started?

At the end of WWI with reparations that created the environment for WWII.

I don't think the crowds were cheering in Czech, Austria perhaps but by then the Germans had broken so many of their obligations at the end of WWI that the steamroller had already started.

You should also note that the UK was getting it's *ss kicked all over North Africa before this late entrant sent it tanks (300) that it was using to train our own forces with. The Brits didn't really have much success until the US entered the war, but that's just Churchill's view, what would he know after all....

If you'd like to know a little more about this subject I suggest you read "The Gathering Storm" by Churchill - the failures of all involved on the Allied side are well documented (Britons head-in-sand, French arrogance and incompetence, American Isolation). It's the first in a series of 6 books that are each about 800 pages, when you're done then we can talk.

OTB
 
There is also a school of thought that holds with the opinion that the fate of Germany was sealed the minute they decided to turn on the USSR and that defeat was assured from that moment on (with or without involvement of the Americans).

But what has any of this to do with your branding of nations as "cowering" becuase they did not fall in line with US foriegn policy? A while ago you brought up the idea that the leak of the recent report critical of US intellgence was the work of some junior staff members and therefore should be dismissed.

It seems now that these junior staff members were simply providing an "advance" of the real report which shows that the US intelligence gathering community was grossly incorrect in thier assumption that Iraq had stockpiled weapons of mass distruction.

League of Cowering Nations? C'mon, it seems obvious that the US was in the wrong to attack Iraq for the reasons publicly stated.
 
quick check of facts

onthebottom said:
You should also note that the UK was getting it's *ss kicked all over North Africa before this late entrant sent it tanks (300) that it was using to train our own forces with. The Brits didn't really have much success until the US entered the war, but that's just Churchill's view, what would he know after all...

Better check your facts first, OTB. Montgomery's Eighth Army, through Operation Bertram and Lightfoot, slammed the Afrika Korps at the Battle of El Alamein. Yes, much of it had to do with the 300 Sherman tanks, no question, but there's much more to it than that.

British intelligence agents were hugely successful in baiting Rommel through false intelligence, making him believe that the British weren't even close to being ready for an assault. The false message read,
"Have confirmed message from reliablest source Eighth Army plan to make final stand in battle for Egypt at Alam Halfa. They are still awaiting reinforcements and are not yet ready for more than a makeshift defence."
(Brown, Bodyguard of Lies, 1976, p. 113)
 
OTB, are you honestly comparing 2003/04 Iraq to 1938/39 Germany in terms of military might (global danger) and making that the basis of your argument for the USA's pre-emptive strike? You got to be kidding me. Iraq couldn't put a scud missile on Tel Aviv and could easily be contained whereas Germany was the big bully on the block that everyone was afraid of in 1939.

In actual fact N. Korea could be more accurately compared to 1938/39 Germany but you don't see the US doing anything about that threat. Why is that OTB? It's coz it has nothing to do with WMD and the rest of that garbage you are spewing and you are just allowing the propaganda of fear to sabotage your intellect. Talk about getting your strings pulled by the Republican administration.
 
lenharper said:
There is also a school of thought that holds with the opinion that the fate of Germany was sealed the minute they decided to turn on the USSR and that defeat was assured from that moment on (with or without involvement of the Americans).

Two fronts sealed Germany's fate, there just would not have been two fronts without the US (UK could never have invaded Europe alone). I would never minimize the USSR contribution or sacrifice.

lenharper said:

But what has any of this to do with your branding of nations as "cowering" because they did not fall in line with US foriegn policy? A while ago you brought up the idea that the leak of the recent report critical of US intellgence was the work of some junior staff members and therefore should be dismissed. ).

I was responding to standard US late to WWII nonsense.

I was making no such assertion, what I was saying is that it's cowering to cut and run because one truck driver gets nabbed. I was in no way referring to Canada.

OTB
 
Re: quick check of facts

happygrump said:
Better check your facts first, OTB. Montgomery's Eighth Army, through Operation Bertram and Lightfoot, slammed the Afrika Korps at the Battle of El Alamein. Yes, much of it had to do with the 300 Sherman tanks, no question, but there's much more to it than that.

British intelligence agents were hugely successful in baiting Rommel through false intelligence, making him believe that the British weren't even close to being ready for an assault. The false message read,(Brown, Bodyguard of Lies, 1976, p. 113)

I think our statements say the same thing, when Montgomery took charge and the US tanks were deployed the UK did very well in North Africa, even better when the US joined in there and in Italy.

Before those 300 Shermans arrived however it was a very different story.

OTB
 
The_Jaded_One said:
OTB, are you honestly comparing 2003/04 Iraq to 1938/39 Germany in terms of military might (global danger) and making that the basis of your argument for the USA's pre-emptive strike? You got to be kidding me. Iraq couldn't put a scud missile on Tel Aviv and could easily be contained whereas Germany was the big bully on the block that everyone was afraid of in 1939.

No of course not, I was responding to the typical "US was late to WWII" comment that flourishes every 17 days on these threads. Read the whole thing and you will see.

The_Jaded_One said:

In actual fact N. Korea could be more accurately compared to 1938/39 Germany but you don't see the US doing anything about that threat. Why is that OTB? It's coz it has nothing to do with WMD and the rest of that garbage you are spewing and you are just allowing the propaganda of fear to sabotage your intellect. Talk about getting your strings pulled by the Republican administration.

bla bla bla, I thought we were in multilateral negotiations on the issue, isn't that what you'd have us do? The N. Koreans would love bilateral talks with the US but the US has pushed back. If these continue to fail (and China were to agree, a bit if) then sanctions would be the next step.... You see how it works now. And if North Korea would ignore sanctions for 14 years then....

Perhaps Canada should lead on this issue, oh I'm sorry I forgot as the world's "honest broker" you don't lead on anything, you throw all your passes on Monday morning.

I think you are giving North Korea too much credit, at least Germany could feed its people.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I think you are giving North Korea too much credit, at least Germany could feed its people.

I would say a country with nukes that can't feed its people is very dangerous. The thing is the whole WMD is a red herring. The USA going to war in Iraq had everything to do with financial self-interests and nothing to do with self-defence.

Where would we be w/o the good ol' USA saving the world from destruction? hahaha. I can't believe anyone in today's global age of media can buy into that crap. I guess you believe what you want to believe and you need to believe the USA is the greatest nation on the face of the earth and you are a small part of that.
 
Re: Re: quick check of facts

onthebottom said:
I think our statements say the same thing, when Montgomery took charge and the US tanks were deployed the UK did very well in North Africa, even better when the US joined in there and in Italy.

Before those 300 Shermans arrived however it was a very different story.

OTB

Well, some of this is half-correct, at any rate.

In fact it was a Commonwealth army - no Shermans - that fought a decisive defensive war during the First Battle of El Alamein in July of 1942. There were running counter-attacks between Achinleck and Rommel for the rest of the summer, but even as the 8th army was exhausted, the German army was hopelessly over-extended. Rommel's pleas to Berlin went unheeded as Hilter was puhsing all of his resources towards the Eastern Front.

When the Americans did arrive in September, they found the Allies in strongly defended positions and the German army near collapse. On top of which all of this occurs post-Enigma so the Allies had detailed information on Axis plans. Both the Second Battle of El Alamein and Operation Torch in October and November of that year sealed the deal.

Was the Commonwealth Army in bad shape at the end of the summer of 1942? Yes, but so was the Afrika Corps. What was a emerging was a stalemate, not defeat. The American arrival tipped the scales.

PS - Perhaps instead of being snooty about reading Churchill, you should think about undating your sources, hmmmm?

PPs - I'm still killing myself laughing about the "Phillipians."
 
The_Jaded_One said:
I would say a country with nukes that can't feed its people is very dangerous. The thing is the whole WMD is a red herring. The USA going to war in Iraq had everything to do with financial self-interests and nothing to do with self-defence.

Opinion, wrong but everyone has an opinion.

The_Jaded_One said:

Where would we be w/o the good ol' USA saving the world from destruction? hahaha. I can't believe anyone in today's global age of media can buy into that crap. I guess you believe what you want to believe and you need to believe the USA is the greatest nation on the face of the earth and you are a small part of that.

Wait a minute, we're late to Europe in WWII but early every other time? I'd be quite happy if we pull the legions home after Iraq and watch for a while.

OTB
 
Re: Re: Re: quick check of facts

Drunken Master said:
Well, some of this is half-correct, at any rate.

In fact it was a Commonwealth army - no Shermans - that fought a decisive defensive war during the First Battle of El Alamein in July of 1942. There were running counter-attacks between Achinleck and Rommel for the rest of the summer, but even as the 8th army was exhausted, the German army was hopelessly over-extended. Rommel's pleas to Berlin went unheeded as Hilter was puhsing all of his resources towards the Eastern Front.

When the Americans did arrive in September, they found the Allies in strongly defended positions and the German army near collapse. On top of which all of this occurs post-Enigma so the Allies had detailed information on Axis plans. Both the Second Battle of El Alamein and Operation Torch in October and November of that year sealed the deal.

Was the Commonwealth Army in bad shape at the end of the summer of 1942? Yes, but so was the Afrika Corps. What was a emerging was a stalemate, not defeat. The American arrival tipped the scales.

PS - Perhaps instead of being snooty about reading Churchill, you should think about undating your sources, hmmmm?

I think a first person account from the guy running the war is not bad, and how many WWII books does a guy really want to read. I was returning fire on the snootiness but thanks for the sensitivity training.

Drunken Master said:

PPs - I'm still killing myself laughing about the "Phillipians."

Yeah, it was dumb and you are obviously easily amused, not that that's a bad thing.

OTB
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: quick check of facts

onthebottom said:
I was returning fire on the snootiness but thanks for the sensitivity training.

Any time! Oh, and I agree, Churchill's an excellent writer. His proximity to the events can, though, cloud his judgement.


Yeah, it was dumb and you are obviously easily amused, not that that's a bad thing.

OTB

Yes, it is. Being easily amused is like being a cheap drunk. The good things in life don't end up costing you very much.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: To Speedo

onthebottom said:
So you wouldn't consider the invasion of Austria or Czech. to be the beginning of WWII? Bit Anglo centric of you isn't it. My point was, that the lesson of WWII (in the European theater) was that everyone was late.

I think you will see, after Iraq, another isolationist movement in the US. Not as drastic as after WWI, the world is a much smaller place now and the threats are different, but I think Americans are trying to figure out why they have tens or hundreds of thousands of troops in Europe and Asia defending Europeans and Asians.

OTB

"Anglo centric". My but you are grasping at straws.

Austria went willingly and the Czech's were political pawns, hope that in giving Hitler his "one time show of power" would stop his bad behaviour, much like why they got the Olympics. A bad decision by Neville Chamberlain, (who is lucky that Churchill so overwhelms British politics of that era or Chamberlain would be renoun for being the idiot he was), in assuming that he could trust Hitler when he said, "Neville, trust me I won't cum in your mouth."

To answer your question though. The World War did not start with the Czech invasion because at that point the only countries involved were Germany and Czechoslovakia with Stalin turning his back. At that point it was still a 'local issue'. Once England, France, Germany, Russia, Italy etc. get into the game then it is not just a war but a category World War.

Your point about 'late' is marginally valid in that the world did not do much to control the situation, (certainly Hitler was egged on by the fact that the US indicated they would remain neutral hard to say what he would have done had the US said "Nuh uh uh! No invading or we'll re-tool Detroit and wipe the floor with you Dolphy). However when we speak of late it is more to the point of "now that we are clearly fighting a world war maybe you want to come lend a hand?"

I personally find the "US experience of WW1" as any sort of cause a laughable rationalization. The US was hardly involved directly in WW1 for a year in total and even then it was based more on fear that France and England were going to get all the goodies after the Kaiser was defeated than coming out to assist. But then again as I said before there is a misconception that WW2 and WW1 are related and excepting some of the punitive war reparations that contributed to Germany being in economic turmoil for the next 15 years there is little to compare the administration and motivation behind WW1 and WW2. Regardless the ‘isolationism’ was a policy pre-WW1 in the US and certainly not a response to their involvement in the so called ‘Great War’.


Could the US go back to an isolationist policy as you suggest? Possibly. It is interesting the way you phrase it though as if the US has been ever responding to requests to put troops in the Philippines, Japan, Germany etc. whereas in fact the troops were basically just left behind from previous actions only without the moniker ‘occupier’. Who else in the world, excepting Russia back in its prime, has its own military bases in other countries these days? I think it is a little self serving to suggest that the US is out there benevolently protecting the interests of these countries.

Besides if the US foreign action were really about doing the right thing North Korea is the current hot spot. Jong Ill has perpetrated atrocities upon his people at least as worse and on a far greater scale than Hussein could have imagined. North Korea remains a far greater risk both to the region, the world community and the US economically than Iraq ever could be and unlike Iraq that had no WMD and little else North Korea certainly has weapons of ‘massive’ destruction if not some forms of WMD. Of course that would mean taking on a capable enemy and Bush is quite aware that North Korea is no Iraq.

However all of that is moot. You have hit on the big issue with respect to isolation and that is regardless of whether there was justification or not to be in Iraq will the US public have the stomach for anymore forays into the world given that the Iraq war sequel has not been nearly as much fun as the first one and that the world has not embraced the effort. It matters little whether their perception is myopic and self centred or not, it is their perception and right now I can only imagine the harsh taste of bile that rises up in the average American’s mouth when he considers Iraq and whether or not it is worth the effort.

Maybe it would be good for both the world and for the US to step back and realize that;

A: the world does not need the US to behave like the enforcer big brother.

B: there are times it is nice to be able to call up your big brother to lend a hand.


However I am just not certain that given the current multi-national economic system that it is truly possible for the US to simply withdraw.


T.