Pay for garbage collectors

someone said:
One again, you show a complete misunderstanding of the issues. Fuji is undoubtedly referring to the competitive outcome where, at the marginal, the last worker hired is just getting his reservation wage (e.g. “lowest wage at which qualified people would accept the job”). At the same time, the firms are paying the highest wages they are willing to pay for that marginal worker. Thus, it is both "lowest an employer can get away with" and "the highest a worker could get" at the margin. This outcome is Pareto Efficient. Intramarginal workers are getting rents. Any other wage results in unemployment where other workers would be willing to work if the wage was a lower and firms would be willing to hire the additional workers. I will not bother with the rest of your post as it just follows from this basic misunderstanding of yours. There is a much better way you could debate Fuji but I very much doubt you will hit on it as it likely would not be on the NDP website.
Thanks for butting in, but I'd rather let fuji tell me what he's "undoubtedly referring to", as you put it so patronizingly.He seems quite able to express himself without the pompous jargon and insult.
 
oldjones said:
Thanks for butting in, but I'd rather let fuji tell me what he's "undoubtedly referring to", as you put it so patronizingly.He seems quite able to express himself without the pompous jargon and insult.

No, he more or less has it, I just try and avoid the jargon because not many people understand what "pareto efficient" is, but most people would agree that it's a good thing if you can make someone better off without making anybody else worse off (which is what pareto efficient means).
 
fuji said:
No, he more or less has it, I just try and avoid the jargon because not many people understand what "pareto efficient" is, but most people would agree that it's a good thing if you can make someone better off without making anybody else worse off (which is what pareto efficient means).



HaHaHaHaHa!!!!!!

Well put Fuji.
 
Hands up all who do.

Do we crash the thread here on the Scylla of jargon, or must poor someone endure the Charybdis of less learned utterances?

Worth considering while the economic theorists check in.
 
Last edited:
oldjones said:
Hands up all who do.

Do we crash the thread here on the Scylla of jargon, or must poor someone endure the Charybdis less learned utterances?

Worth considering while the economic theorists check in.
One again you have nothing useful to contribute. Even if you did not understand what Pareto meant and did not bother to take 2 seconds to do a search, the meaning of my post was pretty clear.
 
oldjones said:
Hands up all who do.

Do we crash the thread here on the Scylla of jargon, or must poor someone endure the Charybdis less learned utterances?

Worth considering while the economic theorists check in.

Come on OJ, who wrote that for you.
 
Toke said:
Okay, I'll be harsh...
To the striking workers, "How much do you want to be paid to pick up trash?"

That is not harsh

Harsh would to say your new wage is $15 / hr , you get 7 sick days a year you can not bank them & you have a job as long as you do your job well.
Head counts will be culled to an efficient level
Your union will pay for full page ads in all four newspapers & apologize to the residents of Toronto for putting them through this unpleasantness
Take it or leave it. If the final offer is not accepted, we will initiate immediate and permanent outsourcing of this work

A more reasonable approach would be
Your new wage is 5% above the market value of the competition, with raises of 1%, 1.5% and 2% over the next three years, you get 10 sick days a year you can not bank them & we will commit not to outsource this work for the duration of the contract & we commit to maintain head counts at the current level

Please consider this offer, you are more than welcome to submit a counter-proposal within a week, however significant deviations from this offer will be rejected and we will initiate immediate and permanent outsourcing of this work
 
JohnLarue said:
That is not harsh

Harsh would to say your new wage is $15 / hr , you get 7 sick days a year you can not bank them & you have a job as long as you do your job well.
Head counts will be culled to an efficient level
Your union will pay for full page ads in all four newspapers & apologize to the residents of Toronto for putting them through this unpleasantness
Take it or leave it. If the final offer is not accepted, we will initiate immediate and permanent outsourcing of this work

A more reasonable approach would be
Your new wage is 5% above the market value of the competition, with raises of 1%, 1.5% and 2% over the next three years, you get 10 sick days a year you can not bank them & we will commit not to outsource this work for the duration of the contract & we commit to maintain head counts at the current level

Please consider this offer, you are more than welcome to submit a counter-proposal within a week, however significant deviations from this offer will be rejected and we will initiate immediate and permanent outsourcing of this work

I like it, but something tells me 3 people don't.
 
addicted2whiskey said:
.

My ex-gf worked for the City in a mgmt position and left for greener pastures (and also because she wanted more of a challenge)… the things she told me were absolutely mind-boggling and atrocious for a progressive City like Toronto with respect to their recruitment and selection of staff!
Can you share? Sounds juicy.
 
fuji said:
That




There's no evidence of any private monopolies developing in garbage collection. In fact just the opposite--in areas where collection is private, such as other cities in Ontario, or pickup of commercial and industrial waste, there are many firms competing for the business.

Garbage collection in NYC is controlled by the mob, it is widely believed. Not to much competition.
 
chiller_boy said:
Garbage collection in NYC is controlled by the mob, it is widely believed. Not to much competition.[/QUOTE

Tell me if I'm wrong but NYC is not in Ontario.

There are some 800 lb gorillas in the business but enough medium to small companies that would make for some interesting bidding wars. Remember the one that the unions were so threatened by they had to picket them and threatened business disruption, if they did something they weren't doing.
 
chiller_boy said:
Garbage collection in NYC is controlled by the mob, it is widely believed. Not to much competition.

Collection should be handled by the city. I'm not for contracting out. I'm actually for the city regulating many services. However, I am not for city-paid workers striking. You can't have the security that comes with a government position, but have a union to bully that same employer when required.
 
fuji said:
No, he more or less has it, I just try and avoid the jargon because not many people understand what "pareto efficient" is, but most people would agree that it's a good thing if you can make someone better off without making anybody else worse off (which is what pareto efficient means).
Thanks for adding the definition. So with reference to rthe issues in the current strike, how does the city's oroginal 'final' offer—the one the workers walked out over—to renege on their contract to pay out banked sickdays stack up in Pareto efficiency?
 
oldjones said:
Thanks for adding the definition. So with reference to rthe issues in the current strike, how does the city's oroginal 'final' offer*the one the workers walked out over*to renege on their contract to pay out banked sickdays stack up in Pareto efficiency?

Not very well, presumably, although almost certainly more pareto efficient than the union's offer.

The issue is that the union has a monopoly on garbage collection and so it is almost certainly extracting rents from the city. It is almost certainly the case that this is resulting in inefficiencies--say two people doing a job that could be done by one. If that is the case then putting that one person to work doing something productive creates more stuff, and the extra goods produced could be used to make somebody better off without making anybody worse off.

Were we to have a competitive situation, even if it was two unionized alternatives, then things would tend to be more pareto efficient. If you figure the city's offer is nearer what you would see in a competitive situation you can guess that it's likely more pareto efficient than the union offer.

That said labour relations bargaining is all about achieving pareto efficiency. A common strategy is to offer two alternatives to the union that are of equal cost to the city, in the hopes that the union values one of them more. In that case the union can be made better off without making the city worse off, and so on.
 
Mrbig1949 said:
Sometimes without high levels of education. Just because you have an education and you don't make more you are living in some sort of dream world if you think that is going to change.

Look at NHL hockey players. No education in most cases and high wages. Oh that is because they have talent, bull shit, Gordie Howe never made any real money. It is because Ted Lindsay and some others organized a UNION the NHLPA.

MOST Pro athletes in the Major sports MLB NBA NHL NFL are MILLIONAIRES.Even if you are making 1.5 mill you are in that class.Most MLB NHL players do not go to University College etc. They come up from the Minors NBA NFL players do go to Univ-College but most take basket weaving 101 etc because they know they will be playing Pro someday.

The poor CFL NO BODY makes even CLOSE to a mill!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
fuji said:
Not very well, presumably, although almost certainly more pareto efficient than the union's offer.

The issue is that the union has a monopoly on garbage collection and so it is almost certainly extracting rents from the city. It is almost certainly the case that this is resulting in inefficiencies--say two people doing a job that could be done by one. If that is the case then putting that one person to work doing something productive creates more stuff, and the extra goods produced could be used to make somebody better off without making anybody worse off.

Were we to have a competitive situation, even if it was two unionized alternatives, then things would tend to be more pareto efficient. If you figure the city's offer is nearer what you would see in a competitive situation you can guess that it's likely more pareto efficient than the union offer.

That said labour relations bargaining is all about achieving pareto efficiency. A common strategy is to offer two alternatives to the union that are of equal cost to the city, in the hopes that the union values one of them more. In that case the union can be made better off without making the city worse off, and so on.
Just to add to your point, the current situation is not PE as there are still gains from gains from trade. Assuming the city has already hired workers up to the point where the marginal benefit of their work is equal to it marginal cost, lowering the cost of hiring new workers (e.g. by getting rid of the sick day thing for new workers) would allow the city to hire more workers. The benefits of the new workers would be less than the cost. Thus, both the new workers and the city would be better off. I am in a bit of a hurry now but I checked and Wikipedia has decent simple explanation for the cast of monopoly (which is what a union is in the labour market). See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_efficiency

Also related, the idea of a dead weight loss: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deadweight_loss

Of course if the city has already hired more workers than is efficient (as you suggest) and their marginal benefit is less than their marginal cost, the current situation is even more inefficient.